GamesRader writes: "Nostalgia? Please. As great as the original Secret of Monkey Island is, it's a new adventure we've all been craving. Even though Tales is the first of the series not made by LucasArts (although Telltale have no shortage of people who worked on them, such as Dave Grossman and Mike Stemmle), make no mistake: it's officially the fifth game in the series, not some farmed-out spin-off."
* Funniest comedy adventure in ages
* Solid writing
* Excellent puzzle design
* Some tedious jungle exploration
* No new standout characters
* Will have to wait for the next chapter