Approvals 9/3 ▼
mania568 (2) - 2621d ago Cancel
LaFleur (5) - 2620d ago Cancel
strayanalog (2) - 2621d ago Cancel
130°

Making the grade: Why tying anything to aggregate review scores is bad

The culture around aggregate review scores, people being so obsessed with them and companies often tying developers livelihoods around them needs to change...

Read Full Story >>
apptrigger.com
Create Report !X

Add Report

Reports

+ Updates (1)- Updates (1)

Updates

Changed from Pending to Approved
Community2620d ago
Hardiman2620d ago

A review or meta score won't stop me from liking or supporting agame. Mafia III was a good game but it was repetitious. That being said I think it sucks bonuses are tied to scores!

Now when a game like GOW comes along and racks up the critical reviews it's hard not to take notice! I was hopeful it would do well(because SP games seem to be in constant danger to some in the industry) but I was not expecting it to be universally praised but I'll take it!

At the end of the day If GOW hadn't of reviewed as well I still be getting it on Thursday and be just as excited!

xHeavYx2620d ago

I just wish people would stop worrying about Metacritic do much.
An article have GoW an 8.6 and people were worried about the score showing on Metacritic. It's just pathetic

Silly gameAr2620d ago

Yeah, I thought that was pretty cringeworthy to be honest.

rainslacker2620d ago

Not many companies for bonuses to review scores anymore. The review system became too fickle, and most devs had no control over the producers who did things which affected the score negatively.

Most bonuses nowadays are tied to sales, but a poorly revised game often doesn't sell as well.

SegaGamer2620d ago

I just think the obsession with review scores has gotten completely out of control. It's gotten so bad now that even when a game get's an 8, rabid fanboys are going mental about it. It's gotten so bad that they can't even see their own hypocrisy. A few weeks back, IGN reviewed Ni No Kuni, it didn't score massively high so most fanboys started saying things like "this is why IGN shouldn't be taken seriously" or "IGN are a joke". Then God of War comes out and IGN give it a 10 and the fanboys love them again.

How can you even have an intelligent discussion with these people? they're insane.

Review scores are taken WAY too seriously. Just play your damn games, even if it was rated 1 out of 10, you're still allowed to enjoy it and it can even be your favourite game if you like it that much. All a review is is an opinion, can you really not look beyond somebody else's opinion of a game?

letsa_go2620d ago

It is one of the only tools we have to fight the crap that companies like EA have been putting into their games. It lights a candle under the developers asses not to screw it up or they will be sent to the unemployment line. I don't know where this mentality came from that we have to coddle the developers and support them even when they put out shit games. That just encourages them and other companies to release more shitty, incomplete games with microtransactions. They need to be held accountable so we don't get a bunch of unfinished shovelware.

Razzer2620d ago

" A few weeks back, IGN reviewed Ni No Kuni, it didn't score massively high so most fanboys started saying things like "this is why IGN shouldn't be taken seriously" or "IGN are a joke". Then God of War comes out and IGN give it a 10 and the fanboys love them again. "

Uh.....did you go and check to see if the exact same people said these things about both games? Or are these just different people having different reactions to different game reviews?

Inzo2620d ago

I dont trust average review scores for the most part especially user reviews and especially for exclusive games. GOW is sitting at 94 on Metacritic but I expect it to have a 7.0 to 7.5 user review, not because its a bad game but because it is going to be flooded by negative reviews from disgruntled and salty Xbox fanboys. This is a fact that history teaches us.

Dark_Knightmare22620d ago

It’s actually 95 on metacritic :)

Razzer2620d ago

Well yeah, user reviews on metacritic are just trash. I don't pay them any attention at all.

Inzo2620d ago

Go and have a look at how many of those user reviews are flat out 0/10 with no reason given as to why.

michellelynn09762620d ago

I know. Mario and Zelda got those as well. Seriously, people need to stop that. Both Horizon and Zelda are much better than their Metacritic fan scores say they are. Is it any wonder no one takes those scores serious anymore?

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 2620d ago
CrimsonWing692620d ago

It bums me out when a game I’m interested in gets a bad review score but I’ll still buy the game or check it out for myself. I’m usually 50/50 with review scores. Some games that review bad I thoroughly enjoyed while some that review good I didn’t like. So there ta’ go.

160°

PlayStation Store "Mid-Year Deals" Sale Starts and Includes Titles That Don't Get Discounted Often

PlayStation Store "Mid-Year Deals" sale kicks off, and it includes some never-before-seen discounts and houses over 3,800 items.

Create Report !X

Add Report

Reports

+ Updates (1)- Updates (1)

Updates

Changed from Pending to Approved
Community9h ago
310°

Sony PS5 Era Profits Soar Past $13 Billion, Outpacing All Prior PlayStation Generations

Sony’s PS5 era has generated over $13 billion in profits, surpassing the combined earnings of PS1–PS4, with $136 billion in sales.

