Submitted by Blues Cowboy 983d ago | news

Microsoft & Sony Rivalry Blocking Defiance Cross-Platform Multiplayer

Dealspwn.com reports: "Having spent several hours getting to grips with Defiance, it's clear that Trion's ambitious cooperative MMO shooter currently allows for smooth cross-platform play between PC, PS3 and Xbox 360 versions. However, Microsoft and Sony aren't willing to set aside their bitter rivalry for long enough to make it work at launch - if ever.

"There will not be cross-platform play," Trion Worlds Senior Producer Robert Hill told us during a lengthy interview scheduled for publication later today. "We do it right now." (Defiance, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

AngelicIceDiamond  +   983d ago
I dunno why, I think the idea is great. 2 systems cooperating and intertwining in a MMO is a good idea.

Fanboys would have a chance to get along with one an other and work as a team. But MS and Sony doesn't want that. Instead they rather keep the tension and both fanboys at bay Or they don't want any possible cross promotion.

Whatever the case is its too bad on MS and Sony's part.
MikeMyers  +   983d ago
Well, I guess that settles it. We will all just have to continue seeing the rivalries here on the forums. Yay.
darthv72  +   983d ago
i always wondered
why they didnt have more crossplatform games.

Unreal was a game that pitted pc vs ps3 but could have added in 360 vs pc vs ps3 for even more interesting play. A shame they cant settle whatever differences keep such things from happening.

I seem to recall it had something to do with mod support or the availability of current patches that would need to be made available to all platforms at the same time.

Ms and sony have different approval processes for such things but the PC side is much quicker to respond. Or something like that.
MikeMyers  +   983d ago
Different types of communities between the PC and consoles. You also get into the mix with people using a mouse/keyboard against those with a controller. I know the PS3 supports it but I imagine most people use the dualshock. The PC is also more quick because it doesn't have all the mandates put in place. Microsoft has their set of rules, Sony has theirs.

Microsoft really dropped the ball since they also run Windows. They look to finally be tying Windows 8 into one unified service across different hardware. Apple has done it with iTunes by making it very familiar for everyone. That's one of the knocks with Android and how you have various operating systems and not cohesive.

Plus with Xbox Live it really backlashed on the PC. You can't really charge for Live on the PC because Microsoft does not control the PC gaming market. Some may argue against any fee but they can get away with it more on the console because it's a closed platform.

I don't ever see Playstation and Xbox running on the same server. I think it would be fun but it's not going to happen. Correct me if I'm wrong but Dust 514 I think only shares the same universe but PC and PS3 players don't play directly with one another.
#1.1.2 (Edited 983d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
elhebbo16  +   983d ago
i dunno, i think the tension would actually get worse. there is always gonna be one immature fanboy who's gonna say 'my controller is better' or 'the graphics look better from this side' then the whole in-game chat session goes to shit.
Skips  +   983d ago
Wasn't Sony ok with the cross platform MP for Counter Strike or something. But Valve was the one that ultimately pulled the plug (For good reasons).

I could be wrong, but that's what I heard.
#1.3 (Edited 983d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
violents  +   983d ago
Ps3 has already gone cross platform with games like dust 514. I think MS just doesn't want to play nice so its a no go.
Ben_Grimm  +   983d ago
MS did cross platform with games like Shadowrun. I think Sony just doesn't want to play nice so it's a no go.
violents  +   983d ago
so then we'll agree to disagree then?
Welshy  +   983d ago
That's not true at all @Ben_Grimm

Dust 514 interacts directly with EVE Online servers, Portal 2 allowed you to play with PC players and Counterstrike was penned to have cross platform but Valve pulled the plug in the polishing stages as KB&M users were too accurate in comparison to pads and would unbalance online matches.

Let's not forget, that despite both running Via PSN, the Vita can play PS3 users too which is still technically cross platform.

Not to mention the fact that XBL being a paid service, 360 users who didn't have gold would feel (rightfully) aggrieved that both PC and PS3 guys get to play each other at no extra cost but they have to cought up another £40 to Microsoft for the privelage.

XBL being paid and PSN being free is the major block on cross platform MS/Sony games in my opinion.
JBSleek  +   983d ago
PS3 has one cross platform game and that came isn't really cross platform actually as PC isn't Dust and it just has some effect on it.
violents  +   983d ago
actually It has a few that are ps3/vita. That is technically cross platform as well.
SmokingMonkey  +   983d ago
Portal2 is cross platform betwixt PSN and Steam.
DonMingos  +   983d ago
final fantasy XIV, Portal 2...
Saryk  +   983d ago
One game wouldn't make everything just peachy. Besides I would like to see someone take their thunder!
hkgamer  +   983d ago
its probably microsoft not allowing it.
its kinda hard to justify xbox live when other platforms do it for free.

ffxi had crossplay but you didnt need xbox live gold membership to play it. and i dont think microsoft liked that.

another reason for this is releasing patch updates, would be a pain to release for sony, ms and pc at the same time
Hicken  +   983d ago
Seeing how strict they are with their online, you can bet it's Microsoft and not Sony. I remember them saying something like, "We can't guarantee the quality of online gaming on another console, and we don't want to expose our consumers to that," or something to to that extent.

Which sounds to me like, "We'd be screwed if our consumers started realizing they could get the same quality of online gaming elsewhere for free."
Ben_Grimm  +   983d ago
Of course it's all MS's fault coming from Hicken and the lot.

