880°

Respawn: We Did Not Sell Titanfall to Microsoft

Vince Zampella: For those asking about the 'future of titanfall' announcement, I'm confused as to what that is. We did not sell tf to MS.

Yo Mama3793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

Some Microsoft fanboy's still won't believe it.

Eonjay3793d ago

Touche.

But what does he mean when he says hes confused by what Future of Titanfall means?

For God's sake please don't wake up on Monday and find out that EA has stolen your IP from you lol /jk

NewMonday3793d ago

maybe MS have bought Respawn all together

Eonjay3793d ago

@NewMonday

https://twitter.com/VinceZa...

No lol its just something started by the Doritos Pope.

Irishguy953793d ago

Yeah I don't get it...how can they be confused about their own Ip's future? Surely they know exactly what they're doing with it? EA do not own it

MightyNoX3793d ago

@Eonjay: Vince seems to be in the dark about a lot of things. I wouldn't be surprised if the scenario you proposed turned out to be true. :P

hqgamez3793d ago

They just going to say the future will remain an xbox exclusive. That's the future.

AngelicIceDiamond3793d ago

So this is The Dorito Pope's misinformation?

Typical.

johndoe112113793d ago

I died reading the second and third posts in that twitter feed.

Patrick_pk443793d ago

Remember that Vince Zampella never knew EA cut a deal with Microsoft from the beginning. It would be terrible if EA sold the rights of the game to Microsoft.

3793d ago
ShinMaster3793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

Why would Respawn keep teasing that the sequels to Titanfall will be on PS4 in the first place if Microsoft owned it.

It's just a temporary deal they have for now.

strifeblade3793d ago

Respawn is awesome. They did not sell titanfall to Microsoft EA did. Definitely not sell outs.

its_JEFF3793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

I really don't get how you guys aren't getting this... EA didn't sell the rights to anybody. EA doesn't own the IP, Respawn does. The reason Respawn is even a thing is because they wanted control of their own IP, they wanted to own their own IP. The only possible thing that EA could have sold is full exclusivity!

There is a chance that MS could have bought Respawn, but that would mean that they're now under someone again... just like they were with Activision. So in essence they could be in the same boat, again. Vince went off to be independent because he was tired of people telling what he could and couldn't do.

If anybody is gonna sell TitanFall it has to be Vince, he owns it.

diehardmetallicafan3793d ago

how does anyone even know if there will be a titanfall 2? what if the first dies in the arse?

Visiblemarc3792d ago

Well, for the guys at Respawn, this whole situation is unfortunate.

The company was formed after a dispute with activision, now they have EA making deals behind their backs.

On the one hand they are lucky to have a situation where they have a very hungry company, MS, pushing their game super hard. But on the otherhand, if the hype is to be believed, lightning has struck twice and they've yet again created a money printing IP...and yet again are out of control of it's destiny.

For their best interests, EA better have specified minimum sales numbers in this deal. Otherwise if this whole thing is a misfire they can go ahead and release it on all platforms, without waiting a whole dev cycle and praying the hype stays alive.

andibandit3792d ago

Theyre problably in the middle of negotiations with ms, thats why they havent sold it yet and cant say what the future holds either

nukeitall3792d ago

From all accounts, Titanfall will be a huge success.

This type of thing is very typical i.e. Respawn owns the IP, but EA owns the publishing rights for probably a trilogy meaning they own the right to publishing two sequels as well. EA then funds Respawn and they all reap the rewards.

@Visiblemarc:

"The company was formed after a dispute with activision, now they have EA making deals behind their backs."

Surely Respawn could have learned a thing or two, but allowed EA pretty much free reign on deciding the fate of Titanfall. Respawn might own the creative freedrom to do as they please with the game, but EA owns the right to publish and market the game.

The only way around this is if Respawn used their own money, which isn't likely to happen.

"Well, for the guys at Respawn, this whole situation is unfortunate."

I see Respawn as extremely lucky, because of their past history. How many developers is likely to get the free reign Respawn gets?

MysticStrummer3792d ago

"So this is The Dorito Pope's misinformation?

Typical."

This made me lol

If your source of info is a guy named The Dorito Pope, getting a second opinion is mandatory.

+ Show (14) more repliesLast reply 3792d ago
MorePowerOfGreen3793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

Why would the fanboys not believe it? Only people talking about acquisitions and IP purchases are PS4 fanboys being worried. The news from other sources are talking about a Partnership not IP purchase.

Why in the heck would Xbox fanboys not believe? The game is exclusive to MSFT platforms.

The partnership could be anything from Doritos/singers deals *to* Publishers, free DLC and more.

LOL at the fanboys running and crying to Vince.

filipakos3793d ago

The game is coming on PC too whats makes it an xbox exclusive?PS4 "faboys" can try the game there or dont

johndoe112113793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

https://www.change.org/peti...