Read Full Story >>
inspire2rise.com
Create Report !X

Add Report

Reports

+ Updates (1)- Updates (1)

Updates

Changed from Pending to Approved
Community14h ago
lukasmain18h ago(Edited 18h ago)

Their recent Playstation revenue is also more than Xbox and Switch combined, obviously in large part due to 3rd party sales.

Christopher18h ago

I mean, if Sony is keeping third parties happy, kind of feels like a winning method.

IRetrouk14h ago

Kinda always been that way if you look at previous gens, exclusives are important but they aint the main revenue generator.

Reaper22_13h ago(Edited 13h ago)

.While that is impressive. Microsoft made 13 billion in one quarter. Making up facts doesn't make them true.

Mmmkay13h ago

microsoft is not xbox. a bot should know that by now. you have been told this bs 1000 times on this site alone.

OlderGamer1710h ago

Yeah Microsoft but Xbox on the other hand.....

Aloymetal9h ago

Your defense of Microsoft is only highlighting Lord Phil's and the lame MS mismanagement. Since you're talking about MS as a whole, imagine having trillions in the bank and still losing to ''tiny'' Sony PS and Ninty. It doesn't get any more lame than that.

Christopher4h ago

If what Microsoft made as a whole was all that mattered, we would still have Windows Phones and Zunes. I would love to see Xbox' operating profits. Love to see it.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 4h ago
thorstein11h ago

I prefer Playstation over Xbox when it comes to consoles but how does this news justify their layoffs?

Shane Kim10h ago

But the execs brother. You got to think about them. How could they otherwise buy yet another mansion and yacht?

raWfodog9h ago

People are generally paid for the work they are doing. Layoffs generally occur when there is no work for them to do (project cancelled, business slowing down, etc). I’ve been laid off from two jobs during my 40+ years of working so I know about these things. A company is not going to just keep paying people if there is no work for them to do, no matter how much profits they made.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 4h ago
MIDGETonSTILTS1714h ago

And this is why the game output for ps5 has been a tad slower…

1) they needed to be… games take longer to develop, and they’d burn out their teams trying to maintain the same pace as ps3.

2) they can afford to… games cost more than ever to push boundaries, so Sony had to figure out a way to match Xbox’s clever profit strategies in order to afford to continue to innovate and take risks.

lukasmain9h ago

So much time was wasted on those Live Service shits. Glad they learned their lesson and have scaled that way back. Still haven't killed it, but I like it being in the background and not at the forefront

MIDGETonSTILTS173h ago

Honestly, I love Helldivers 2 so much that I can forgive them for over investing in GaaS. At least they got one gem from the endeavor.

And I still dream of Factions releasing one day.

I don’t hate GaaS inherently, most are just implemented poorly.

Reaper22_12h ago(Edited 12h ago)

@ s2killinit

Thats xbox which includes other services. The playstion division also includes other services as well. Its mostly playtion but not all playstation. What's up with all the double standards around here.

Chevalier12h ago

Yeah double standards like some idiots who got to talk about unrelated profits as a talking point. Wish those damn parrots could stay on topic with game related profits.

Next thing these idiots will talk about is something unrelated like Nintendo made more off the Mario movie than all of Xbox studios TV/movie endeavors combined you know?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/...

12h ago
Deathdeliverer11h ago

@Chevalier

Mind you that’s only AFTER buying all those other companies adding them to the revenue. It was a LOT lower. This is Activision, Bethesda, and others COMBINED to get that number.

“The sales of windows professional on the other hand trounces god of war sales” 😂

Reaper22_9h ago(Edited 9h ago)

All you did was prove that you dont know what revenue is. Tencent is no.1 in profits. Buts that's ok because unlike Tencent and Microsoft, Sony isn't in it for the money, right.🤔

pwnmaster30009h ago

That’s what Xbox fanboys do. They’ve been doing this since Xbox one.

They will use all of MS, one of the biggest company in the world and play it like every dollar they earn comes from Xbox just to one up PlayStation.
Is actually pretty sad.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 9h ago
Chevalier11h ago

"Mind you that’s only AFTER buying all those other companies adding them to the revenue. It was a LOT lower. This is Activision, Bethesda, and others COMBINED to get that number."

Guys we're off topic here you know? Can someone bring us back on topic and tell us how much revenue Xbox studios does for movies and TV? Pretty sure we should also discuss how much Nintendo stands to make at Universal studios on Nintendo land and the rides should be a hot ticket this summer.

"Ouch! hahaha no wonder reaper wanna hide behind profits made by windows XD"

Yeah idiots with some sort of inferiority complex needs to get their win somewhere though. But wait shouldn't we get back on topic guys? Like seriously how much money do you think Fallout Season 2 will bring in?!

