130°
8.0

Giant Bomb: Halo Reach Review

When taken with the appropriate context--namely, that the game's original developer is saying goodbye to the series and passing it off to a new team--Halo: Reach feels like a wholly appropriate stopping point for the series, filling out some more of the relevant fiction that surrounds the core trilogy while building the multiplayer out in such a way that Halo fans will have something to play until whatever's next is ready for release. While I do feel that the formula has worn thin in a few spots, Reach feels like a love letter from the developer to its fans. If you're one of those fans, you should have this game.

Read Full Story >>
giantbomb.com
5378d ago Replies(3)
RockmanII75378d ago

How are you gonna give MW2 a 5/5 then give Reach a 4/5? I don't get that.

JonnyBigBoss5378d ago

Maybe because Modern Warfare 2 is the better game?

Bobbykotickrulesz5378d ago

Bahaha.

I laughed.
MW2 is NOT better than Reach. Hands fucking down.

Roozium5378d ago

MW2 is a better game... when compared to Robocop on the original Xbox.

T9X695378d ago (Edited 5378d ago )

Well Gamesradar gave MW2 a perfect 10 as well and Halo Reach an 8. Any site that gives MW2 a perfect 10 should be smacked across the face, I'm not saying Halo Reach deserves a 10, but Reach offers WAY more than MW2 and is overall better designed and should be at least a 9.0 if the same site gives MW2 a 10.

@Tru3_Gam3r - Killzone 2 shits all over MW2 in every aspect.

PrinceOfAnger5378d ago

modern warfare 2 got 94 metascore and killzone 2 91 that mean mw2 is the better game right ? right ?? because the game with the better score that mean the game is better?

5378d ago
+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5378d ago
Roozium5378d ago

Giant Bomb = CoD fanboys, easy as that

Fanb0y5378d ago

And also automatic halo haters. You should listen to their impressions on their podcast. They don't even try to understand the game.

ABizzel15378d ago

1. The reviewers could have been different people.

2. They've played Hal Reach, while many of you haven't yet you somehow already know what score it should get.

3. It review was based off what he likes. Not everyone is going to like Halo, God of War, Mario, or whatever else.

And 8/10 is a good score.

tinybigman5377d ago (Edited 5377d ago )

they gave it 4/5 the world is coming to an end. does every big game have to get a 5/5 or 10/10 from every site? and no they don't need to change their ratings system.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5377d ago
JonnyBigBoss5378d ago

I trust GiantBomb more than any other site to deliver solid reviews. Jeff Gerstmann inspired me to start writing reviews back when he was on GameSpot.

HyperBear5378d ago

Wow...I honestly don't know what to say about this...I thought giantbomb was gonna deliver the 5/5...but I don't know wtf to say about this 8/10 from GiantBomb???

mrv3215378d ago

A 4/5 DOES NOT EQUAL a 8/10 in review terms. They use this system to prevent a huge cluster of reviews at 9+/10 with no big difference between a 9.3 or 9.5... and it works

A 5/5 game is GREAT and a must buy
A 4/5 game is good

http://www.giantbomb.com/re...

Look how FEW games get a 5/5, Out of 313 reviews only 40 odd games get a 5/5 and most of those games are games I own or recomend. I feel they've made their point clear about Halo: Reach being similar to Halo 3 which it kinda is.

darren_poolies5378d ago (Edited 5378d ago )

I hate it that people complain about an 8/10, Gamespot have given the same score and are being give so much flak with people saying 'clearly they are just looking for hits'. Well how about it's just there opinion *gasp* I know its crazy isn't it? That different sites and writers have there own options, I had a mini heart-attack when I found out. /sarcasm

An 8/10 is a good score people!!! But I'm not going to trust any reviews for Reach because Halo 3 was getting the same kind of praise and scores and man that was disappointing. Online was awesome but the single-player was pretty bad and it had received lots of 10's and 9's for some bizarre reason claiming it was like the second coming of Jesus. Lets hope this is not the same with Reach.

HyperBear5378d ago

Its not that I dont think its a bad score. I just look at other games such as MW2, which they gave a 5/5, and then look at these games like Alan Wake, Halo 3 ODST, Skate 3, etc..all get 4/5's and apparently Reach is on the same level as them? This is where the whole /5 rating score blows, and they need to improve it.

darren_poolies5378d ago (Edited 5378d ago )

I agree with you but Alan Wake and Skate 3 are in a completely different genre than Halo Reach so I personally wouldn't compare them scores to this. The MW2 score is stupid but I bet that a lot of sites would change that now it they could I just think that with that, hype got the better of them.

I completely agree that the rating system needs to be changed and not just on Giantbomb. I believe all site should do ratings out of 100, it just makes a lot more sense.

But I still stand by my point that people complaining about an 8/10 are just being greedy and silly really I mean there not goign to be able to buy it them be like 'zomg I cant buy this it got an 8/10 omfg wth am i going to dooo' they are still going to buy it so why complain. Btw HyperBear my post wasn't aimed at you just people who complain like 8/10 is a bad score.

HyperBear5378d ago

I know right. I know those games aren't in the same league as Reach, or genre for that matter, I just picked some games that had the same score to use for examples. But I mean, they gave ODST a 4/5, and I guess they felt there was no difference between ODST and Reach?