I think you are oblivious to exactly how fanatic, insensate and obtuse xbox fanboys can be. But i'm sure you're not like them right? Right?

Zhipp3793d ago

@filipakos
He said it's exclusive to "MSFT platforms." i.e, the game will never be seen on Android, Linux, Mac, or, yes, Playstation.

QuickdrawMcgraw3793d ago

I hope Titanfall stays a Xbox1 exclusive...The Xbox1 has been taking it on the chin since this gen started...And the Xbox1 really needs something...anything positive for their fan base to crow about...

mcarsehat3793d ago

@johndoe11211

I would be quicker to say Fanboys in general than JUST Xbox Fanboys.

AndrewLB3792d ago (Edited 3792d ago )

Johndoe- You mean like these fanboys? http://www.change.org/petit...

Or these... http://www.change.org/petit...
and these... http://www.change.org/en-CA...

Some more... https://www.change.org/peti...

When will it end? I thought none of you PS4 fanboys want titanfall? http://www.change.org/petit...

Wow... http://www.change.org/petit...

dear lord... http://www.change.org/petit...

johndoe112113792d ago

@AndrewLB

Are you serious? What does that have to do with the point I was trying to show? What exactly do those petitions prove? That ps owners would like to have a game that they believe would be a good game on their systems? A game that was obviously meant to be a timed exclusive before microsoft threw money at their 10 cent whore known as EA?

Whereas the other petition shows the vindictive, selfish, spiteful, hateful, idiotic, moronic and utter stupidity of a fanbase that is trying to stop another system from getting a game out of pure hatred and malice.

All fanboy bases can be a-holes at times no one is denying that but a petition to keep titanfall as an xbox exclusive just to spite the ps fanbase shows how pathetic and disgusting the xbox fansase is. Mind you, not all of them are like that but this petition makes you wonder.

The sad thing is your post made even less sense than their petition. At least I know it is hatred that is driving them but what exactly is driving you seeing that you are a pc elitist? Is it because microsft makes you pc os that you will champion anything microsoft? Is it that that drove you to post such a senseless and irrelevant response?

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 3792d ago
lolCHILLbro3793d ago

im a MS fan and Xbox fan and i dont really care!

Bathyj3792d ago

Xbox fan I can see, but I don't think I've ever heard anyone say they were a Microsoft fan before.

AceBlazer133793d ago

Maybe respawn didn't sell it maybe EA did.

3792d ago
Radentangr3792d ago

It depends on the agreement. I have had IPs sold off without my signature, its about who owns the majority.

DeadlyFire3792d ago (Edited 3792d ago )

You mean maybe Respawn sold Titanfall to EA right? As Respawn owns the IP. EA just has a publishing agreement with Respawn. That is all.

avengers19783793d ago

Well he also said he was surprised EA signed the exclusive deal with MS, I'm not to sure this guy has to much say in the matter...
Remember EA is the original EVIL EMPIRE, maybe they stole it and sold it too MS.

showtimefolks3793d ago

why would Respawn sell their IP when they just got away from Activision. If anything we may see future TF games publisher by a different publisher, EA went behind Respawn's back to make it exclusive

Respawn owns the IP
NO EA or MS

TheDrunkenJester3793d ago

All he is saying is they didn't sell the IP to Microsoft. That doesn't mean it's going multiplat, take Gears of War for example, that series is completely xbox exclusive, but Microsoft only bought the actual IP from Epic a month or so ago.

So we could see the same for Titanfall. No Microsoft does not own Titanfall, but it can still be their exclusive indefinitely if this game sells well enough.

cabbitwithscissors3793d ago

The Gears of War example is not really true. I'm guessing that MS did pay for lifetime exclusivity (if any), or it could be that Epic Games didn't want to go through the hassle of programming for the PS3 due to its unique requirements.

But they did have a change of heart when the PS4 came out, and there was news around stating that they were thinking of bringing Gears of War to the PS4 platform before MS blew a fuse and went and made the offer to buy that game off of Epic games and made it a xbone exclusive.

For MS to get exclusivity on Titanfall, they will need to pay a huge sum to both EA and Respawn. Something that they may not be able to do with the new change in management.

EA only has a contract on the first game, not the subsequent ones (excluding DLCs). What's to say that Respawn goes to another publisher or change the contract terms with EA for the new game ?

There's a lot of possibilities and maybes at the moment, and things are still up in the air.

We don't even know what are the contract terms made between EA and MS or even EA and Respawn, and with the MS platform being low in install base and MS giving out the game for free, I'm guessing that there is a clause in the contract that sales figures must meet a certain number in a set time period or the game will go to other platforms. Conjecture here actually.

fermcr3792d ago (Edited 3792d ago )

What everybody knows is that Titanfall is being released on PC and Xbox platforms. It will stay exclusive to those platforms according to EA... and Titanfall 2 might be released on Sony or Nintendo platforms in the future... the rest is just speculation.

