Fatal Frame and Silent Hill 1-3 did it to me. I don't like horror games full of jump scares. The thrill doesn't last very long. I like when the game makes you think about it even when you stop playing it.
One of very few games that made me jump out of my skin
REALLY made me jump, I remember dropping my ash tray that was sitting on my crotch area, I was proper baked at the time, real lazed out on my sofa, then that happened
I even went to bed with the lights on in every room
Siren: Blood Curse on PS3 gave me the creep! i played lots of survivals and this is the only one that i think has some very stressful moments.
http://www.youtube.com/watc...
One of very few games that made me jump out of my skin
REALLY made me jump, I remember dropping my ash tray that was sitting on my crotch area, I was proper baked at the time, real lazed out on my sofa, then that happened
I even went to bed with the lights on in every room
Why haven't me had a C3 yet?
SCP:CB is awesome, its one of the few games that actually make me scared.