170°

Xbox 360 Kinect Vs PS3 Move: Consumer Choices during Black Friday 2010

As most of you will be aware, Microsoft has just launched their new Kinect hardware for the Xbox 360, possibly at the best time too, since we are leading up to a hectic holiday season.

Read Full Story >>
product-reviews.net
darthv724918d ago

If someone has a ps3 then the likely choice is move. If someone has a 360 then you can figure on kinect.

If they have neither, the choice is dependent on the games they intend to play. 360/kinect bundle vs ps3/move bundle vs possibly even the wii again this season.

sdtarm4916d ago

PS3 320gb and Move Bundle all the way! :D

karl4916d ago ShowReplies(2)
Imperator4916d ago

IMO, PS Move should by far be the better choice; however, since we're talking about the average consumer, I'm sure they'll be misled into thinking Kinect is better.

jessupj4916d ago

I agree, sadly the average consumer is very uneducated.

JoySticksFTW4916d ago

All I heard yesterday at work were people marveling over controlling games with no buttons, Minority Report, Move being a Wii rip-off. Not my words...

I'd get Move first. It actually has games for it that I like and can be used in "hardcore" games to add to the experience. I haven't seen that in Kinect yet.

But I really think Sony's problem is it's marketing pales next to MS. And there are crazy amounts of quality games coming out for PS3 where Move isn't needed yet.

The only MS game that I am really salivating over is GeoW3. PS3's list of upcoming games is nuts already.

And heck, I just dropped $40 on GoW:GoS for PSP

There is no boredom or lack of games that makes me want to get Move RIGHT NOW to keep PS3 feeling fresh.

There's no NEED for it, as most games give you the choice of Move or dualshock. And there aren't that many must have Move-only games yet.

And unfortunately for Sony, the amount of great quality non-Move specific games - Sony exclusives and multiplats - may keep buyers' money elsewhere for now.

My choice was Move for a few games like TC:RS and Tumble? Or use that money to catch up on some great games like Dead Rising 2, Fallout, Ratchet & Clank:CiT, Red Dead, GoW collection, and day one GoW:GoS and Sly Cooper collection?

(Yeah, I know. Why haven't I played some of those yet... I got hooked on Oblivion and Demon's Souls again, and about to beat 3D Dot Game Heroes and GoW:GoS)

I want Move. I just don't need it yet.

shadyiswin4916d ago

It might be because kinect is way better and offers a more jaw dropping effect. Mostly because sony fanboys have swore on there unborns it lags and it's glitchy, so now when people play it there's an extra omg it works effect. The Move can work perfectly and it does but will always be looked at as wii in hd, which would awesome if everyone wasn't tired of wii, sony was a year late on the one. No one wants to hold wands anymore especially if they don't have too, which they don't.

Kinect will win the holiday hands down, it's up to developers to keep it fresh which they prob won't for a while, I'm thinking summer 2011 or at e3 you'll see innovative titles for kinect. As for Move I don't see any games for it at all, what are the must haves? I've always enjoyed time crisis but no one I'm paying $99 then $40 then $49 for another controller, I'd want the gun add on as well, sure I don't need but that's what I liked about an expensive arcade experience at home. I'd be better off getting a ps2 and time crisis with 2 guns........or keep have fun with kinect adventures/dance central.

Sackdude4918d ago (Edited 4918d ago )

If your a gamer and like core games get PS move (KZ3, No more heroes 2, MAG, Dead space, LBP 2, Resident evil 5...etc)

If your new into gaming and find core games hard for you and you prefer gimmicky casual games then get Kinect.

T9X694916d ago (Edited 4916d ago )

I'm a core gamer and I got Kinect, the games are casual yes, but gimmicky no. They actually work really well and are pretty fun. I was actually surprised how well Kinect Sports worked, while playing the game I never experienced any lag, but I've only played the Table Tennis and Bowling, the whole running in place thing is a little to casual and much for me though lol.

feelintheflow4916d ago

I believe the fact that I have owned almost every major video game console since the magnovox Odyssey qualifies me as a core gamers. The only ones I missed were the gamecube and the turbo graphix 16 I believe. I have kinect and I find the games exactly what I expected, fun, easy to pick up, and a plain old good time. That doesn't mean that it is for core gamers, it just means that as a core gamer, i don't care what I look like when playing a game, unlike the tards on here who are worried about how they look, and I just love to play games. It doesn't matter what kind. Are the games revolutionary, nope, are they fun, yep. To mme, I feel it is sad that someone would bash this with an elitist attitude, acting like only games he likes are worthy. Sales don't mean quality, but it means that a bunch of flippin people like what the game is all about.

baodeus4916d ago

yeah, i tried kinect sport out myself and it works well. You can do spin, slice, smash etc...with ping pong too. After reading about all the negatives things about it, i actually find kinect work quite well. Currently though, i think dance central is the best so far.

lowcarb4916d ago

I just don't get it. You already have a controller for those core games that works perfectly fine. The real deciding factor should be who is supporting there device with games built specifically for it. .

snp4916d ago (Edited 4916d ago )

It's simple, Move is an alternate controller _as well as_ a control method bringing new games to the plate.