Blaze9293792d ago

this guy didn't even want nor know Titanfall 1 was going to remain an Xbox One exclusive. Yet it's his company and IP? lol talk about a mixup.

I wouldn't be shocked to see EA straight lift the IP right from Respawn

+ Show (6) more repliesLast reply 3792d ago
GraveLord3793d ago

Looks like PS4 owners can look forward to Titanfall 2 in the future.

Abash3793d ago

Hopefully Titanfall 2 could be more of a full game with an AAA campaign mode

InTheLab3793d ago

And some form of co-op like most shooters...

Debaitable3793d ago

It doesn't need a AAA campaign, what they have now is good enough. BF4 sells well enough with the majority of its player base only touching the multiplayer.

scott1823793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

^
How do you know a majority of Battlefield players only play the multiplayer? That is a wild assumption that seems very much false. If people didn't, why would they take so much time and money making them such a big part of the game?

mo2413793d ago

campaign is not needed. I would love to see a splitscreen in the sequel. Most important thing needed is for it to be on the ps4, which is most likely. Still considering to get the game on the x360, but I was planning on not to buy games anymore for the current gen consoles so I can focus on the next gen. And don't want to pay for a ps plus and an xbox live sub.
And the fact that it's delayed on the x360 doesn't make it any better.

Boody-Bandit3793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

And no bots.
Bot farming is why I'm meh on this game even though I own an X1 and PC gaming rig. They need to do away with them for TF2. It's like shooting fish in a barrel. The grunt AI is so dumb.

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 3793d ago
avengers19783793d ago

I'm a PS4 owner and I could careless if TitanFall ever comes to PS4, it's not like there will be a shortage of games for it, or a shortage of shooters for that matter.

MRMagoo1233793d ago

My thoughts exactly , i would not be playing it if it was on the PS4 anyway, if i want titanfall ill get it on my PC but i really have no interest in another fps , i would prefer no more FPS games where made for the entire gen but i know that wont happen.

showtimefolks3793d ago

yes sir and if i want to play it i can on my PC. People act as the only way to play TF is to buy an xbox one. If anything i say PC version would be the best if they allow mods and stuff

cabbitwithscissors3793d ago

Spread the love. You might not want the game, but there are others who are interested in it and want to play it. Why limit choices ?

This game is by a third party developer and a small one at that, they need all the sales they can get.

Also, going multi-platform is a good way to make your game available to more people. That is one reason Insomniac Games made but somehow they went against their reasoning and went back to exclusivity with MS for Sunset Overdrive. They must really be eating their words.

Izzy4083793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

Give it a rest already, PS fanboys; jeezus. Stop making a big deal about Titanfall being an Xbox/PC exclusive. You have exclusive games too. Deal with it!

AngelicIceDiamond3793d ago

Lol @Izzy kinda has a point.

It's funny because Titanfall isn't even a true exclusive. I do agree because fanboys are are getting a little crazy. They forget they have exclusive games as well.

Enjoy what's coming to your console and have fun.

ABizzel13793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

@Izzy

To be honest I'm with you on this. It's not a big freaking deal. Each console has exclusives to play, and it seems like some of these PS "gamers" (and I use the term lightly) are more interested in getting TitanFall simply so M$ doesn't have a leg to stand on.

Just let it go, and why would you want part 2, when EA/Respawn basically tried to whammy you with the original release, because they felt they'd make a little more money hoping XBO would lead NA and UK.

That's like someone selling a car you were waiting going to buy, and then telling you they sold it but wait a couple years and they'll sale you another one for the same price. GTFOMF.

Why would you even support that? Sloppy seconds. If anything you guys should teach them a lesson and not buy it, or buy every copy used, so they know better than to do something like that again.

As for EA it makes no sense to create a multiplatform game, then make it timed exclusive, then full exclusive, and a couple years make the sequel multiplat and expect everyone to be happy like they didn't just play you. Nope next. And I hope PS gamers don't buy it, because of your greed, and there's no way Respawn didn't know this. Zampella you're running a freaking, and you mean to tell me you don't know what's going on with your business, and if that's really the case then it's no wonder you got screwed over by Activision, and why EA did it again, and you don't need to be leading any company at all. If you don't know what's going on within your own company how on earth are you going to run a successful business. That's F@#$ing up your money.

Getting back to gamers if it's that big of a deal for you then you have 4 options.

Cheapest to most expensive.

1. Buy GTX 750 Ti GPU and stick put it in a any desktop PC you have, and play TitanFall, 1080p @ 60fps ($150)

2. Buy an Xbox 360 + XBLG ($240 4GB / $310 for 250GB + Halo 4 + Tomb Raider), download the games for gold for the next year on the console, and play TitanFall, although it might be 600p - 720p @ 30 - 60fps.

