550°

Metacritic responds after Dragon Age: The Veilguard review bombing

Review aggregation site Metacritic has spoken out in response to the ongoing review bombing of Dragon Age: The Veilguard.

Read Full Story >>
eurogamer.net
Obscure_Observer178d ago

Glad that Metacritic has been call out on their bs! Those haters days are numbered!

User reviews should only be submitted by actual gamers who owns the game, just like Steam, MS and Sony does.

OldDuffer178d ago

Don't always align with your posts, but it seems pretty stupid to downvote you when you've said something all could universally agree with. I guess people see your name and autoclick disagree 🤔

thorstein178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

Coupled with the fact that it is about Veilguard, instant downvotes for some people so desperate to make the game fail.

Notellin178d ago

That's how it works. Nothing Obscure says is genuine or formed by any kind of expertise. It's similar to crying wolf. Say enough things that are disingenuous and rooted in anecdotal bias or lies and no one will ever care what you have to say.

Armaggedon178d ago

Lmao. I think that might be the case, as I get downvoted even when I say things that are objective facts. Like if I say “I cant say anything about Ff7 because I havent played it…7 downvotes. 😂

Seraphim178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

agree with sure, but unlike Steam, MS and PS who are platform holders, metacritic has no access to knowing who owns which games/movies. I'm not saying they couldn't implement something, but that would likely require access to your purchased games on said platforms along with linking your account w/ metacritic; at the very least. It's one of those comments/things that sound good on paper, but once you put an ounce of thought into it realize it's not a simple measure/fix. There are a lot of things that are ideal, but the world itself is far from ideal nor will it ever be. Furthermore said system would likely be less beneficial to consumers as only the die hard flaming fanboys would be likely to post reviews. In which case they'd all be glowing reviews.

LordoftheCritics178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

Review bombing was started by the 10's everywhere.

What did you expect?

PapaBop177d ago

but but I don't want to universally agree with anyone, I just want to write angry reviews on games I have no interest in playing /s

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 177d ago
SoloZelot90178d ago

Absolutely. It would be great to put the review bombing argument to rest with that type of confirmation.

Vx_177d ago

Trump will fix this shit, can't wait goanna be fun time to watch.

177d ago
MajorLazer177d ago

Same goes for love bombing. The game is neither a 1, nor a 10.

THEzRude177d ago

Im sure you have nothing against paid 10/10 reviews....

Killer2020UK177d ago

And there's your problem. Twice as many people down voting you than agreeing.

WHAT DO YOU WANT YOU MORONS?! Reviews from people who haven't played the game? Are you that reactionary?

Evidently it would seem so.

+ Show (5) more repliesLast reply 177d ago
blackblades178d ago

All I hear is all talk and no real action. There is an easy solution to this kind of a problem. Also didnt the FTC do something about review bombing recently.

DivineHand125178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

To those people taking time out of their day to review bomb this game, take a step back from this negative mindset and find some joy in life. BioWare worked hard to make this game and the majority of gamers who played the game are enjoying it. No game is perfect and do not allow yourself to be influenced by people who are only fueling the negativity so they can monetize it. If Dragon Age Veilguard fails, it will only be a setback for EA and the executives but developers who worked hard to bring us this game will be the ones without a job, and you will be partly responsible for driving away people who genuinely want to get into this franchise.

Inverno178d ago

Anyone wanting to get into the franchise has had 3 other opportunities to get into it. And EA and any other publisher or company doesn't need a reason to fire employees as seen by MS's only success since they bought Bethesda being shut down without care. If this game fails it'll fail because Bioware made a game that it's core audience, that's been waiting a decade for another entry, simply didn't like. If the fans aren't owed a game to their liking then the dev isn't owed success. And just as there's people "fueling the negativity" there are people blindly praising it. Works both ways.

DivineHand125178d ago

Yes, there are previous entries in the Dragon Age series. However, some gamers don't want to play games that look dated. I just finished a play-through of Half-Life, and I think it was an amazing game for its time, but many people out there would take a look at it and say, "Nope." Putting you-get gamers aside, it is not possible to play every good game that gets released, and tastes change. It's possible that people who slept on Dragon Age in the past because they didn't like or understand RPGs might be willing to give it a chance now.

I see you mentioned that EA won't fire people if Dragon Age fails. I don't know what world you belong to, but just this year alone, people are being laid off across all industries. It is not only Microsoft, and I am not sure why you brought up Microsoft when Sony just closed 2 studios last week and laid off the staff for underperforming games despite receiving good reviews from major reviewers.

"If the fans aren't owed a game to their liking then the dev isn't owed success."

