320°
7.5

Starfield review | PC Gamer

It's Bethesda's biggest RPG by far, but nowhere near its best.

330d ago
RupeeHoarder330d ago

This is NOT the release Xbox needed. The hits just keep on coming. This game needed to be a literal 10/10 GOTY candidate. Well, back to the old Forza Motorsport drawing board, hope everyone loves racing games.

crazyCoconuts330d ago

And this is with all of Xbox coming together to make this game shine over the last year or so. Well at least there's an Imagine Dragons music video

MatrixxGT330d ago

So a game has to be a 9 or 10 to be good? If they gave it 9’s and 10’s you guys complain about Bethesda getting a free pass. A legit 7.5 and it’s all sudden a horrible unplayable waste of time..smh.

At this point why don’t we get rid of review scores all together and just go with a “buy” “don’t buy” system.

shinoff2183330d ago

I think Sony fans are just giving back the same energy xbox fans gave out. Not even just recently but even back during 360 ps3. If your old enough my God xbox fans went hard.

RupeeHoarder330d ago

a 7.5 is absolutely a disappointment for Starfield considering the hype and the lack of anything to play.

MrNinosan330d ago

That's not the point.
Xbox has had many mediocre to good games, but 0 exceptional games which they really need. All the hopes has been put on Starfield to carry that flag, and many of us, Sony-fans as well, would've hoped that was going to happen.

If MS can't give us the Sony-versions of God of War, Last of Us and Spider-Man, by buying up the best studios around the world, how will the future shape.

I will play through Starfield and hopefully love it, but not being close to perfect will have a negative effect, especially on this game and of the worth of GamePass.

kneon329d ago

It's not what xbox needed, but it's what was to be expected given their track record

MontyeKristo329d ago

A 7.5 is not even a bad score. Idk why there's this huge misconception that anything under a 9 is a bad game.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 329d ago
Si-Fly330d ago

Oh well … back to BG3 then.

Tapani329d ago

The major Patch 2 is awesome! Most of the problems were fixed, and performance is also better. Just in time for the final part of the game which I landed in after 110 hrs :)

VenomUK329d ago

I don’t normally hold much stock in individual reviews anymore, but i looked at the Starfield reviews as a collective to see which way the wind is blowing and was surprised to see some lower marks - this PC Gamer review and the IGN review make clear the main criticism: The lack of a unified space travel system which reduces that sense of an open world / open universe.

Si-Fly329d ago

It’s an odd situation because the sites giving the lowest scores are the ones I’d usually just ignore anyway! I’ve been listening to NoClip’s Starfield podcast this morning and they’ve actually got my hype levels back up to the point I’m considering paying for the early access when I’m back from work tonight 🤣

Dazelya330d ago Show
execution17330d ago

Just like the xbox simps giving it perfect scores even tho the game dips to single digit frames, buggy ai, bugs, can't even fly to or from planets cause it's just static, planet exploration pales in comparison to no mans sky

Yung-T330d ago

Author literally says he worshipped Elder Scrolls&Fallout and played hundreds of hours on each one, even going as far as roleplaying as an NPC.

At least read the article and try to make a sound argument, instead of being a blind fanboy and writing absolute nonsense here.

anast330d ago

I keep seeing it's Fallout 4/Skyrim. It's Bethesda sleaze right there.

FGHFGHFGH330d ago

The Fallout aliens should be in it. If not, deduct a point from the score.

Show all comments (25)
290°

10 "Bad" Games I Actually Enjoyed

TNS: "We're shining a light on a bunch of "bad" games that may've been left wanting when it comes to their critical or audience reception."

Read Full Story >>
thenerdstash.com
Profchaos2d ago (Edited 2d ago )

Good list I've had similar reactions to some games even ones on the list like the order and Callisto

Also I recently grabbed forspoken for, 5 dollars at a eb games Clarence sale and I am actually enjoying it more than I thought I would

Sometimes you just need to give critically panned games a chance

FTLmaster2d ago

Oh gosh, good shout on Forspoken! Genuinely forgot about that one, and haven't got around to playing it. It's on my to-buy-in-a-sale list!

Cacabunga1d 12h ago (Edited 1d 12h ago )

Knack was great ! Had a blast with the first one. Haven’t tried the second one though due to backlog

The Fight: Lights Out was also a game i enjoyed very much and highly detailed with great motion control when you understand how they work, which is what pushed people away from this game..

LoveSpuds1d 10h ago

Both The Order and Calisto were harshly treated in my view. I am not saying they are perfect, but the were both really solid games. I personally really liked them despite acknowledging their flaws and coincidentally, got the platinum trophy for both games.

