WTMG's Leo Faria: "I cannot stress how disappointed I was with The Inquisitor. It’s all due to how much I wanted to love it. Its setting and premise are downright amazing. I loved Königstein and the mysteries haunting it. I wanted to know what would happen next in this crapsack world. Sadly, that required playing the actual game, which ended up being janky, messy, and full of questionable design choices. I commend the developers for taking risks when trying to adapt an unknown book into a game, but for as interesting as The Inquisitor is, it’s not worth playing it in this current state."
Gareth writes: "The Inquisitor is an entertaining game; ambitious and unique, but ultimately it is too rough around the edges to hit the heights."
NoobFeed Jay Claassen writes - The Inquisitor has nearly endless potential to be great, but it’s so damn hard to get into the story, even if is based on a set of stories from a Polish author. It’s got a solid base, interesting mechanics, and brilliant voice acting, but the execution seems to need some work, and this detracts from the game in all the worst ways.
Playing a medieval church cop hunting a vampire is a great concept, but blurry choices, weak combat, and a ton of handholding keep The Inquisitor from leading a compelling inquisition.