UGO: Who will win? Just how much do we know? This feature will answers all your questions about Project Natal and Project Move with everything we know so far.
I think Project Natal has the upper hand is sales but both won't do as well as Sony or Microsoft hoped.
I don't understand. Why does there only have to be one? Right now, I don't know many people that are interested in either.
Only fanboys will say there only has to be one lol
This isn't the same as the BluRay vs HD-DVD war where there really had to only be one. Two different systems, two different styles of control, both can thrive.
I think Natals smoke a mirrors will sell more but there is no doubt the hardcore gamers and those who know what they are buying will go for Move. Just imagine you don't know about games and you see something similar to how Wii seems to work and than you see a MS advert telling you (no more controllers now you are IN the game wooooooowowoowoww) What would you go for? Casual gamers will not think oh there are no buttons how the hell will I be able to do some of the things I can do with the Move?
One for each console. But no one will get either, lol. Problem solved.
the 2 people the disagreed will buy them, geez :D
Not if that $150 is true I still think both will do ok
Probably Natal sells better if there is cheap hardware, but nobody will buy games. Hardcore players using move might buy games.
there can only be 1? thats like saying there can only be one console on the market.clearly not the case, anymore, at least.with combined sales of 100 million+ this gen.you can bet that there will be owners of all consoles who will buy both peripherals.
I agree... No way in hell will Move have the same impact Natal has and will get. Move doesn't offer anything new people have not already seen. Expect many articles leading up to E3 that suggests Move is on the same level as Natal when it comes to Tech, Popular opinion, mass appeal, developer support, something new, Unique Experiences. Already to or three articles either slamming Natal or making Move seem on the same playing field as Natal all in response to the: "Why is Microsoft visiting Kojima Productions?" Due to the meeting most likely is related to Natal on some level.
how does move not offer anything new ? i never understand that argument bloody fanboys!!! there are enought devs that say both offer new things to games. personally i would love natal if it was like its being hyped by the media to be something like virtual reality where your in the game but its not its an eyetoy 2.5 do these fanboys have no sense.
"Move doesn't offer anything new people have not already seen." neither does Natal. voice operation, UI control, facial recognition...all of these are already possible with the PSEye. however, with the Move you get something that you can't possibly get with Natal the way the developers intended you to use it.....physical feedback.
I suppose the headline is just for fun, comparisons are fine but really I just can't get over how fanboyish it all sounds. "There Can Be Only One" -yeah, like theres only "one" home console, and of course people would be estastic if we had: one tv manufaturer one car model one cell phone service one restaurant chain one movie studio one news channel one govt official who makes laws I had a weird thought, maybe people like variety and might actually enjoy both....it might also be OK to just like one or the other and decide to buy just one of them without any hate for the other. JOY
will sell better than Move. I mean wow? My money is on Move, since its actually real, shown to the public, and has demo's running. My money isn't on Peter Monelux changing the way everyone games for the rest of our lives... My money isn't on Ricochet. Not buying move, because its a gimmick. Sony has had gimmicks in the past, and will continue to do so. One thing for sure, Natal is the biggest thing for the 360. Its not a gimmick for MS, its their xbox720. Its been the biggest news since e3. And anyone anyone has seen on this site...is ricochet. God damn thats good marketing MS. Ketchup Popsicle to a woman in white gloves! People would rather empty dreams to sell more than Sony at this point, because they ignore investing into actual content like game studios for their customers. Glad to be in the neither camp. I workout to workout, not play games.
There can be only one just like PS3 Sixaxis motion vs Nintendo Wiimote motion. There can be only one like Move motion vs Natal motion. Just saying.
Are we talking about sales, quality of gameplay, price war, nuber of had core, nunber of casuals, number of systems they move, ...? What? And why must there be only one? This article should not have been approved is the answer.
how about we stop compaing these two great systems? For once, let us have peace... Natal will appeal to different rich gamers, and move will appeal to other gamers
Why can't there be two?
Because the Title is flamebait. On top of that Move and Natal are actually pretty different despite both being motion based. Why must there be one when we can enjoy both? Besides, there is no motivation if there is no competition. Oh, my favorite part: "Just how much do we know?" We've known pretty much the same thing for a long time now and many articles have tried to draw the same conclusions on seemingly the same very little information we've all had. Seriously, we've read all this before. At least reserve the topic for post-E3. @KIWI Exactly. Both Sony and Microsoft are distinguishing themselves and claiming their own independence with motion control and developers are seeing the benefits of both. Their success does not necessarily depend on the competition of each other but rather the success of the product. It's silly to compare these two like this and it just defines the childish behavior the gaming industry is known for, especially when you claim "There can only be One". And we wonder why the rest of the world doesn't take this industry seriously and why the perception that video games are for children is so prominent.
Plus the fact that they are on completely separate and financially successful systems. If there is room for three consoles in the market, then there’s also room for three motion controllers.
Im sure all THREE will co-exist, but only one can win, which the Wiimote has already, lol.
exactly. there is room in this generation for both natal and move and I believe they will sell well to the casual crowd.
hmm, article seems a bit biased...
I AM THE ONE & ONLY!!! :D c wat i did dere?
That song was...