No one is owed success, but fans should not go out of their way day in and day out trying to sabotage the game in every way possible. If it is truly a bad game, it will fail on its own without people trying to forcibly move the needle with a flood of negative articles, videos, and fake reviews.

If you say there are people blindly praising Dragon Age, I would like to know where they are? Because it is either 5 people in total or the negative user reviews on Metacritic say otherwise. In addition to that, the only positive sentiment this game seems to be receiving is from those who actually played the game, as we can see from the verified reviews on Steam.

Armaggedon178d ago

Baldurs Gate 3 exists. Dragon age origins fans have been waiting since 2009….its not happening. Play BG3 instead.

Armaggedon178d ago

@DivineHand125

You know how it works: speak truth: get downvoted.😂

But in a serious note, you are dropping more truth. People were just using metacritc as a form of confirmation bias to show why Starfield is a bad game. Now all of a sudden we dont want to use steam reviews? People are so boind by bias against veilguard that its borderline self sabotage. Like divinehands125 stated, if the game is that bad, it will flop on its own like other bad games that no one talks about. You guys trying so hard to put a knife in its gullet, and it standing relatively strong regardless, is very telling. Who knows what those players numbers would be if the darkspawn were not out here trying to taint the darn game. You guys keep saying you want the old Bioware back. Guess what ? That is never happening if you kill them.

SoloZelot90178d ago

Not my problem or yours. Let people do what they want. They have a voice too even if you disagree. As long as they aren't breaking the law all is good in my book.

If reviews are just "opinions" then everyone is entitled to one.

DivineHand125178d ago

Didn't the FTC just release a rule that prohibits the use of fake reviews and testimonials? I doubt it will be enforced but the thing I dislike about this situation is the exaggerated negative reaction from the community.

Armaggedon178d ago

F the law. People are sowing entropy, thats the real thing we should be worried about. This type of insidious, vitriolic behavior will slowly corrode us from within and manifest itself in broken laws. If you want to stop law breaking, it starts right here.

Inverno178d ago

I said they don't need a reason to fire people, success or not and bring MS up because HiFi Rush was basically their only successful game worth getting after their Bethesda acquisition and they still closed down Tango. As for the people blindly praising this game, there's like 5 of them on this site who seem to be spending more time getting triggered than spending time playing, also have you been to Twitter? Have you been to literally any other site where people are talking about the game? Fans have legit criticism, if you wanna bunch them up with the usual grifters it won't help ya win any arguments. All you gotta do is add "reddit" to the end of your Google search and you'll see hundreds having normal non hateful conversations about this game.

-Foxtrot177d ago

Exactly.

It’s funny, I gave up on this franchise a while back where I feel nothing for it anymore so I’m pretty numb to all this but the same people going on and on are actually the most annoying part here.

It’s clear if you take away all the politics that people are making a thing out of it’s still a Dragon Age game which is a shell of its former self. A step back from what came before which most journalists would have torn apart in reviews for how lacking it actually is for a big AAA game of a once great established IP.

It’s gotten to the point now you can’t even point the actual flaws of the game without being dragged into all this. It’s either you love it or you are “one of them” and it’s sad the “politics” people are going on about are being used to deflect the game from actual real criticism about gameplay.

Armaggedon177d ago (Edited 177d ago )

Its still dragon age. Just in a different form. There are plenty of other games that have deviated from their roots. This on, is the problem though.

Armaggedon178d ago

@DivineHand125
The hardest truth I have seen said in these comments since the game dropped. Well spoken, and kudos.

177d ago
+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 177d ago
pwnmaster3000178d ago

Remember when these gamers use to hate cancel culture. What is so political about this game?

Look at some of the reviews.
0/10
“ Pure propaganda and screwing up a francise. Cant we have something to do or play to escape these woke politics they try to force down our throats”

1/10
“ My review:… Trash game too many lgbt characters no medieval characters in a medieval game nobody wants a lgbt medieval game most people want a game like Witcher 3 *GO WOKE GO BROKE* 1 point for this bald head guy in this game 1/10”

0/10
“ Im a fan of dragón age, but this is a piece of ****, a dont want to be a non binari. The world is ending wtf and nonbinan wrf”

0/10
“ Only liberals are giving this trash anything above a 5+. More woke garbage.”

I don’t expect this game to be anything above an 8 but come on man.

178d ago Replies(4)
LordoftheCritics178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

Extreme reactions but is legit from their point of view.

They clearly won't buy it but they are potential customers as well.