Even though MS has allowed cross platform games before in the past with Shadowrun, Universe at War: Earth Assault and I believe Lost Planet: Colonies(??).

But yea its most likely MS's fault, lord knows Sony can do no wrong.
ALLWRONG  +   983d ago
"We'd be screwed if our consumers started realizing they could get the same quality of online gaming elsewhere for free."

You mean like charging people for downloading in the background?
Outside_ofthe_Box  +   983d ago
***"You mean like charging people for downloading in the background?"***

LOL What are you talking about? People have been downloading stuff in the background way before PS+ started. My Ni No Kuni demo downloaded in the background. What are you smoking lol?

I find it hilarious that you see a problem with downloading things in the background being a premium feature, but online multiplayer for a game you already paid for being a premium feature is okey-dokey for you LOL.

MS does have more to lose doing cross platform MP, but I doubt Sony wants to do it either. What do Sony and MS gain from doing it besides making their gamers happy? Nothing. Yeah I know both have done it before, but with the PS360 cross-platform play both companies actually risk losing their customers to their direct competitors.
#4.1.3 (Edited 983d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(3) | Report
DonMingos  +   983d ago
I am all in for cross platform multiplayer.

Would love to play some co-op (aliens colonial marines) with some friends that only have the other console.

Plus, what better place for fanboys to settle their differences than on the battleground of a game. Would love some team deathmatch between team PS3, team Xbox360 and Team WiiU. That would be the kind of rivalry that makes sense in the gaming community
Blues Cowboy  +   983d ago
Agreed, such a move would massively benefit us gamers. Problem is that shareholders are the priority...
hkgamer  +   983d ago
funny how you included nintendos console... i totally forgot about them...
k-dillinger  +   983d ago
Why would Sony wanna cross play with someone who isn't on there level like m$ in terms of gaming that's like asking scar face to come to a sit down meeting with the guy he overthrew no no never
Dlacy13g  +   983d ago
The Sony / MS rivalry kills games like this. Points above like MS not wanting their customer base seeing other gamers getting to play for free certainly I would think factors into it. I am sure there is not wanting to expose your customer to a rival on both sides of it. Additionally you have to wonder if either side worries that if their version of the game is super popular with their base that they would artifically make the other versions user base feel bigger than it is.

In a nut shell its gaming politics.
Blues Cowboy  +   983d ago
@Dlacy13g (reply fail, sorry!): Agreed - and it's even more annoying since gold members have already paid up-front and the extra cash should make it easier to sort out the servers on their end. Massively generalising I know, but I'd rather see my Gold subs spent on cool new initiatives like this rather than poxy 30 day timed exclusives (frankly I'm getting much more out of my free PS+ games atm and might not bother renewing my Gold come April).

Once again, it's a shame that politics are getting in the way of giving us a properly connected universe to explore!
#8 (Edited 983d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
mayberry  +   983d ago
wasn't portal 2 cross platform on ps3 also?
Blues Cowboy  +   983d ago
Yeah, just had to link Steam & PSN accounts I think.
JasonKCK  +   983d ago
this would be so cool if they made it happen
TXIDarkAvenger  +   983d ago
This would be an awesome idea, however I don't think MS will play along.

I can see this being a cross platform between PS3 and PC similar to what they did with Portal 2.
InTheLab  +   983d ago
Never gonna happen. Imagine Xbox and PS3 gamers playing the same game with a shared online community. Now what will happen when Xbox gamers realize they've been lied to for 7 years about how good XBL is over it's competitors....

I also recall MS saying something about not being able to guarantee performance of Live when linked with other services, so they were not interested.
Belking  +   983d ago
That would be like Apple and Google teaming up to create a phone. It's not gonna happen. Not surprised that some here are blaming MS.
stage88  +   983d ago
PS3 and PC can do cross-platform multiplayer. But guess who doesn't want to join in the fun. Surprise, surprise....
Belking  +   983d ago
It's not a question of can do. All of them can do it, but they won't which is makes good business sense. Once again, everything is MS fault. This is N4G so it doesn't surprise me. Most gamers probably don't even care about it. Only the loyal fanboys.
stage88  +   983d ago
No idea what you're talking about. Sony and PS3 are doing it eg. Portal and Dust 514 just off the top of my head. I look forward to more games like this as my and my PC friends had a blast on Portal. The only one that isn't doing it and won't play ball is MS. Don't turn this into fanboy war.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Uncharted 4 Sound Designers Will Appear on Dolby Soundworks Collection Podcast

10m ago - "Naughty Dog sound designers Rob Krekel and Phillip Kovats will be appearing on the Dolby Institu... | PS4

Watch Dogs Review: Right to be Forgotten - Without the Sarcasm

10m ago - Watch_Dogs has a few good ideas. The plot centers on our privacy in a constantly connected world,... | PC

PC Games Still To Come This Month

Now - We're halfway through the hottest month of the year, but there's plenty more PC games still to come, so don't go outside just yet! Let's take a loo... | Promoted post

6 Ways the Riddler is Batman's Least Effective Nemesis in the Arkham Games

12m ago - OX writes: The Riddler is one of the most enduring members of Batman's rogue's gallery, despite... | PC

Impressed by Dishonored's new-gen visuals? Here are the best prices

13m ago - Dealspwn: Dishonored: Definitive Edition is out now and should be on the radars of anyone that di... | PS4

Lara Croft GO Review | Pocket Gamer

14m ago - PG: You only have to suffer through 30 seconds of the crushingly bad Tomb Raider 1 port on iPhon... | iPhone