OXM: "You might soldier through tedious interrogations filled with strained dialogue and limp button-tapping quick-time events, but there's just no good reason to subject yourself to yet another clumsy jigsaw puzzle, Morse-code translation, or painful mix-and-match facial-compositing exercise. Your reward for bearing 10 hours of drudgery? A lengthy report-filing sequence packed with all the leisure value of a final exam. You're better off just buying a puzzle magazine at the airport."
Zac Elawar from Capsule Computers wrote:
"Red Johnson’s Chronicles: One Against All is the 2nd entry into the Red Johnson’s Chronicles series. Much like its predecessor, ‘One Against All’ was first released on the PlayStation Network, before marking the series’ début on Xbox Live Arcade and finally making its way onto the PC in 2013, a year after it’s initial release. The first game had some great puzzles, but many experience-dampening issues. Has Red redeemed himself in this second adventure?…"
DSOGaming writes: "Lexis Numérique and Microids announced that after a noted incursion on both Playstation 3 and Xbox 360, detective Red Johnson is back on PC with two high-risk investigations."
AG: Several genuinely clever puzzles provide a good challenge; unique art style; built-in hints keep you from being stuck for too long at a stretch.