Since almost NOTHING about Natal/Wave has been shown....how can anyone Michael Patcher what the impact will be? We don't know how much of the smoke and mirrors presentation is even doable. Move shows promise, I do think that Sony is going to push this alot more than people realize.
they can "michael pacther" it because that would mean make a uneducated guess and 95% of the time being wrong
There can be only one! /Highlander EDIT:That only one will be the Wii. Better luck next time guys.
It seems like Microsoft are trying to beat Nintendo in seeing who has the most shovelware.
Both will have shovelware, you're a fool if you think any different.
Shows Natal and its games in 12 days
still not sold on ANY motion or camera control. i bought the wii at launch, played it for MAYBE a month, and then sold it after it sat there after another 6 while i played my ps3 and 360. i still don't understand why so many people are buying into all this motion control bs. nintendo has absolutely bastardized and ruined gaming(imo, of course).
just like Highlander there was always more than one and always will be. I'm sure they will both do well. A year or so from now we will still be arguing which is better.
If Lucasarts produces a jedi game for the psM....It will truly be over .....a highlander game....then there will only be one;)
Naw, if they've both got decent enough games, there's room enough for both. And Wii makes three. Dear internez: you need to chill bro...
Quote: "My main concern about Natal was that it doesn't seem to have the capacity for more than one player at a time." Natal is confirmed to track up to 4 people. Granted, those that have played it have only done so on the 2 player Breakout game, but the 4 player feature has been known since it was revealed.
I'd choose move. Microsoft has been too quiet to catch anyone's attention. "HEY LETS DEMONSTRATE NATAL ON BURNOUT EVEN THOUGH WE HAVE NO PLANS TO PATCH IT WITH NATAL CONTROLS =D" >=/
people going to look at the move and say why? i got a wii. natal presents at least on the surface an evolution of that. or just one look at that douche butler trying to shill move through his annoying sarcasm will for sure be a turn off for many..
Not true. Move will have its place AND the games will look better than what the Wii has to offer. The real bonus for Sony will be games coming out for the Wii can also be on the PS3...the PS3 versions looking better. Move and Natal have their place
Hey jack where you coming by? Didnt think so hahaha, poor QQ jack, dont send me a pm then ignore me. Now you dont have a chance to read the replys I gave you. And why would I look at the move and say why? My wii collects dust, ah well, guess your coming by soon hehehe, lmao.
The title is misleading. There is nothing in the article itself that argues "There can only be one." None of the information contained in the article was new to me... and the attempts at humor were rather lame. It remains to be seen if either of these motion systems has any merit. From what little is known, there is nothing to get excited about.
I like videogames, therefore (if the price is right) both have a chance to live in my living room. Oh, and they gotta be fun, too. That's... kind of a big deal to me.
natal will sell more based on hype and commercials, yet gamers will know that move is the superior product. gaming media will never give it credit....just like everything else involving sony this gen. i hope 360 fanboys realize that if natal is a smashing success you "hardcore gamers" will be dropped like a bad habit, much like nintendo did. ms obviously wants the wii market and you will be yesterdays news if they succeed. they'll keep you placated with your gears and halo and hope that it shuts you up (hell they do that now), like nintendo does with mario and zelda. it's blindingly obvious. you should want it to epically fail.
I only interest in move,because i only have ps3.
Frankly I don't care who 'wins' in the end. As long as Sony' Move works well and we get the hard and soft core games they promised, I am onboard. I could care less if the Natal works or not. Plus if I know Microsoft's MO, Natal will have a hundred glitches that will need a hundred patchs to make it work right and even if they make 100 games about 5 will be worth buying.
Why can't there only be none instead?
Move and PS Eye. Is not just 1. 2 Peripherals, 2 type of games will be designed for each Hardware, for PS Eye and Move.
like eye of judgement or eye toy pet??....ps-eye needs move to survive
Both need good games to survive.
There hasn't been any commitment so far to the ps eye. I bought the Eye Pet about six months ago and there has been no other software to make use of it. It's a piss take really, when is there going to be something else released for the ps eye or whatever it's called, because as of now it's not being supported at all. I didn't buy the the ps eye just for the eye pet, I thought they were going to support it.
the wii is out and people will compare move to the wii...not natal natal is on its own since sony can only use ps-eye for eye of jusgement and eyetoy pet.......and not very many people have a ps-eye and sony doesn't market or have the games for the ps-eye.....thats why they had to add controllers PLUS the eye.. lets hope Microsoft has some other good games for natal or flop...and hope its not pricey or FLOP... MOVE since its 2 controller pieces lets hope they aren't pricey or no one will buy move...especially if you want 4 players. but ill end up getting both.....maybe
why can there only be one. if that is the case let it be the wii lol. but seriously everything is win or lose with people hopefully they will both be successfull enough to where they make money. Then use that money to fund more core games. but thats just wishfull thinking
If it would work like they say it works, it could have a chance. But its lacking of possibilities like shooters, its lagging etc.. Clear Win for Sony!
I own a 360 & a PS3. Well, at least I know i'm only allowed to have 1 of them now.
N4G is a community of gamers posting and discussing the latest game news. It’s part of NewsBoiler, a network of social news sites covering today’s pop culture.