3. Buy a XBO TitanFall Bundle ($500)

4. Buy a gaming PC ($400 - $600)

The PC options are the best for you if you're a PS gamer. The PS4 / XBO will have 90% of the same library, and you might as well get a PC and get the games cheaper on Steam. As I said buying a 750 Ti basically turns any desktop you have laying around into an XBO for $150 (depending on the CPU and RAM). Upgrade your RAM to the max and fastest memory your desktop can handle if it's really old.

LexHazard793793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

I like how you say gaming PC $400-$500 but does that include monitor, keyboard and mouse, OS and anything else your gonne need for system. Not bashing PC as Im gonna be doing my first build and ive been doing my research. But let be real its more like $800-$1000. My build is gonna cost me $2,257.67. But thats because im building a rig for video editing, music producing and some gaming but still gaurantees me ultimate experience!

Btw- yeah that 750ti is good card for low budget gamer for sure!

MRMagoo1233793d ago

actually BakPAin i have just built my son a pc that can run titanfall on mid range settings for $450 in Australia which is even cheaper in the US and he got a monitor and keyboard/mouse, the screen was only $40 and the K/M came free, i already have windows and can easily get it for free of the internet if needed anyway.

8gigs of corsair ddr3, a gtx 550 and 1 tb hdd . along with an amd phenom 2 black edition cpu. cheap as chips.

ABizzel13793d ago

@BakPAin

If you want to use the monitor excuse then you need to buy an HDTV to play a console on.

You can still hook your PC up to your HDTV as well. A Keyboard / Mouse is dirt cheap. And You can download SteamOS free, Linux free, and you can find Windows 8 disc on ebay for $30 - $40.

I've been building several $600 gaming PC's that outperform the XBO for the last couple of months, and you can build an APU gaming PC for $400, which is why I put that range.

You've been doing research? I've been building for the last 4 years, you're out of your element here.

And spending over $2,000 for Video and Music editing with a bit of gaming proves you know nothing about performance. For editing your CPU is the most important thing, and a i7 4770k is more than enough for the VAST majority of editing. You need to reevaluate your knowledge and your budget, because you don't know what you're talking about and you don't know how to properly budget for a gaming PC.

I should know I'm an AV Engineer already, and all it takes is $1,000 - $1,200 to build a great editing PC, with a great GPU tossed in.

saint_seya3793d ago

I dont know why you would say that.. i had the beta key on my origin account, saw the videos of the game, i didnt even care to download it.
I cant say im one of those who isnt interested in playing titan fall at all, i dont like to play with bots, but its just me, then again im a ps fanboy, so your generalization doesnt work at all.
I wont talk for every PS fan, but you cant either.
Its like saying all the MS fanboys are just retarded trolls because you see people like green power, when the truth is a lot of MS fans are cool guys that like games that x-box has and im totally cool with that.

scott1823793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

I don't know if the game is good or not, but it's third party, there is no reason why it shouldn't come to the PS4. Microsoft doesn't own them or the ip and people seem to think they do. It's a greedy industry now it would seem.

mo2413793d ago

it's fine for 1st party games to be exclusive, but for 3rd party deals it sucks. It would be awesome on the ps4.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 3793d ago
stuna13793d ago (Edited 3793d ago )

If Respawn had sold the ip, they would have been the one's hurt the most by it! Really think about it, how much do you really believe Microsoft paid for the first 1st game!? More than likely the cost was taken from the 1 billion set aside by Microsoft for new ip's/game development.

@chistocolus

Now people need proof all of a sudden, when normally they go alone with things that certain entities say without a lick of it being present! But just for you, there are two occasions where Microsoft stated explicitly that they had set aside 1 billion alotted to game development/new ip's. The Xbox1 unveiling and E3.

And although not very specific it has been quite obvious where this billion dollars is being spent! As the saying goes "A leopard can't change its spots".

christocolus3793d ago

"More than likely the cost was taken from the 1 billion set aside by Microsoft for new ip's/game development"

Dude where is the link? Or do you have an inside source?

Show all comments (120)
340°

Microsoft Responds To Latest FTC Filing, Calls It Misleading

Microsoft was quick to fire back against the FTC’s latest claim

Read Full Story >>
gamersocialclub.ca
Sonyslave37d ago

It a warp lol ftc is need but this case against Ms is over.
😭😭

lelo2play6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

All the whiners 😭 complaining about Gamepass, where were they when Sony increased their prices and introduced several tiers for PS Plus membership?
When Sony does it, it's perfectly acceptable. When Microsoft does it, all hell breaks loose...
Hypocrites 🤡 much!

BTW, I bet most whiners 😭 complaining don't have or even care about Gamepass. They whine simply because it's Microsoft.

isarai6d ago

We were very vocal and many people including myself cancelled their subs. Tf are you talking about? 🤣

outsider16246d ago

As isarai..said. even i cancelled it when they raised their prices. Im enjoying single player games now.

shaenoide6d ago

It's not the price increase the main problem. It's the removal of day one releases for console users while PC user are safe (for now). It's a weird message being send to console fan ( "You should have bought a PC bro !)

