Mass Effect 2 vs. Red Dead Redemption for 2010 Game of the Year?

Six months into 2010, with six more months of solid titles still ahead of us. Is it too early to start sizing up Mass Effect 2 and Red Dead Redemption against each other as the primary contenders for Game of the Year consideration? Not at all.

Read Full Story >>
The story is too old to be commented.
Lucreto4000d ago

They are both great games but I have a feeling Super Mario Galaxy 2 will get it based off reviews.

Joule4000d ago

God of War 3 for me so far.

TheXgamerLive4000d ago

red dead was hella fun but ME2 has been like no other. Hell, Alan Wake was hella fun, but mass effect 2 has been incredible and Bioware continues to support it, so it keeps on rocking.

There will be other continders later on this year.

bloop4000d ago

ME2 for me too so far, with GOW3 a close second. But why are these articles popping up when we're only half way through the year?!?! There's a lot of big hitters to come this year yet.

FanboysWillHateMe4000d ago (Edited 4000d ago )

would probably get it, but I hope that's not what they base it on. Sure it got a high score, but you can just look at the amount of effort and detail put into other games such as Red Dead Redemption and Mass Effect 2 and I think it blows Mario out of the water.

I thought God of War 3 was tight, but for me it was just like the first and second one. I really thought Bayonetta offered more variety and fun, and this was only Bayonetta's first outing. The games that innovate or push the boundaries get my vote, and with that said I'd put Heavy Rain over God of War 3 if I had to choose. But overall, my top 5 as of now is:

1. Mass Effect 2
2. Bayonetta
3. Heavy Rain
4. Bad Company 2
5. Red Dead Redemption

AntoineDcoolette3999d ago

What about Starcraft 2? Why does everyone forget about PC exclusives and vouch for console games as GOTY?... why! : /

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3999d ago
Quagmire4000d ago

Im liking that pic


yoshiroaka4000d ago (Edited 4000d ago )

Glad im not the only perv here lol

I mean cmon!! Look at it! lol
If thats not a AVN awards trophy i dunno what is.

dkblackhawk504000d ago

Who else but Quagmire?! :D

GrilledCheeseBook4000d ago

i seriously don't care about GOTY
only clicked because of the pic

TheXgamerLive4000d ago

no matter what it looks like, she's an automatic KEEPER:)!

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 4000d ago
Donny4000d ago

heavy rain imo will get GOTY.

but on topic: i think out of the two, mass effect 2 is the better game, red dead is overrated imo.

Donny4000d ago

wow i had 3 bubbles, and just for stating my opinion i have 2.

Hellsvacancy4000d ago (Edited 4000d ago )

Ill give u 1 (a bubble that is) i like your pic, thats 1 SCARY mofo


On topic: Demon's Souls is MY game of the year, it only got released in the UK last week so technically, it counts as this year

TROLL EATER4000d ago

who cares halo reach game of the decade

Gawdl3y4000d ago

It seems that the troll eater has absorbed the trolls that he ate into himself.

jeseth4000d ago (Edited 4000d ago )

Never has a game left me in such awe. The whole game was unbelievable and is an incredible end to Kratos' story.

Also in the running IMO :

Heavy Rain
Red Dead Redemption
Mass Effect 2 (thought about buying another 360 just for this game!)

All in all, GRAN TURISMO 5 will be my GOTY by year's end.


Simon_Brezhnev4000d ago

God of War GOTY for me i played heavy rain, rdr, and me2.

TheLastGuardian4000d ago

2. God Of War III
3. Bioshock 2
4.GTA: Episodes From Liberty City
5. Modnation Racers

ABizzel14000d ago

I can understand why people would choose these two games, but neither did anything for me.

I don't like GTA or westerns, but I gave Red Dead a try anyway, and it just wasn't my kind of game.

Mass Effect 2's problem to me is the gameplay. I love the story and the lore within the game, but the gameplay ruins what would be an amazing game. The 3rd person shooter mechanics aren't good, and going through so many menus all the time takes away from the action. What makes me mad about Mass Effect is that I know it's the type of game I like, but the gameplay is keeping me from getting into it.

If I had to choose right now, it would be God of War with Heavy Rain close by. God of War met my expectations, and was a great conclusion to the series (although I would have liked it if it was longer). Heavy Rain expanded upon the genre started by Indigo Prophecy, and did a great job at showing games outside of the norm.

+ Show (6) more repliesLast reply 3999d ago
maxcavsm4000d ago

An unfortunate and yet accurate statement. Ugh.
Thanks Lucreto.

DontShoot-Me-Bro4000d ago (Edited 4000d ago )


Only a Playstation 3 Exclusive can be Game Of The Year.

Sorry to burst your bubble.

frjoethesecond4000d ago

I take it your talking about heavy rain which is game of the year. Sorry red dead, it's either ME2 or HR.

2FootYard4000d ago Show
DelbertGrady4000d ago

Only a PS3 exclusive can be the TRUE goty. As in FACT.

November 9 20044000d ago

a boring racing game wont get it,its rdr,galaxy 2 or ME 2.