It's not easy to choose between two obvious Game of the Year candidates, but in reality, not everyone can afford to buy every game out there. So GamePro poses the question: If you had to choose, would you buy BioShock or Halo 3? GamePro breaks each game down into eight categories to see who emerges victorious.
Both BioShock and Halo 3 are classic shooters and hold up as two of the best games of all time. If you look at the results by category, it's easy to understand. If you're not much of an online gamer, BioShock is your best bet. If you consistently play on Xbox Live, you need Halo 3. But really, the final choice is simple: find the money to buy both.
Here is the list of the categories and its winners. See the article for the detailed explanation:
Story - winner: BioShcok
Graphics - winner: BioShcok
Sound - winner: BioShcok
Arsenal - winner: Halo 3
Controls - winner: Halo 3
Single-Player - winner: BioShcok
Multiplayer - winner: Halo 3, obviously
Innovation - winner: Halo 3
Replayability - winner: Halo 3