Reaper22_6d ago

Well said! They truly are huge hypocrites.

Einhander19726d ago

This has nothing to do with PlayStation, this is about Microsoft breaking its promises.

Bringing up PlayStation is just a petty deflection attempt to not take responsibility for their own actions.

People are unhappy because this has caused thousands of people to lose their jobs, four studio closures and xbox owners should be mad about price increases and the fact that Microsoft paywalled day one games breaking their promise to their own consumers. Now even if you don't want Call of Duty you're paying for it.

The xboners like you who keep defending this type of stuff are actually making things worse for yourselves because you keep sending the message that no matter how much Microsoft bends you over by breaking their promises you're still going to defend them.

Xbox gamers make gaming worse for everyone every time they defend this type of crap.

lelo2play6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

@Einhander1972

When ponies like you accept anything Sony does without complaining, that's the major problem here...

Sony can do anything they want, and people like you will simply take it with a smile.

Einhander19726d ago

This has nothing to do with Sony.

It just shows how weak the argument is when the best you and Microsoft can can do is deflect with whataboutism's.

This is about Microsoft buying a huge publisher then going to court and saying things they knew weren't true, then going back on their own word. They went into court and knew telling the truth wouldn't be popular with either the court or the public so they lied in court. That is what is being judged here, not anything that Sony did.

You claim we are defending a price increase, but you are defending outright lies that have caused studio closures job losses and your own price increases and new games are paywalled to a higher tier.

And what did you get? Games that you were already going to get without buying these publishers. And on top of that now regardless of if someone actually wanted the games they are forced to pay extra for them.

The scale difference between our two arguments is huge.

MetroidFREAK216d ago

I canceled my yearly subscription after the price increase :)

Outside_ofthe_Box6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

"Sony can do anything they want, and people like you will simply take it with a smile"

Isn't that what you are doing with Microsoft's price increase you hypocrite? I bet you were the first to complain about Sony's increase, but not surprisingly first to defend Microsoft's increase because you are a hypocrite.

GamerRN6d ago

They didn't "remove day one" for console users, they created a tier that doesn't get them. They basically brought back Live Gold with GamePass games instead of monthly drops.

Profchaos6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

Yeah I complained when Sony increased their prices it was dramatic and they didn't even comment on why it was fine and I'll complain here to

In fact there was a huge outcry just because you missed it doesn't mean it didn't happen

StormSnooper6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

It wasn’t the same thing. Sony’s tiers didn’t take anything away from people. Two of the tiers already existed. No promise was broken. Xbox tiers are breaking promises MS has made regarding day one, while also increasing price.

Angyobangyo6d ago

People were complaining and pissed. Only you seem to think Sony gamers graciously accepted it. You sure do whine a lot don't you

Hotpot6d ago

Nope, I cancelled my PS Plus already.

Your turn, criticize MS yourself, right now.

Outside_ofthe_Box6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

^^^^
@Hotpot

"Your turn, criticize MS yourself, right now."

He's a hypocrite so he won't. He's going to simply take it with a smile on his face like the pic in his avi 😭

+ Show (13) more repliesLast reply 6d ago
XiNatsuDragnel6d ago

No it ain't mate essentially ftc has a case here

CrimsonWing696d ago

I’m not trying to be an ass here when asking this, I just genuinely want to understand more. What’s the case that the FTC have?

XiNatsuDragnel5d ago

@crismon
Microsoft said to courts when they purchased Activision they wouldn't raise the price with gamepass but they did after they got Activision.

1Victor6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

@slave3: “It a warp lol ftc is need but this case against Ms is over.
😭😭”
Well at least PLAYSTATION GET ALL Xbox FORMER “EXCLUSIVES”.
GEAR is next on the list of lubricants before they ram the big HALO on PlayStation.
So enjoy winning that FTC battle to badly loose the war 😭😭.
Edited for typos

ThinkThink7d ago

I mean, yeah.. if any of these tier options aren't right for you, you can always just buy your games the old fashioned way.

XiNatsuDragnel6d ago

Fair but this is about lying to the courts not lovely options

ChasterMies6d ago

You can buy games the old fashioned way now. Microsoft’s end game is releasing Call of Duty exclusivity on Game Pass.

Rude-ro6d ago

For now.
I can assure you, Microsoft wants subscriptions to access their games.
Just a matter of when not if or optional.

XiNatsuDragnel7d ago

Lol still lying about not raising prices in court eh? Can we address that plz

TheNamelessOne7d ago

If the price raise was attributed to the acquisition. Nobody can make that claim, and every sub service has been raising their prices. Sony made a massive one not long ago.

lodossrage7d ago (Edited 7d ago )

The problem is Gamepass price was already raised last year, just for them to raise it again this year. That right there will help the FTC's argument

It's only gets magnified when Spencer's words don't match what the company does. He said publically gamepass wouldn't change as a result of COD. He said the price wouldn't change. Both of those things were clearly untrue. Among other things

Einhander19726d ago (Edited 6d ago )

They didn't just raise the price though, they also removed day one games from the standard tier and paywalled new games behind a more expensive tier which they also raised the price on.

