Andrew Clark: "It's those "What the hell is that?" moments that made it for me, beyond everything else From Software did to artfully capture my heart on Blu-Ray. You don't have to understand it, and you don't have to understand why you keep going back to it, because the sense of satisfaction you get offers all the explanation you'll ever need. I might have already put in my 2009 Game of the Year nomination, but I have to take it back. Demon's Souls is one of my all-time favorite games. Period."