The game does give off sufficient data that you could call it negative masculine or leaning towards certain biases or being sermonic in nature etc
I could see it but i just ignore it like its just 3d models and get straight into combat.
Some ppl cannot go into ignore mode for whatever reasons whether personal or political stances, and that's the backlash you'd get.

Also I believe the reviewing bombing was started by the 10's everywhere.

Armaggedon178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

Are you referring to the critic reviews? I only saw two perfect scores.

Vx_177d ago

Trump will fix this shit, can't wait.

DankSinatra177d ago

Fix what? Expression? That's not something a president has the power to do. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean it's something that needs to be fixed. I swear you people love by a "i hate everything I don't agree with" mentality.

anast178d ago (Edited 178d ago )

They should respond to the paid reviews form advertisement sites and the review bombers. Steam reviews went from 76% to 74% and dropping. The game is average. It shouldn't get bombed, but it also shouldn't be hyped up with IGN 10s.

SoloZelot90178d ago

Irresponsible reviewers pointing fingers at irresponsible reviewers. It's a joke.

HankHill178d ago

Agreed. Everyone keeps glossing over the fact that this game had paid review shenanigans.

I don't agree with the review bombing or the blatant shill reviews.

Armaggedon178d ago

They paid for 6/10 scores? Sounds like a rip off

Armaggedon177d ago

“Paid reviews” people gotta let that idea go. Is it that hard to conceive that they actually thought the game was good? And Ign gave it a 9, not a 10

177d ago
anast177d ago

Yes, it's hard to conceive that people that have seen thousands of video games and thought about them critically can give this game a 9 or a 10 based on the objective aspects of the game.

Show all comments (68)
130°

DLC Wouldn't Have Fixed Dragon Age: The Veilguard, But It Deserved Some Anyway

Dragon Age: The Veilguard was never going to be one of those games that gets "fixed" with updates, but DLC could've let the devs tell their own story.

Read Full Story >>
thegamer.com
GhostScholar13d ago

I know everyone hates this game, but I have had a blast with it. I enjoyed the combat, characters (for the most part), and the story. Not to mention the environments are beautiful. I like this game more than dragon age 2 or inquisition.

raWfodog12d ago (Edited 12d ago )

I’m still playing through Inquisition now but will hop into Veilguard after that. I was surprised when it was added to PS+ Essentials last month. I’ll see for myself if it deserves all the hate or not.

Lexreborn212d ago

The best thing about options and people is. Things are allowed to cater to others and they enjoy it, and it’s equally okay if you don’t individually vibe with something.

What’s not okay is over criticizing something due to your personal bias and agendas. Campaigning against harmless things that don’t truly dictate anything in your life. I’m not into dragon age games, but I never once made an agenda to tell people how “bad” each iteration is because it didn’t click for me.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 12d ago
Rancegamerx13d ago

This game deserves nothing more than to be buried in the annals of history, only to resurface decades later as a cautionary tale of the astonishing foolishness that prevailed in 2024.

GhostScholar12d ago

You must have not played a truly bad game I’d you think this is a bad game.

Snookies1212d ago

This game was a mockery to the Dragon Age series. I lost all faith in the series thanks to this one.

GhostScholar12d ago

I can see not liking the change in combat but that’s about the only criticism I could give it and I actually had a blast as a veil jumper archer. To each his own I’m not saying it’s the greatest game ever but it’s my favorite dragon age game since origins

TheColbertinator12d ago

That's what people say about every new Dragon Age game. Many fans almost gave up on the series after Dragon Age 2. Even more stopped caring for Inquisition because despite the high reviews, fans of the original Bioware hated the gameplay. Some players never even left the first area "The Hinterlands".

Asterphoenix12d ago

Lots of the main Bioware team is gone from years ago. The site is silly if they want to fix it they would have to re-do everything.

They might as well make a new entry. They should take fan feedback rather than ignoring them to push an agenda.

Definitely didn't feel like a Dragon Age game.

GhostScholar12d ago

I just don’t get that critique. Graphics were great, characters were great, story was great, and I liked the combat as well. Like I said to each his own. It sucks for the people who didn’t like it, but I really enjoyed it.

PanicMechanic11d ago

Characters and story were sure as hell not great at all.

Rancegamerx11d ago

The characters were great? In what universe? They were thinly disguised activists shoehorned into a fantasy setting, prioritizing forced ideology over genuine storytelling. Calling them "great' is an insult to the art of character creation. They lacked depth, relatability, and purpose—a mess that even garbage would resent being compared to.

11d ago
dmonee12d ago

The DLC was supposed to feature a blond haired dude, with orange skin, that bans all woke nonsense from the game.

