Crispy Gamer writes: "The game was the perfect late-night, just-getting-in, don't-want-to-think-too-much, I've-had-too-many-beers experience. It was always just challenging enough to make me feel like I was doing something interesting and, ideally, exciting. Unlike other sports games, I didn't have to monkey around with rosters or worry about draft days, or how much I'd charge for the average seat in the upper deck. It was pure. It was baseball sans the bullshit. Unlike other sports games, I could load up the game and instantly get a tangible payoff."
A fan of The Bigs 2, Flynn from Leviathyn.com talks about how much he'd love to see the return of an arcade-style sports game in The Bigs 3.
Justin Lacey offers up some historical video game examples of how to improve the sport of baseball.
The only worthwhile addition to the game is "Become a Legend" where you take a slugger from obscurity to the Hall of Fame. This is great for a while, but after the 26th time your potential home run is caught by yet another 30ft diving catch you'll be left in controller-throwing frustration. It's then you realise The Bigs 2 is excellent against mates or for a blast online, but its arcade style means it's not best suited to longer game modes.