Honest Gamers writes: "Missing the mark in everything it tries to achieve, Fenimore Fillmore's Revenge is a catastrophe of an adventure game. Thoughtlessly designed and amateurishly crafted, it quickly descends into a pile of pointless gibberish and unfinished ideas. Fortunately, it's so insignificant that it's not worth getting upset about. If you're stupid enough to play it, make sure you disconnect your speakers first."
This is not the best adventure game in the world. Gamers will not be captivated by it in this day and age. It is wrong to venture into a genre with the bar so high...However, Meristation did find it an adventure that will delight those who have the courage to try it.