Evil West is another really fun game that's worth checking out for sure.

andy851d 10h ago

Forspoken was great. Never really understood all the criticism. 2nd best traversal in a game after Spiderman

Profchaos1d 3h ago

Yeah gameplay wise I get huge infamous vibes with its combat starting out as low level eventually becoming a unstoppable power spewing killing machine with a wide variety of powers infamous is one of my favourite franchises obviously it's not the same but I love the combat of it so far.

ChasterMies2d ago

I feel like we’re finally starting to see a sea change in how we treat our favorite games. Sure, we all acknowledge that a game can suck and we can still enjoy it. Hopefully this results in meaningful review scores. Personally, I find a lot of bad games are better if you blast through them on the easiest difficulty. Callisto protocol on the image is a good example of this.

LoveSpuds1d 10h ago (Edited 1d 10h ago )

I really liked Calisto, harshly treated for sure and I don't necessarily think it needs to be played on easy to enjoy it. It's not perfect, but it's not the car crash the media portrayed it as either.

I have said it before, but part of the issue is that there is a mind share going on in games coverage, with all the main outfits being personal friends and talking too each other. As such, there is a risk that everyone ends up sharing in the same opinion rather than thinking from themselves. I reckon that's why some games get a universal bashing when consumers actually like the game and equally, games get great reviews across the board and the game doesnt land with consumers.

RaidenBlack2d ago (Edited 2d ago )

Actually, I started liking FO76 after the wastelanders DLC ... it has been my guilty pleasure
other games I can think of Order 1886, Driveclub, Resident Evil 6 (only the Leon part), Alpha Protocol (pretty unique, needs a remake), XIII Remake (after patches), Medal of Honor 2010, Medal of Honor Warfighter, Homefront The Revolution, Enemy Front, Legendary The Box, Faces of War, Conflict: Vietnam, Conflict: Global Storm & Codename: Panzers – Cold War

CosmicTurtle2d ago

Driveclub was genuinely a good game with a poor launch. Alpha Protocol is superb, just a few archaic design choices for the time.

RaidenBlack1d 11h ago

I want past games with interesting setups/mechanics but having some flaws (due to crunch or budget) to be remade so that the gaming community can appreciate and enjoy them as was envisioned and intended by the developers. In contrast to a successful game being remade again just with prettier coat of paint.
Alpha Protocol tops that and I'll include FO:NV as well as an exception (it is popular but features were cut due to limited dev time). And also Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines I, Singularity, KOTOR II and maybe Daikatana.
There might be others which I can't recall atm.

SonyStyled2d ago

I loved Enemy Front. I pre ordered it months prior and remember calling the store to check if it came out that day. The guy never heard of it but confirmed my copy was ready to pick up. Game was simple and basic in a good way. Didn’t have any tacked on extras. A simple mission and objectives in each level. Kind of reminded me of the first Crysis in a way

gold_drake2d ago

The Order was really good. abit short

RiseNShine2d ago

I loved The Order, ridiculous graphics for it's time and a very interesting setting, it was linear but not as bad as people say. Similar thing with Callisto Protocol, i admit that i played it a long time after release so maybe issues were fixed by then, but it was a fantastic Dead Space-like horror game with some of the best graphics i've seen in my life.

LoveSpuds1d 10h ago

Yup, I am afraid to say I waited on Calisto and picked it up for around 30 quid. Once I played it on felt really badly for the devs because the game was really decent.

Show all comments (26)
100°

Earth Becomes Habitable Again in Starfield, Thanks to this Mod

Thanks to the Starfield Creation Kit, the "Earth Restored" mod has transformed the Earth into a Pine Forest and filled the sea with life.

Read Full Story >>
gamerstones.com
4d ago
130°

Starfield DLC needs to be as awe-inspiring as Shadow of the Erdtree to win players back

Shadow of the Erdtree saw a 1000% player count surge at its launch. Will Starfield’s Shattered Space be able to do the same?

Read Full Story >>
starfielddb.com
Brazz14d ago

Spoiler... It Will not. Bethesda is outdated.

anast14d ago

If it gets rid of the loading screens and adds space exploration, it will.

phoenixwing14d ago

loading screens and zones are hardboiled into the game, they would have to remake it to change it. which if they had just made a new engine or used someone else's they wouldn't be in this mess

purple10114d ago

only PSpro release will get rid of there loading, at at minimum, half the time it takes.

lucian22914d ago

nah cuz game has multiple things that have to happen before transition to outer space; issue is it isnt seamless

BoneMagnus14d ago

I played Starfield this past weekend. I enjoyed it and overall was about 30 hours in, but as soon as I got the e-mail about the GamePass price increase, I cancelled my account and deleted Starfield, Halo, Forza and others off my Series X.

If I want to play those games, I’ll just buy them outright - and truth is, I’m pretty sure I won’t. They aren’t worth it to me.

Ninver14d ago

Brutal truth. Thanks gor being honest.

Show all comments (18)