In its latest editorial, Gamerlive.tv discusses the awesome footage from Battlefield 3 and Uncharted 3 and wonders...who wins in this battle of awesome gameplay footage?!
im going to say uncharted 3 to be honest battlefields look good for pc but for consoles uncharted 3 wins and a goty inn my book?
It's not all about the graphics, you know. And you never know, battlefield 3 for consoles could look just as great, if not better, than uncharted 3 in its final stage.
No way, uncharted is the best game, no game beats it, its the best game. its the best.
Sony and PS3 owners won, Both these games are on PS3.
gotta giv it to battlefield because they finally officially showed console fotage ... even tho it was the darkest level ever i didnt watch all of uc3 demo because i dont want any more "spoilers"
pc gamers win this time... chin up drake there's always next time. Unless Battlefield is coming out that year too lol. nothing beats gameplay trailers. I mean nothing. You can give me cg trailers all day long. The winner will always go to ingame trailers.
@evrfighter True CG trailers are just a waste of time IMO. However how does this relate to the article. BOTH games and their corresponding Gamescon trailers have all been in-game. Stop being such a pathetic PC fanboy. Both games are AMAZING. Some will prefer Uncharted 3 others will prefer BF3. PS3 gamers however will be able to enjoy both no matter what. Stop being so ignorant.
Nice stealth trolling. What "cg"? http://youtu.be/NP7A90584LM... This was all real-time.
@aviator189 Well you got to remember that if Battlefield isn't finished then neither is Uncharted so BOTH have just as likely a chance to be better in terms of graphics. Honestly both games are on par with each other so far EXCEPT for story because lets face it battlefield and first person shooters in general have never been known for STELLAR stories. Also Uncharted is as of right now the most cinematic game I have seen. I think Battlefield 3 will last me longer because of its multiplayer which is looking to be rivaled by none. But I can agree with you without a doubt though that Battlefield 3 will destroy on PC especially with it benefiting from the extra players and larger maps. But I say let the games speak for themselves because then we all win!
Both - BF3 looked amazing and U3 is making me wqnt to buy a PS3 again
On PC Battlefield 3 is stronger than UC3. But on consoles it's UC3 that blows away anything
The Ps3 version of battlefield was shown at gamescom. Why does everyone think it's the Pc version?
People r talking bout the caspien trailer that was shown at gamescom its clearly PC. Your thinking of that co op vid which was ps3. Go youtube watch the bf3 caspien trailer its all PC loving.
I know but what I meant was that only the ps3 version is playable and that is what people can get their hands on over there at gamescom.
Yeah, but what if Battlefield 3 looks as good as it does on consoles? Then what? :D
Trinity and Morpheus disagreed with you.
BF3 has the internet more or less on fire it seems, mostly due to it being a multiplat game with an overall bigger fanbase than Uncharted. (As well as the huge marketing behind it) Personally, I'd say it was pretty close, but that little robot-drone gives BF3 the edge.
LOL the little robot-drone part was hilarious, but I gotta give to to UC3. That trailer blew my mind. What a rush. Edit: At the end of day we PS3 owners can enjoy both. CHEERS!
but I saw most of that Uncharted footage from the last trailer. This Battlefield footage is new and awesome.
UC3 for me!!!!!
another war game, albeit a well done war game by a proven developer or. http://www.youtube.com/watc... i really want both but if i had to choose, i would go with or.
BF3 for me. Don't get me wrong I am still excited about Uncharted 3, but it will be pretty much more of the same, just different location and story. Same gameplay.
Pshhh that is the same thing for BF3, another shooter with new locations. The story will not be as good as uncharted no way. And it's another shooter woo hoo.
Story - UC Multiplater - BF /end
Well for me I'll most likely enjoy Uncharted 3's MP more. I'm just a tad tired of FPS's myself and overall prefer TPS's over them. I'm sure the majority will say BF3's is better. Both will be amazing, but I see myself spending more time in Uncharted 3's. It just seems like there is more lasting appeals in Uncharted 3's MP than there is in BF3's. There is just a LOT more content to mess around with and unlock in Uncharted 3's. P.S. I'm not hating on BF3 in anyway. No matter what platform it is on I'm 100% it'll be a must buy this year. It'll also probably win the majority of Best MP of the Year awards along with some GoTY. Overall though Uncharted 3 appeals more to me and I just prefer it over BF3 myself. I'll be enjoying both on my PS3 though in October.