I agree, ratings should be out of 100. That way, if they were to score ODST the same as Reach out of 100, then we know something is wrong with them. But because they chose to have ratings /5, we can't really complain about them because they only have 5 numbers to rate games out of.

darren_poolies5378d ago

Yeh I have to agree with you, this doesn't deserve the same score as a full-price expansion pack and if ODST scored an 8/10 this should have at least received a 9/10. But it could be different writers who written the reviews and this one just thinks that Reach is a 8/10 game?

I don't know and it doesn't really matter as I'll be buying it either way. They just need to change there rating system at the end of the day.

HyperBear5378d ago

Yeah, me too. Its a Day 1 for me, and agreed, they do need to change their rating system

HeroXIV5378d ago

Sorry I can't find that Gamespot review of it. Got a link?

Show all comments (33)
90°

6 Friendliest Characters in Games

GF365: "Oftentimes, video games have characters who are antagonistic and really not very pleasant. Here are some of the friendliest characters in games where you might not otherwise expect to find them."

Read Full Story >>
gamefreaks365.com
thorstein649d ago

Dogmeat: *bark!*

Translation: you are dead to me.

JSONEHUNDRED649d ago

You can probably add Karlach to this from BG3

150°

10 Best Lore-Rich Video Games

Talented writers can build worlds that are as wondrous as real-life. Here are the best lore-rich video games for you to get immersed in.

Read Full Story >>
gamefreaks365.com
shinoff2183885d ago

How'd fallout not make the list. Atleast over cyberpunk, tales , and halo. Fallout been around since what 96 98 and has 5 6 games into it. It's full of lore when you play it. I'd even add star ocean to a point.

robtion884d ago

Agree Fallout should be on there.

MadLad884d ago

And somehow Planescape Torment doesn't even make the list.

Crows90884d ago

Hollow knight surpasses these.

shinoff2183884d ago

In lore? I must be missing something

Crows90884d ago (Edited 884d ago )

Yes in lore. Easily missed... absolutely. Never played a game that had me loving the world and lore behind it as much as that one. Most of course wouldn't be able to experience it since it is a more difficult game.

DarXyde884d ago

I can't speak for all titles on this list, but by the time you get to Dark Souls III, the lore is a bloody tapestry of intricacy

Crows90883d ago

Played them all. Im not saying the games on the list dont have good lore...I just think hollow knight had more lore that is hidden but present and more easily explored and accessed. The souls games have tremendous lore but theyre mostly hidden and stay that way unless you look for it and research it. The lore is not very accessible.

DarXyde883d ago

Crows90,

I think that's a somewhat fair assessment. For me, the Souls games are less upfront about the lore, but it does invite your fascination through NPCs, items, locations, bosses, etc. There's this kind of natural progression where the picture becomes just clear enough by doing the essential tasks, but it really makes you want to explore every inch of the world.

TheColbertinator884d ago

Suikoden and Legend of Heroes also have massive lore setups.

agent13884d ago

narration is more important than lore i'd rather watch the story and characters in a more cinematic way instead of searching for notes and stuff that's why i love sony exclusive games like uncharted and gow and hate from software games

shinoff2183883d ago

The article was top ten lore in video games. I think they did a bad job picking games out. I know what you mean though. I just like a variety of games and genres.

Show all comments (16)
220°

Halo’s best Bungie campaign has its worst feature fixed after 12 years

Halo’s best ever campaign mode developed by Bungie has had its most annoying feature fixed after more than a decade, making the sci-fi FPS game better than ever

Read Full Story >>
pcgamesn.com
SullysCigar970d ago

Awesome news - so can we look forward to playing Halo: Infinite with no online issues circa 2033?

just_looken969d ago

"You can download the improved Reach AI mod at Mod DB" This was a mod 343 did nothing so the online will be fixed in our dreams.

SullysCigar969d ago

Par for the course with 343.

Profchaos968d ago

They did say they had a 10 year plan for infinite we just all assumed it would be DLC could of been a 10 year netcode rollout.

But seriously this is a mod the community won't be able to modify infinite in the same way

Cikatriz_ESP969d ago

Combat Evolved was the best campaign, and it's not even close.

just_looken969d ago

You should have tried this version of reach when it first came out remastered for a year there was no sound because 343 could not locate the sound files.

It was a special challenge.

badz149969d ago

more like the bunch at 343i are simply mentally challenged

ACEMANWISE969d ago

Well I guess 12 years is faster than most fixes. I guess this is a cheap way to "remaster" something nowadays.....by just fixing something that used to always be broken.

zidane1341969d ago

Did you even read the article? This is a mod to improve AI from back almost 2 gens ago. Nobody is claiming this is remastering anything. Yeesh.

Crows90969d ago

Halo is dead. Microsoft has other shooter franchises it cares more about now. 343 are no longer Xbox golden studio. They are likely to shift things around or even close it all together and give the IP to someone else.

343i decided to pummel the IP into the ground...and when they see it didn't quite look like Glenn's face they decided to just keep on pummeling. Not sure if Glenn is the IP or the fanbase in this case though.

Profchaos968d ago

343 were never the golden studio they were a hastily thrown together b team when bungie said we want to do something else cya

Crows90968d ago

Well ...I didn't want to say it but I agree. Makes you wonder why Microsoft gave them the IP and didn't keep Bungie or any of the talent they acquired from any studio.

CobraKai968d ago

“ Halo Infinite, Halo 3, or Halo: Combat Evolved. It’s hard to say which of the sci-fi FPS games offers the best experience all round.”
He lost me with Halo Infinite.

Show all comments (18)