Duh, different writers. Just like any other website, funny that!
A Team Ico HD Collection along with (or including) The Last Guardian would be amazing. Of course, trophies would be the added bonus.
Challenging and fun solo campaign, awesome with three buddies, decent online modes. It's much better than a lot of the games out this year.
Reviews = opinions. It's an old argument. That particular reviewer liked DA2 enough to give it full marks. Perhaps another writer would disagree. The review text says more than the score does generally.