Hello everyone.
The moderation team has been discussing the recent slew of rumors and how it has affected N4G based on upholding our guidelines on not allowing anonymous rumors and the community who want to discuss what appear to be credible rumors from many sources that we want to discuss but can't. Because, you know, no anonymous sources.
After approval from the BGFG Team, we are going to start a process of vetting anonymous rumors. This will be done by the moderation team and will take into consideration various factors. Does this rumor come from a credible YouTuber with a history of such things and they can't present the original source of the news entirely? Is this something that has been discussed by analysts but not officially announced? Or is this just something that has been reported similarly in the past and has had no legs to stand on? Among other considerations.
Why would you do this now?
The goal of Mod Team Vetting of rumors is to get more discussion on N4G, not to open the doors to anonymous rumors in general. There has to be a middle ground in this age of journalism where people can't reveal who told them what as well as weeding out the rampant rumor mill material that people say just to get attention. We can't trust everyone, but we can trust those sources with a lot of time in the world of journalism and with obvious sources to people in the know. Doing this now helps to get past a blockade on more credible rumors while helping us to prevent the less credible sort.
How will we know a rumor has been vetted?
A report on the submission will be made by a mod team member with the simple text of 'Vetted'. As always, you can see who is and who isn't a moderator from https://n4g.com/users/index... as well as admins from https://n4g.com/users/index... . If anyone not on that list makes such reports, please let the moderation team know via ticket or PM.
What if we disagree with something that was or wasn't vetted?
Disagreements are a part of our discussions about games in general. We're not always going to make people happy with those decisions, but we make them nonetheless with the goal of what is best for N4G and its community and what isn't. In the end, we want good and relevant news on N4G for the community to discuss and we feel that vetting this content is better than our strict 'no anonymously sourced rumors at all' rule.
If you have other questions or concerns, please ask them below.
Thank you,
Christopher
The Honkai Star Rail 2.2 banners introduce Robin and Boothill, alongside returning faces Topaz and Fu Xuan to HoYo's space fantasy RPG on PS5.
Available right now on Xbox, PlayStation, Switch and PC is the latest from a prolific KEMCO team - Horrific Xanatorium; a horror Visual Novel
Gary Green said: You’ll be forgiven if you haven’t heard of the Ar Tonelico trilogy. The previous two games arrived so late in the PS2’s life-cycle that they simply went unnoticed. While most were tinkering with their shiny new PS3s, Ar Tonelico: Melody of Elemia and Ar Tonelico II: Melody of Metafalica were being ‘returned to sender’ by your local Game stores. Luckily, you won’t need to have played them to understand and appreciate this third and final chapter, Qoga (pronounced k-yoga) tells the story of a racial war between humans and Reyvateils, a breed of biologically produced female cyborgs capable of reproduction, while still having a digital mind.
Oh my god. I kinda wish this would get a remaster on PS5, it would be awesome. One of my favorite games on PS3.
That and 3D Dot Game Heroes. It's a shame that some stuff is stuck on PS3.
Ar Tonelico 3 is good I still prefer the first AT game. The music is solid in all the games and Akiko Shikata is a very talented singer bringing life to the game. Only annoying part is well I find is Saki I always choose Finnel or Tyria. KOEI so needs to HD remaster the franchise along with Ar Nosurge and Ciel Nosurge since it never came to North America. I would day one the Ar Toneliceo games and Ar Nosurge if they were remastered.
I still have the limited edition of Qoga unopened. Unfortunately it never went up in value like I had hoped all these years.
Used to own all these quirky JRPG on ps3 good times. Wish I would have kept them all
So this affected the PS5Pro because even though everyone knew it was real, the standards of proof were raised far higher than any other rumor required before it. So at some point with so much evidence and leakers, it becomes news not a rumor. You finally budged when DF said it was real with the same evidence as everyone else.
The original rumor came from Moore's Law is Dead (one of the most accurate leakers on YouTube) and cohobated by Tom Henderson (the most accurate leaker of all time).
Plenty of rumors have been reported by him and approved. There has been literal year of evidence of the PS5 Pro from the most accurate leakers on the internet. Far more reliable than any of the other rumors allowed on this site. This last stand by the mod team to act like it wasn't even worth of a rumor is silly don't you think?
Either way, I appreciate the policy change consideration.
nice to see you are changing your tune regarding rumors. I know it can be hard to take a rumor as truth because many are just people spouting whatever they can to get attention. But some end up being true so having the option to discuss such things is nice. Like the 5Pro rumors and potential games that XB may release on other platforms... stuff like that.
I think this is a good move, bc a lot of this news is being talked about even on the major gaming sites.
There are instances of certain leakers who have a high, high accuracy rate, such as Pyoro who always calls the Nintendo Directs before they happen, even with titles that have never been announced. Pyoro obviously has sort of connection to Nintendo, whether he's a Nintendo employee or someone just really close to one.
But of course, there's a lot of nonsense out there. It's good to vet.
Thanks Christopher for the update, sounds like a step in the right direction. Personally I think the community should decide what is and what isn't allowed and not just the mods but at least we have some progress.
Finally
Rumors are everywhere and at least they cause a discussion while we wait and see if they are true or have can be disproven.
I can see these articles from Reddit to Social media sites such as Facebook or Twitter
When something turns out to be true, N4G just feels like they are behind.