Reaper22_7h ago

Nah, reaper's not hiding behind anything. I'm just pointing out some facts. At first the narrative was Microsoft isn't going to make the money back from the ABK deal to now their profits wouldn't be as high if they didn't get the deal. This very topic is part of the reason why the deal was secured. Sony's dishonesty and reluctance to tell the truth about how much money they're making and lying about how much this deal would hurt their business. That strategy failed. They're are making a lot of money. No doubt about it and its good for the industry but don't get butthurt when Microsoft post their profits and you guys see they are also making a lot of money as well.

CrashMania7h ago

@reaper.

Microsoft don't reveal Xbox profits, sales numbers, or gamepass numbers, I wonder why that is?

You call Sony dishonest but at least they don't hide and obfuscate meaningful playstation numbers like MS do with Xbox.

IRetrouk6h ago

Reaper stop lol, only one company hides that info and it ain't sony....

Chevalier9h ago

"All you did was prove that you dont know what revenue is."

Nah all you did was confirm you're an idiot.

Reaper22_7h ago(Edited 7h ago)

You seem to be fluent in idiocy. Not everyone speaks it. So next time speak slowly and clearly so we all can understand. Getting emotional doesn't really make you smarter. Before you post a link with info make sure you know what it says.🫡

Chevalier3h ago

"Nah, reaper's not hiding behind anything. I'm just pointing out some facts"

🤡 What facts? 🤣

Please share with everyone your idiocy

What does Xbox make in revenue and profit? What are their sales? How much money does Gamepass cost them? Oh right you got ZERO numbers to post.

"Before you post a link with info make sure you know what it says."

Says the idiot who can't even tell the difference between Microsoft and Xbox? Lmao. Seriously all you're showing everyone again is how much of an uninformed parroting idiot you are.

But go ahead and post your evidence! Oh right again ZERO from a ZERO. Absolutely 💯 hilarious to see you stumble like the idiot you are.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3h ago
Npugz712h ago

Only because of games prices otherwise it’s the worst generation in PlayStation history especially for games

Reaper22_12h ago

Thats true. The article did mention game and prices were a reason. Its also shows their greed is no different than Microsoft. Laying off all those people but yet bragging about profits and still tried to stop ABK deal. What the hell!

MatrixxGT11h ago

Closing studios, layoffs, leadership changes, PS plus increases, multiple game cancellations and delays, total flops like concord. Slowest release of first party games of any generation and they just shut down PS stars I guess because it was costing to much.
Yet they announce record profits…..the greed here is insane, MS and Nintendo too. All of them milking gamers and we just keep lapping it up like a blood hound for a meal.
Them tariffs are really hitting them hard I see.

Deathdeliverer11h ago

Well a part of running a business is a tight grip on that P&L sheet. In project management. It’s a known fact that the farther into a project you go, the more costly the corrections. Having something reach the definition of done, the end of the road, and it’s hated is a monumental loss of money. As games are usually made iteratively it’s like how was this not caught and course corrected several times before this point. Sony is definitely known as trusting and allows teams to make the games they want to make. They “trust the process”. The caveat to that big budget and freedom is if it bombs, especially if it’s your first game, you’re outta there. They have shareholders/stakeholders to keep happy. Where as normally a done game like Concord would give ROI as it was out in the wild. The cost of the project is recouped and turned into profit or delivered whatever value they wanted. If the game is now NOT coming out, how do they get that money back and stay profitable? By not paying wages for that team over a course of time that would have still been on payroll working on the next potential bomb, DLC for a dead game, and essentially costing more money.
It sadly isn’t greed, it’s business. They release these great profits because 1) it’s enticing for more stakeholders to invest, and 2) Despite failures they are still balancing the books and turning record setting profits.
How many live service games died at various stages of development? They are still this profitable? Imagine if the games came out and were hits to add onto the profits?

Christopher4h ago(Edited 4h ago)

So, you're saying that over $10B of this is from $10 to $20 software price increases? Zero to do with increased market reach? Massive MTX from third-party games?

Vithar12h ago

where are the "Sony is in trouble" sayers? LOL

Chevalier11h ago

They're talking about Microsoft quarterly profits like any true gamer would be doing.

Aloymetal9h ago

Oh, that's coming, it's a mandatory thing just wait for next gen and you'll see infinite articles from the shills and the green fanbase saying ''tHiS GeN WiL Be dIfFerEnT''

stonecold31h ago

over twitter xbox fanboy you tube are saying saying sony is broke cant afford warner bros.

Show all comments (64)
70°

Nexus Mods founder announces new ownership, promises it will remain "community-first"

After decades of running an incredibly popular modding community site, Nexus Mods founder Dark0ne is passing control to new owners.

Create Report !X

Add Report

Reports

+ Updates (1)- Updates (1)

Updates

Changed from Pending to Approved
Community1d 5h ago