110°

BioWare Co-Founder Praises Dragon Age Veilguard, Says Long Gaps Between Games Raise Fan Expectations

Bioware co-founder Greg Zeshuck has praised Dragon Age: The Veilguard, saying that lengthy gaps between game releases raise fan expectations.

Read Full Story >>
twistedvoxel.com
Redgrave64d ago

Long gaps to an extent, but too long and you enter into impossible expectations and loss of interest. The balance is hard to allow for adequate development time and avoid over inflation of the product, but such a thing aa too long is absolutely a thing.

Dragon Age Veilguard I think was too long, especially after what we ended up getting. Mass Effect 5, if not canceled, will likely suffer a similar fate.

NoDamage64d ago

No it does not. There were no expectations for this game since pretty much nothing was ever really shown to increase hype....the only hype for this game was self generated because of the love of the franchise. It was nothing extreme...and yet they still failed.

There was more hype for anthem then for this game.

goken64d ago

The Self delusion is strong with this one…

-Foxtrot64d ago

Who raised their expectations? People have been iffy with new BioWare games in general since they screwed up the ending of ME3 and they just got lower until Anthem really put us all on a downer

The fact it was so low and still got people disappointed showed you how bad this was.

I’m sorry but simply put he’s talking s***

TheColbertinator64d ago (Edited 64d ago )

The gap between Veilguard and Inquisition was an issue of course but the pressing problem was the lack of confidence towards Bioware after Andromeda and Anthem. These two games were to be pillars of Bioware's continued dominance in the RPG market. In the days since other RPG developers have come to take the center stage and push out Bioware. Obsidian, Bethesda, CDPR and Larian are among the many developers who have staked their claim since DA Inquisition launched.

620°

PlayStation Plus Monthly Games for March

PlayStation Plus Monthly Games for March – Dragon Age: The Veilguard (PS5), Sonic Colors: Ultimate (PS4), Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Cowabunga Collection (PS4 /PS5)

All playable March 4.

Read Full Story >>
blog.playstation.com
Terry_B65d ago

I was happy with the last two PS+ Essential Game Lineups too, but this one is a ton cooler. Owned TMNT Collection on PC already, but will most likely play it again on the bigger screen.

Is Dragon Age The Veilguard worth the time it probably needs? Liked the previous games of the series a lot.

pwnmaster300065d ago (Edited 65d ago )

I mean no harm in trying.
I’m glad it is because I was just gonna buy it.
I usually just grab any monthly game.
I have so much games that I’ve never played sitting in my library because of the monthly games lol. Do they have an expiration?

Popsicle65d ago

So long as you stay subscribed they stay in your library.

Terry_B65d ago

Only if you unsubscribe to ps+..but even if you make a subscription pause of years, they would be back if you subscribe again with the same PSN account ^^

Back in August '24 I started the crazy quest to try and beat as many of the ..around 350 PS4+PS5 ps+ games I have + a few bought one sin physical form ..since I started subscribing back in 2013 already. From A-Z.

Played through a weird game named 2064 Read Only Memories..had a lot of fun and almost tears with the damn awesome 2 "A Plague Tale" games, enjoyed Alan Wake, Aliens Fireteam Squad or what its called and a couple more games started with A.

When I was at the standalone dlc for Assassins creed IV Black Flag I bought that friggin whole game and beat it because I liked the dlc.

Now in february 2025 I am still at fucking letter B because I also bought Barman Arkham Collection and just beat Arkham City, Getting the time for all these games that are good and come for such a small price is more soulslike than anything from FromSoftware.

Lets see if I make it to Letter D by the end of the year >:I

65d ago
Eonjay64d ago

This really feel like good value for the plus sub. Can't wait to give DA and Sonic a try. Already have TMNT

Jingsing63d ago (Edited 63d ago )

@Terry_B How is PS+ good value if for example I haven't been subscribed for 5 years, Then 5 years later I want to play a game I got on the service. I have to pay $100 or more whatever the price will be in the future, almost certainly higher. That isn't value at all having to pay a high access fee for an old 10 year old game. Nothing about game subscriptions make financial sense unless you can keep them in your library without having to constantly pay for it. That is how they make the money and you ultimately lose as a consumer.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 63d ago
Tacoboto65d ago

Dragon Age has a fun combat system that offers good challenge on the higher difficulty (haven't tried normal).

I'm about 10-12 hours in, on PC where it runs so well, and just got Lucanis in my party. Graphics are nice, audio is good, quality of voice actors is also good.

The only problem at this point is there are signs of overly-positive writing and one character I've complained about before that is especially annoying.

I haven't played more because of other games, not because it isn't fun or the writing is *that* off-putting.