That's cool.Everyone has different preferences.I enjoyed UC multi player as well I just don't enjoy as much as I do some other games.
Im gonna buy both...
Agreed... Doesn't matter who "won" because I am buying both and will play through both.
I won... hands down..
Can't say I'm too excited for Uncharted 3. I loved the first one, couldn't get into the second, and the third has simply fallen off the grid. The mp footage shown for BF3 looks like its going to be a blast. Can't wait for that one, especially considering all footage is coming from alpha.
You loved the first one but couldn't get into the second? Why not?
It was just one of the those things. The main thing was that I couldn't get into the story (one of the few I'm sure). I didn't particularly enjoy the mp. Same thing happened with God of War, I loved, loved, loved the first two and then found my self dissatisfied with the 3rd. It happens. I'm not saying they were bad games, just that I didn't enjoy them.
No, I finished both of them when they first came out. I couldn't just leave myself hanging. I'll play U3 too, to finish up loose ends, but like I said, I'm not particularly excited.
So you never finished it, or you finished it and didn't like it?
I win, I preordered both :D
I'm glad I will get to enjoy Uncharted on PS3 and BF3 on PC. I normally don't play on PC, but some of the Battlefield 3 PC footage stands out.
They both look amazing and I am getting both of them.
That's the answer that everyone seems to like. :D
BOTH LOOK GOOD BUT IN ALL HONESTY FPS ARE A BIT CLICHE SO UN3 IS A BREATH OF FRESH AIR FOR ME
In reply to all the PS3 fantards above, its a a shame the average PC these thats used for gaming is about 5 times more powerful than the PS3, its outdated and aging fast in terms of hardware, uncharted 3s MP sucks and I mean sucks, its just crap, it feels like a cartoon. Once I rent and complete the Single player sorry uncharted but you are just eclipsed by BF3 & Skyrim
Standard fanboy mentality. Just find something to complain about and drag it on and on...
Meh you just suck at the mp
Standard fanboy mentality, feel the need to jump in and defend your chosen fanboy flavour. Im not a vanilla commentor, sorry I dont see the fuss over uncharted, it has limited interaction, doesnt suit MP at all, it would be much better having an extended campagn than a tacked on MP, co-op is a good idea though but PVP just doesnt work with the games mechanics IMO. It is a very good game but when you get morons jumping in saying "ITs DA BEST GAME EVAR!" solely because its on th PS3 then thats just stupid. I suck at a video game? my life must be over.
@markus Its not the best game ever because its on a single platform. Its one of the best games ever because it has the merits to back up that claim. Most GOTY awards ever? Check Very high sales? Check One of the highest scores on metacritic? Check Please open your mind. You do have fanboy mentality. Its time you grew a gamer mentality and enjoy your chosen entertainment medium to its fullest. It truly will be a great time to be a Gamer starting next month! Gears!!!
I am purchasing both day one, however UC3 for me looks better and will have the edge. As for the comment someone made tht uc3 will be a lil of the same what the hell you thnk bf3 will be? Same bf recipe with better graphics and diff locations but just another bf shooter and a military one at tht. These gamesd are suppose to be this way and its a proven recipe tht works you just add new thngs everyyear and up the graphics. If you want something new and wholely diff get a new ip game like limbo lol but dnt be surprised if all these games is a lil of the same.
No doubt both games are going to offer much of the same look and feel as previous games... I gotta disagree on BF3 slightly. The co-op play they showed off on stage at Gamescon felt VERY different from previous games like BFBC2 single player. It almost had a stealth like elemenent to it. I mean, I would never expect a BF game to feature security cameras that you need to avoid detection or else it will set off alarms. It really was a very different feel and vibe to a game that typically is just all about the shooting and squad play.
While they both looked absolutely intense. I would have to say in the story department Uncharted 3, and Battlefield 3 gets the multiplayer. Uncharted 3 just looks amazing, and the voice acting and dialog were freakin top notch. Battlefield 3 looks to have the intensity of the battlefield (no pun intended) thrown in your face at all times during MP. I simply cant wait to play this. I am primarily a PS3 gamer, but the bigger maps, better online options, more people in VS on multiplayer just may have me sold on Battlefield 3 on PC. Though i will still be playing UC3 mp quite often.
N4G is a community of gamers posting and discussing the latest game news. It’s part of NewsBoiler, a network of social news sites covering today’s pop culture.