Sarcasticgamer.com picks it's final Nominee for Game of the Year, and it's a controversial one.
From the article: "This is it. The last pick. The final of the five. Its controversial, but it's all mine. Look, there were a ton of GREAT games released this year. Of the games that I played, there are a few that stood out to me. Several notables under consideration include Gears of War 2, GTA IV, Dead Space, NBA 2K9, Fable 2, Too Human (yes Too Human) and perhaps Call of Duty: World at War. All are fine games. All could be Sarcastic Gamer's fifth Nominee for Game of the Year.
Find out what the controversial pick is, after the jump."