Maybe as I play more I'll like it less, but for now, I know enough about the tone of the writing that I can brush that aside and enjoy a fun game with acting that's still good despite some of what they're given - the core of what's been about the story is written better than when it's about or involving that specific irritating character.

VenomUK65d ago

For Dragon Age: The Veilguard to be included in PS Plus so soon after release just goes to show how far EA/Bioware shit the bed.

thorstein65d ago

I'd place it just below Inquisition. There are parts that I really enjoyed getting into the backstory about, especially the infractions with Solas. Luckily there are many companions and you can usually pick who you want with you.

The character stories are decent, with some being quite enjoyable.

nitus1064d ago

I spent a few hours on Inquisition and while I think the gameplay was fine I just lost interest. Of course I did have Dark Souls 2, 3, Bloodborne and a suite of RPG's that I also wanted to play at the time.

Oh well I will bookmark all the games in case I eventually wish to play them.

Luc2065d ago

Playing all these games sounds like a full time job! No doubt you'll come across a gem once in a while.

Abear2164d ago

If it wasn’t for GT7 I’d probably finish more games. Want TMNT just for the nostalgia high and will play it some, but backlog be damned!

I’m only adding must play games to the pile bc I’m already a year behind haven’t started RE4 yet or Alan Wake 2, hopefully news of GTA6 or RDR2 remaster happens by the time I finish them. Probably finish Skyrim before I play Veilguard.

Daeloki64d ago

Veilguard is fun to a degree, but sadly falls a bit short from its predecessors. I bought it at release because I was excited to have it, but sadly I was a bit blinded to actual valid criticism by all the typical loud anti-woke rantings. As in, by the time I wanted to check reviews, all you could really see was grown white men crying about pronouns and other optional character features, and all actual criticism was kinda drowned out.

That said, I think the gameplay is fun, although it can get a bit repetitive. It looks stunning in my opinnion, but the writing isn't very deep. Everyone gets along a bit too well, there is no real friction or risk of uppsetting your companions. Visually it's very pleasing, spells and abilities are flashy and cool, and combat is very fluid and dynamic. The companions had initially interesting storylines, but they kinda fell short despite the potential.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 63d ago
isarai65d ago

Ooh Sonic colors. I never actually got around to beating my Wii copy. I hope it's been improved cuz I heard at lunch it wasn't the best

Terry_B65d ago

Much better graphics, better controls, more languages, a new game mode even some decently remixed music tracks

DoubleYourDose65d ago

Definitely better for a late night snack.

Profchaos65d ago

Yeah same I struggled with the Wii version back in the day because it ran terrible so I'm excited to play this

Cockney64d ago

Someone told me at breakfast the game was a bit on the woke side, I won't download it till after dinner, maybe ill hear different by then

thorstein64d ago (Edited 64d ago )

A companion has an optional storyline about their gender. If you choose to go through that particular companion storyline, you can button beat the dialog and avoid it.

That stuff doesn't bother me at all, but I found that character annoying anyway.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 64d ago
jambola65d ago (Edited 65d ago )

So how long until skull and bones is on ps+?
they love throwing the leftover slop on there lately

rest is cool though
can't beat those Konami collections

Profchaos65d ago

Absolutely it's coming to be honest I'd rather play the underwater tnmt NES level on repeat than start dragon age

Popsicle65d ago (Edited 65d ago )

I am absolutely more excited about the Cowabunga collection when compared to the other 2 offerings. In all honesty it is probably the only game out of the 3 that I will get around to playing.

ravens5265d ago

I just bought Dragon Age too lol. $25 off Amazon. Guess I'll just leave it sealed then 🤷🏾.

badz14963d ago

LOL how many times have this happened to me haha

OtterX65d ago (Edited 65d ago )

Wow, pretty amazing as Veilguard just came out in October. Opinions have been pretty mixed, but I'll happily try it out for free. I loved Inquisition, but I know to keep my expectations lower for this one.

As for TMNT collection, I had bought for Switch a long while back so i could have it for portable play. I'm really happy to get it again on PS5 for trophies.

crazyCoconuts65d ago

Yeah highly unusual to have it Veilguard on PS+ so soon! Don't know if that's a statement of how great PS+ is, how poorly Veilguard did, or a combination of both.

raWfodog65d ago

Yup, get to try it out for myself sooner rather than later without having to 'buy' it. It's really telling that this next DA game has been shifted to PS Plus so soon after its release but I'm still willing to give it a go after the lackluster reviews.

Ninver65d ago (Edited 65d ago )

Try it out you may. But know that nothing is free.

Show all comments (55)