And the FTC's appeal also brings up the job losses and studio closures as evidence that this deal should have been blocked.

Einhander19727d ago

Well, one thing is for sure Microsoft knows more than anyone about misleading people.

The fact is Microsoft said they wouldn't raise prices due to the merger then they did including making a new tier of game pass. They said they wouldn't fire people and they did. And they also closed studios so it's hard to argue that the effect on the consumer and the industry hasn't been negative.

This is a incredibly weak rebuttal.

XiNatsuDragnel7d ago

Exactly ftc has every right to fight this

Reaper22_6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

Go and google the FTC case against Sony for misleading it's customers about the PS Vita. Then come back and discuss who knows more than anyone about misleading people.

What you claim Microsoft said is just lies. They never said they wouldn't raise prices or fire anyone. And even if they did it's their right. You statement is pretty weak and proves nothing but you have a bias just like so many other people here. You guys are just butt hurt that Microsoft won this case and it backfired in Sony's face because they threw stones and thought their own deals would not be a factor but they were. As a matter of fact it was one of the factors that helped MS win the case. Just take the L because it's a done deal. It seems the only effects from this deal is upset playstation only fans who thought the deal was never going to happen. Microsoft won. Get over it. Stop worrying about things we have no control of. Just play games you like and don't focus so much on who made it and all that petty stuff.

Doomeduk6d ago (Edited 6d ago )

You're here again Sony grrrr in a MICROSOFT article
Just chuffed you've given up the obsession with Jim Ryan with just a few more sessions and you'll be able to comment on the actual article you can do it reaper the community is right behind you
Chin up

Einhander19726d ago

https://n4g.com/user/home/l...

You don't understand.

Sony is not part of this appeal at all. Sony wasn't even a part of the original FTC case. The FTC brought this case aledging that Micrsofts buyout of ABK would have a negative impact on the industry. They claimed that it would cause job loss and and that the consumer and the industry would be negativly effected from the buy out including from price increases to game pass.

Sony was only there to provide testimony on how they expected the buyour to negativly effect thier buisness.

They did not file the suit.

This appeal is of the ruling that blocked their injunction, and the FTC is presenting evidence that the buyout has in fact had the negative impact that they said it would and which was the basis for their injunction call.

The fact that you and Microsoft need to keep bringing up Sony instead of actually defending the actions themselves shows that you don't actually have a defense at all.

6d ago Replies(1)
Show all comments (57)
390°

FTC Calls Xbox Game Pass Price Hike 'Exactly The Sort Of Consumer Harm' It Tried To Stop

Despite losing its lawsuit seeking an injunction to freeze Microsoft’s purchase of Activision Blizzard in July 2023, the FTC appealed the decision with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. While it awaits a final decision from those justices, the FTC’s been filing additional evidence to support its claims that the merger would hurt competition in gaming and hurt customers, including a letter from earlier this year after Microsoft laid off nearly 2,000 employees across the newly acquired teams.

lelo2play8d ago

FTC never heard of inflation. Did they expect Gampass to remain the same price forever?
Would be funny if Gampass remained at 10€ fifty years from now...

Einhander19728d ago

"Microsoft insists Game Pass prices ‘will not increase as a result of Activision merger"
https://www.videogameschron...

"It says a price rise “would be counter-productive as it would increase subscriber churn rates”

8d ago
lelo2play7d ago (Edited 7d ago )

"Game Pass prices will not increase as a result of the Merger"

Gamepass wouldn't increase in result of the merger... but it doesn't mean it wouldn't increase due to other reasons, like inflation, extra expenses, etc. Do you expect Gamepass to remain the same price forever?

All other online services have been increasing prices.

boing17d ago

I cancelled my Ultimate sub after the announcement, so they were right. And yet, they still did it. That is so MS.

Einhander19727d ago

Inflation is down since they made that statement.

They also call into question the 2000+ people Microsoft has fired from the developers they bought.

And again, this is contradictory to what Microsoft said they would do.

They lied in court.

Reaper22_7d ago

Lol...they never said gamepass wouldn't increase and they never said it would because of the merger. And even they did it's their right to do so. So what's your point?

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 7d ago
Inverno8d ago

So we blaming this on inflation now? Lol ok

lelo2play7d ago (Edited 7d ago )

Sony and other streaming services (Netflix, HBO, ...) have been increasing prices and altering their services. Do you expect Gamepass to remain the same price forever?
Others can increase prices and alter their services, but Microsoft can't?

Hypocrite much!

DarXyde7d ago

Absolutely.

Ego inflation.

