Addict of Fiction - Custard Trout writes: "Winter stars for kinect is a game where you don’t expect a ravishing story or deep emotional bonds. Which is good, because you will find that the story they do have is pretty "peanut" poor."
7 Bit Arcade take a look at the PlayStation Move game, Winter Stars
Impulse Gamer - The Kinect looks good on paper but in theory, controllerless gaming still has a considerable way to go and unfortunately many developers have created some rather un-inspirational and not very entertaining games for this system. There's still only a handful of Kinect titles that are any good.
Even with the latest Forza game, Microsoft included Kinect as a method to control your car but compared to the 360 controller, the accuracy is just not there and to make matters worse, there is a considerable amount of lag with the Kinect.
GameSpot - There are better ways of spending your time during the cold winter months than playing Winter Stars.