Gameplay Monthly writes: "Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume is a highly decent game that any RPG lover should play through at least once. This said, the lack of voice acting in the US version, along with various other things hold it back from being a fantastic game. If you like the Valkyrie Profile series, you'll probably like this game. If you're just a fan of RPGs in general, you'll probably like the game for its unique story. Whatever the case, Covenant is definitely a game worth playing, but not one that sticks out as "fantastic" in my book".