With Uncharted 4 Out & Over, Do We Really Need A Film Adaptation?

Pixelgate writes:

''As a franchise, Uncharted has provided moments that force you to soak in the scene. For years now, I've refereed to Uncharted 2 and 3 as the accumulation of what main stream video games have aimed to be. Those experiences that rival, arguably surpass, anything cinema can offer.''

[Null1980]

I don't want it. They'll screw it up. Guaranteed.

[PixelGateUk]

Hollywood's track record doesn't really inspire confidence if it ever did happen

[Null1980]

Of course I'd LOVE to see a great Uncharted movie, but you know Hollywood. I'd rather them not even try. :\

[I_am_Batman]

I personally don't see the need for video game movies at all especially when we're talking about story/character driven games. I just don't like the idea of having an entirely different cast of actors play those roles. But then again I don't mind those movies too much. If the movie sucks (which it often does) I just ignore it.

[-Foxtrot]

If they just got the voice actors at least the main three, work their Hollywood make up magic on them, get Nolan to a strict bulk up diet and then follow a condensed Drakes Fortune script from the game which cuts unnecessary chapters out (which were done in the game story to add to the games length) and transition the gameplay sections in-between the cutscenes nicely together then sure I'd want it

But Hollywood aren't smart are they.

[Miguelitons]

For Uncharted I would love to see a film adaption, no matter what others say :-).

[IIFloodyII]

We don't need it, thankfully we probably won't get it any time soon either.

As Nolan North said, by the time it releases, he'll be old enough to play Sully.

[Lon3wolf]

1) They would most probably mess it up (being Hollywood)
2) I think it's missed the boat entirely by now

[MagicBeanz]

NO.

[ninsigma]

I'd rather a CG movie if anything. Use the same voice actors and the characters will look the like they do in the games.

[Lon3wolf]

Sort of like the Resident Evil ones that were released a while back?

[ninsigma]

I haven't seen them but yeah. Uncharted is something where I'd like to keep the characters intact which would be hard to do with actors imo.

[Lon3wolf]

They weren't bad and followed Leon more than anyone (degeneration/damnation) voiced by the actor that did Leon in the later games.

[Edito]

Every time i play this game i say to my self please don't make a movie of this, it's already here... A movie will suck big time.

[uth11]

No

[esmittystud101]

Don't we get DLC as well for U4 down the road. Thats why we got the season pass, right? Probably prequal material, which I'm fine with.

A movie?????

Well, Assassin's Creed is going with it and I'm not going to knock either until I see both.

[The_Sage]

No. Please don't.

[CrimsonWing69]

Do we ever need a film adaptation to any game? I'd say if anything pull an Advent Children on it or some form of love letter continuation of the story with all the actors voicing characters from the game. Let's be honest, most live action adaptations are abysmal.