Kotaku posts:
" OK, you've had an hour or so to argue, debate and decide which games you thought should receive which nominations, including the cherished Best of Show accolade. Now it's our turn. Before you hit the jump to see our picks know this, there was a whole lotta arguing that led up to these final selections and on more than one occasion it came down to votes... on one occasion that vote tied and we had to debate the issue for awhile. Also keep in mind that we made these choices based off of the very specific definitions that The Game Critics Awards follows. So Best of Show gives a lot of weight to buzz. Also, there were two categories that we didn't feel had three worthy nominations, so we didn't include them. They were fighting game and simulation game."
Why isn't gran turismo 5 under graphics, or metroid prime anywhere on that list? Wiifit won many awards, for what? It is a yoga fitness game. Heavenly sword, and uncharted should be on the action list, replacing assasin creed, and folklore. Also why isn't crysis n the best graphical achievement? It looks better then mass effect, killzone 2, and mgs4. Kotaku, are you actually gamers? How could you list wii fit as best of show?
KZII isn't even in here.
What a load of crap this site is. As always.
You want overhyped? It's called Super Mario Galaxy, and Wii Fit.
Anyway, stupid list. It doesn't list half the GREAT games that were at the show.
maybe its a typo and should say "Worst of E3"
Its good they put MGS on top, the trailer for MGS simply didnt get what it deserved. It was great.