IRetrouk7d ago

Lelo, they upped the price last year, along with their xboxs......

waderae7d ago

I believe they call it mental gymnastics.

Profchaos7d ago

Exactly let's not forget this deal was done under the same economic climate this was predictable yet they maintained they would not be increasing prices yet now the merger is done they increased prices and split tiers to avoid further scrutiny.

This is and always has been how Microsoft do business deflect blame and increase profits

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 7d ago
andy858d ago

Inflation doesn't double something in a few months.

anast8d ago

You are correct. It's actually lower. It was around 7% in 2021 and now it's around 3%, which is ideal.

REDDURT8d ago

Dude they are lying. That inflation low keeps getting silly and silly.

gold_drake7d ago

inflation aint the same thing as to lock stuff behind a paywall that was previously not. lol

Hotpot7d ago

*activate clown vision*
*everything looks exactly the same*

KwietStorm_BLM7d ago

Yeah you're right. It's just a coincidence that this happened after spending billions of dollars buying up the industry. And closing studios. And firing thousands of people. All while barely being able to give away Xboxes. It's all because of inflation. LOL

XiNatsuDragnel7d ago

Fanboyism bro this is pure fanboyism, it's bs we all know it so stop defending Microsoft.

thorstein7d ago

You said it all, my friend, you said it all.

jznrpg7d ago

But inflation has gone down in the U.S.

ChasterMies7d ago

Except $/mb of broadband, $/mb of storage, and $/compute power only gets cheaper over time. As Microsoft’s overhead has gone down, it’s prices have gone up.

1Victor7d ago

@lelo: “FTC never heard of inflation. Did they expect Gampass to remain the same price forever?
Would be funny if Gampass remained at 10€ fifty years from now...”
I see you got the industrial size chapstick truck from Microsoft and put it into use already.
Add one more backpedaling to Microsoft and Phil rhetorics

VincentVanBro7d ago

Look in the mirror. You’re a clown 🤡

shinoff21837d ago

Gamepass price was going up regardless of inflation or not and you know it. Hey atleast you guys have an excuse to ride for a little bit

7d ago
PRIMORDUS7d ago

Need I remind you of how much MS is worth? There was no need to let anyone go or any studio. MS are just cancer and should leave the industry.

+ Show (15) more repliesLast reply 7d ago
8d ago Replies(1)
GamerRN7d ago

Apparently it's ok that they raised PSN prices, but Xbox can't compete?!

The "Standard" is just a rebranded Xbox Live. Not expected but not crazy since they didn't really have a proper entry level subscription to match PSNs entry level.

IRetrouk7d ago

Xbox raised their prices last year too though, their entry level was core or gamepass console.

-Foxtrot7d ago

The whole "Bu bu but Sony" thing with the PSN doesn't take into consideration Microsofts whole argument to the FTC during the entire Activision merger court case is that they wouldn't raise prices due to the merger, nothing would change.

Sony never said shit about raising prices and the like so while we can think it's scummy the FTC won't have an issue with it because the argument wasn't towards them, they never swore against anything.

If the Activision merger never happened and Microsoft raised their prices as a standard thing, like Sony with the PSN or even how Netflix has done it with their subscription it would have been business as usual.

GamerRN2d ago

I'm so tired of the Sony defense team. Pay off me thinks a lot of these comments come from Sony shills

RhinoGamer888d ago

All the judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit just got a free windows 11 upgrade!

badz1497d ago

Err...W11 upgrade was always free

GamerRN7d ago

The price hike just brings it closer in line to PSN, yet it still has greater value. The standard sub matches the lowest PSN sub.

FTC trying to seem relevant. Claiming their multi million dollar case was to stop a $3 dollar price hike is a stupid argument and embarrassing for them.

Einhander19727d ago

PS+
$80 per year cheaper
More total games
Retro Games - Added monthly
VR games - Added Monthly
Ubisoft + Classics
4 k Streaming of nearly all games including ones you own digital not on the service. (xbox 1080p series s)
Sony Pictures Catalog
Anime from Crunchyroll
Full Game Trials with Trophy Support

GamerRN7d ago

PSN absolutely does not have more total games. I have PSN Ultimate or whatever it's called.

They don't get day one exclusives.
They don't even have Last of Us 2 Remake on there yet! Or Last of Us Part 1!!
You get Ubisoft classics, so does Xbox. But w Xbox also get EA games!
VR games don't matter to me, but Xbox also gets PC games that don't matter to me.
Both have classic games.
Streaming means nothing to me, it's still a failed concept, Digital Foundry tests it often, and it's not there yet for "serious gamers". The lag is intense!
Sony pictures and anime are neat, I'll give ya that.
Full game trials are cool, but Xbox gets the full game day one, so.... 🤷

I haven't had a good game in PSN since HellDivers, this year has been dead.