It's serves two functions, and was always intended to.

For some people RUSE or whatever will be 'perfectly fine' on the Ds3, for others it - or some other game - may well simply be that much better on the Move. Implementation quality will vary from game to game, though obviously it'll get better as developers get more experience. It's going to a be game to game proposition, and subjective to boot (as it will also be on the 'Move only' games implementation of the Move to, for that matter).

To be honest, i find this constant attempt to have one half - and not coincidentally the best quality/biggest budget half - of Move's catalogue dismissed outright when comparing with the Kinects (which doesn't serve a duel purpose as a controller, and thus have any of these big name games on it's list) more than a touch disingenuous.

blackburn54916d ago

I played with Move at my friends house the other day. Wish I could buy one but other responsibilities for my money right now. Hope to get one of Xmas.

BooBaggins4916d ago

Kinect will sell really well. Ps3 will sell because there's still 100millions ps2 owners who are ready to upgrade

Rorona4916d ago Show
ALFAxD_CENTAURO4916d ago

Analyst from N4G, can't find better analysts than them, lol.

Show all comments (23)
50°

Air Conflicts: Secret Wars - PlayStation Move's Best Kept Secret

Air Conflicts: Secret Wars debuted in 2011, and later updated for modern consoles. However, it's the PlayStation 3 edition that stands out.

20°

Joy Ride Turbo - The Beginning of the End for Xbox Kinect

Joy Ride Turbo launched 10 years ago today. The first title was Xbox Kinect exclusive, yet this sequel failed to support the device at all.

300°

10 of the Biggest Video Game Hardware Failures Ever

Cultured Vultures: "Sadly, not all hardware is created equal, and no matter how much developers might try, some gaming hardware just fails to hit the mark. We’ve compiled a list of 10 gaming hardware fails, and boy did some fail hard."

Read Full Story >>
culturedvultures.com
Knightofelemia825d ago

I would label the Power Glove, Kinect, and that Tony Hawk skateboard more as hardware addons hardware failure would be like the Virtual Boy and one day Stadia.

Magog825d ago

Kinect was bundled with every Xbox One and inflated the price on an already underpowered and low RAM machine so for the One it wasn't an accessory as much as a white elephant.

CaptainHenry916825d ago (Edited 825d ago )

Definitely the RROD but that power glove had a lot of issues as well. The Kinect just didn't work

824d ago
CrimsonWing69824d ago

Hardware add-ons are more like RAM or a video card, basically components that enhance capabilities or performance of the computer.

If you really want to get technical the Kinect is more of a peripheral device, kind of like a keyboard or mouse to a computer.

ThatsGaming824d ago

The person in this article obviously is not up on their gaming history....

Sega Saturn, Sega Dreamcast, Coleco Gemini, Commodore 128, Commodore Amiga, Atari 5200, Atari 7800 were all massive failures and in most cases cost their companies participating in future gaming generations.

Gamer79824d ago

Sega saturn (successful in Japan) and dreamcast were not failures.
Seems like you're not up on you're gaming history

septemberindecember824d ago

@Gamer79

How in the world are the Sega Saturn and Dreamcast not seen as failures? They both sold around 8M each, which is much lower than the ~30M that the Genesis had sold before it, and even the Master System before that. They were both the worst selling consoles in their respective generation (PS1, N64 outsold Saturn, PS2, GC, and Xbox outsold Dreamcast). Both of the consoles were incredibly short lived. The Saturn was discontinued in every territory but Japan after just three years. In Japan the console was discontinued after six years. Meanwhile the Dreamcast was discontinued worldwide in 2001 after launching in most territories in 1999 and in Japan in 1998. The failure of the Saturn and Dreamcast lead to Sega pulling out of the hardware market. Which, by the way, all of this occurred when Sega was massively dropping the price of their consoles quickly to compete. Sega was hemorrhaging money at this point.

None of this indicates a successful console. Saying the Saturn was a success because it did better in Japan is like saying the Vita is a success (they both sold around the same amount of units in Japan). Even the Wii U outsold these consoles worldwide.