Honestly, once Xbox starts dumping all these exclusives on to GamePass, it's gonna be a flood of great titles

Einhander19727d ago

It's $80 cheaper, you're paying $240 a year in hopes of getting Microsoft games, and things aren't looking great on the development side of things beyond all the stuff they started 5 years ago. There is no guarantee that some of these studios will even exist going forward.

No, game pass does not offer Ubisoft Classics, and you only need Extra unlike EA Play which requires Ultimate.

And it doesn't matter what you don't want, xbox isn't offering it for people who do. Those things add value for a lot of people.

What digital foundry found was that PS+ Streaming was vastly superior to xcloud.

Full Game Trials include 3'rd party games.

PlayStation get's "good games" all the time that aren't on xbox,GranBlue Fantasy Relink, Final Fantasy, Helldivers, Rise of the Ronin, Stellar Blade, Zenless Zone Zero, Pacific Drive ect. every week something new comes out or is announced for PlayStation that's not on xbox.

And you're bragging about day one but that keep proving to be unsustainable. That's why studios got closed, 5000+ people got fired, games got ported to PlayStation, the reward system got gutted, prices were increased multiple times and those new games got removed from game pass and paywalled to a more expensive tier.

MrNinosan7d ago

@GamerRN
I guess you don't subscribe to both services.
PS+ Premium has close to 1000 games.
GPU has less than 500.

GPU doesn't come with Ubisoft Classic.
However, the do have EA Play instead.

GamerRN3d ago (Edited 3d ago )

I pay 120$ a year by using cdkeys.com for GamePass Ultimate

And I definitely have both... My main gripe is PSN extreme or whatever it's called is u don't have all the 1st party stuff I want. That being said I just started up Death Standing Directors cut (terrible game, cool story)... I really want Last of Us Part 1 and Part 2.... Other than that, I don't think I have access to Ubisoft games? Where do I access those? Are there any good ones? The menu system is very confusing trying to go to classic games, PSN collection, etc etc etc

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 3d ago
TheColbertinator8d ago

The FTC should give up. Microsoft owns the US Government and then someday the world and all its useless masses.

Eonjay7d ago

When they run out of fish of course!

The_Hooligan7d ago

So long and thanks for all the fish lol

S2Killinit7d ago

Sounds strange coming from a MS die hard.

Show all comments (80)
150°

Xbox Game Pass Only Has 3 More Games Coming in July 2024

The low number of new games coming to Xbox Game Pass as part of July 2024's Wave 2 lineup couldn't have come at a worse time for Microsoft. Just recently, Microsoft raised the price of Xbox Game Pass, and not only that, but it's announced that major day one releases will be locked behind Game Pass Ultimate. These decisions have understandably upset longtime Xbox Game Pass subscribers, with analysts predicting that another price hike and perhaps an ad-based tier could potentially be introduced down the line.

Read Full Story >>
gamerant.com
10d ago
OtterX9d ago (Edited 9d ago )

You'd think they would have packed the lineup after announcing an impending price increase in Sept.

Bathyj9d ago

That would just be throwing good money after bad at this point. Microsoft needs to just drop this failed experiment altogether, leave Xbox in the wind and become the biggest 3rd party publisher on the planet. It's the only way they will ever be successful in gaming.

darthv729d ago

They already were successful in gaming before joining the console space. And they already are the biggest 3rd party publisher on the planet. They are in this to make $$ from all fronts. So suggesting they bow out and only focus on one area is a stupid idea. They make $$ from all of them, some more than others... but they all make $$.

Bathyj9d ago

The console, and gamepass is just costing them money and splitting their focus. They would make more money simply being a publisher, not a platform holder, and SELLING their games, like publishers are supposed to.

They wouldn't be acting like they are if that wasn't true. Xbox is the red headed step child of Microsoft's gaming portfolio now. Just sell games. You've bought enough Dev's and IP now to do that.

Petebloodyonion9d ago

Rumors are circulating that Microsoft may add Modern Warfare 3 to Game Pass this month, as suggested by the current game release schedule, which lists only five games instead of the usual seven.

OtterX9d ago

That would be a smarter move on their part.

TheColbertinator9d ago (Edited 9d ago )

I welcome that. I could use fresh meat for MW3.

--Onilink--9d ago (Edited 9d ago )

They released 8 games during Wave 1 for July… and the 3 coming now are all actually quite interesting.

Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn (Cloud/PC/Xbox Series X) - July 18
Dungeons of Hinterberg (Cloud/PC/Xbox Series X) - July 18
Kunitsu-Gami: Path of the Goddess (Cloud/Consoles/PC) - July 19

I’d say releasing 11 games in 1 month for gamepass should be enough…

ChasterMies9d ago

The reason for the price increase is the same as the reason for procuring fewer games from their parties; more profit.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 9d ago
anast9d ago

The PS+ model was always the end goal. I'm sure they got a few before closing he net.

TwoPicklesGood9d ago

To be fair, the July releases on Game Pass are great. I'd rather have today on my ps5 then the junk we are given.