Magog825d ago

The picture should be the 360 RROD. When I think of gaming hardware failures that's what springs to mind. Kinect and it's bundled price tag definitely hobbled the already underpowered Xbox One though for sure so I would give it a close second place.

porkChop825d ago (Edited 825d ago )

That's not what the author means by failures. It's about hardware that failed in terms of sales (Wii U) or just failed to deliver on its promise (Kinect).

Magog825d ago (Edited 825d ago )

Given that the 360 had a year head start, much easier hardware to develop for, was cheaper, and still ended up in third place I think it qualifies especially when you factor in the frustration and huge losses incurred by RROD.

porkChop824d ago

Selling over 80 million consoles isn't a sales flop. We get it, you don't like Xbox, but that doesn't mean the 360 is suddenly a failure.

Rhythmattic824d ago

Porky....
You know how many people I know bought a 2nd or third 360 due to RROD? Even when MS had to confront the issue with replacement systems, my mates couldn't wait for even the turnaround of sending it in, and waiting for a replacement.,,..,..
If that's how you consider it a win... OK.. but so is having 5 , of which 3 don't function.... Its a win win....mwhahahahaha

porkChop824d ago

"my mates couldn't wait for even the turnaround of sending it in"

You're acting like it would take months. When I sent my 360 in I got a new one literally 5 days later. As soon as MS had tracking confirmation that you sent yours, they'd send a new one to you the same day. No one is going to spend hundreds to buy a new console instead of waiting a week. I swear you guys pull some of the dumbest shit out of nowhere and think people will actually believe it.

Regardless, none of this changes the fact that this isn't what the article is even about.

Rhythmattic823d ago (Edited 823d ago )

Porky
"You're acting like it would take months"
Sometimes it could.. FFS.. 'Strya here...
Best turnaround I reckon was 2-3 weeks.....
Either way, My mates experiences still exist.. So Sorry, no point trying to earn Xbox Achievements when it doesn't feature in what was a situation you never dealt with,,,,
3 of my friends would disagree (overall, 10 extra Xboxes purchased)
Regardless.. MS sold a lot of 360's that was due to this reason.. That is sales. Fact

"none of this changes the fact that this isn't what the article is even about."
Headline says HELLO !
Oh and "Sadly, not all hardware is created equal," that's enough to pass this on without taking your article bias into consideration.....
As for the rest.... Ok.. But you've actually gone out of your way to give MS a Pass... Fap on.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 823d ago
Aloymetal824d ago (Edited 824d ago )

Yup, and because of that big fiasco MS had to fork out 1 billion but knowing them I think they're very proud of the 360, it's the only time a MS console reached 80mil+ sales, RROD played a big part of that and a record they will never break again.

Rhythmattic824d ago (Edited 824d ago )

So true.. Even when MS accepted they where caught out in the biggest lie of any generation, The wait for a replacement was outweighed by just buying another, and having one be returned as a backup, which, btw, generally failed on first swap.
I own honestly can't believe MS tards are just supporting , or arguing why and what MS did by just dismissing it....

lonewolf10825d ago

Lol I had the Atari Jaguar, surprised its "competition" the 3DO isn't on the list too, both as "popular" as each other.

SullysCigar824d ago

Lol same. Played the crap out of Aliens Vs Predator and Tempest 2000 .... aaand that's about it really!!

lonewolf10824d ago

Sad but true that was pretty much it.

Kurt Russell824d ago

Agreed, I never actually saw a 3DO make it to retailers in the UK. At least the Atari Jaguar was sold for around 6 months.

lonewolf10824d ago

It made it to some my brother got one, fared just as well as the Jaguar so most probably hard to find in general.

darthv72824d ago

3do had way better games. Jaguar not so much. Neo Geo sold less than both and yet isnt considered a failure. Go figure.

LWOGaming825d ago

Stadia is a weird one. It hasn’t sold at all well but in terms of how it works it’s still miles ahead of Xcloud in terms of stability and performance. Xcloud is still a way behind and that needs sorting but it will be in time. Stadia for me is one of those things that will go down as a what could have been moments. With better marketing it could have been a roaring success. I still play it and it remains the best place in my opinion to play CyberPunk 2077. Only platform I have played it on without having any issues at all. The tech is great. The concept is fine. Marketing terrible. Shame really.

Magog824d ago

The sales model was awful. They should have teamed with an existing player to allow for local and cloud access to games or a gaming subscription service.

LWOGaming824d ago

It was a strange mess from such a huge company, as I said, as a system it works really well but without gamers it’s nothing. Such a waste,

LWOGaming825d ago

The Xbox One was Microsoft’s Nintendo Wii U. Undercooked, undersold and just an unholy mess. The thing is with any of these failures is to learn from them and thankfully both Nintendo and Xbox did just that to the benefit of gamers everywhere.

Show all comments (39)