200°

Best RPG of 2023

VGChartz's Miles Gregory: "2023 was a fantastic year for video games in general, but it was particularly notable for those who love RPGs, especially those of a Western style. We saw the release of the highly anticipated Starfield from Bethesda, the same studio that arguably helped evolve the Western RPG genre into what it is today. Baldur’s Gate III took the world by storm, providing an experience that modernizes the old Western RPG formula while simultaneously paying close respect to the Dungeons & Dragons source material from which it's based off of. The release of Final Fantasy XVI pushed the series into a new direction, with combat that feels fast, fluid, satisfying, and distinctly Western in style contrary to what the series, and even the developer, is renowned for.

But if you're looking for something that feels a bit more like the Square Enix of old, look no further than Sea of Stars, which once again proved that you don’t have to be a large studio to make a memorable and critically acclaimed RPG. With so many fantastic games to choose from, who will the winner be?"

Read Full Story >>
vgchartz.com
LordoftheCritics106d ago

Hogwarts Legacy is a better RPG than Starfield.

Sonic1881105d ago

Even Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty DLC is better than Starfield

NiceneCreeder105d ago

solitaire is a better RPG than Starfield

anast106d ago

When the writer puts Starfield in the same room with BG3, everyone knows that the writer is not capable of doing their job.

coolbeans105d ago

*Sigh* Shouldn't be surprised at this point.

It's important to know: this writer didn't put Starfield in the same room with Baldur's Gate 3, these shortlists are tallied by weighing staff & community votes together (50/50 split). Whichever games make it past the prelims (between 5-7) are then refreshed for everyone to vote once again. These are the ones that made the shortlist.

anast105d ago

*sigh

Was any WRPG under the sun was available for this list? Why wasn't Starfield left off?

*sigh

We saw a middle effort by Bethesda's Starfield while BG3 reset the bar to where is should be. Despite this... and so on...This would have been a more honest write up, if the writers were actual critics.

coolbeans105d ago (Edited 105d ago )

-"*sigh*"

Haha. Just to be clear: I didn't mean that personally. It's more directed at how it seems like every year I have to explain how the voting process is more than "here's x writer's best, 2nd best, and top 4 RPGs of 2023."

-"Was any WRPG under the sun was available for this list? Why wasn't Starfield left off?"

So, I went and looked at the final voting list again. It did have Hogwarts Legacy & Super Mario RPG on there, but they didn't make the shortlist cutoff. Again, Starfield wasn't cut off b/c it received an accumulative amount between staff & community (50/50 divide). Only difference between staff & community votes is staff can list a winner & runner-up option.

-"We saw a middle effort by Bethesda's Starfield while BG3 reset the bar to where is should be. Despite this... and so on...This would have been a more honest write up, if the writers were actual critics."

I just don't get it. The fascination of *NOT* having Starfield make a shortlist seems insanely spite-driven. It's garnered a mid-80s critic response and has a wild amount of players who've dumped dozens of hours into it. Pretending as though this is an affront to RPG GOTY lists is so divorced from reality, especially since it's likely to net overall GOTYs from a few random outlets. Speaking about this optically, you look a bit unhinged in catastrophizing this situation as though it permanently damages the reputations of everyone involved. It's just that a bunch of people are effusive about Starfield to either claim it was the best or 2nd best RPG they played last year.

anast104d ago

A wild amount of time is spent on Candy Crush. If this is the metric, then the critics failed to see games as an art and more like an amusement park. Most Game critics are not critics, they do not have any foundational theory that they work from, they are advertisement writers. This is the reality of it and this is why I say that most game critics are actually not critics, and this is why Starfield is on a list with the best.

Actually it is your comment that seems unhinged. You could have used less words, but you didn't, for probably unhinged reasons.

coolbeans103d ago

Okay, now this *sigh* is personally for you and your spiel. You understand how such determinations of "Best RPG" are going to come with competing theories between different groups of people, right? Again, you're talking about a split voting influence between community and staff.

-"A wild amount of time is spent on Candy Crush. If this is the metric, then the critics failed to see games as an art and more like an amusement park."

Now you're just lumping one of the laziest Skinner boxes with an open-world RPG. You're pushing a false equivalence while disregarding the context with which I'm talking about Starfield's popularity. Again, I'm only trying to frame this as an outsider (haven't gotten to it yet) and rebutting this over-zealous language, as though Todd Howard personally pissed in your cereal.

-"Actually it is your comment that seems unhinged. You could have used less words, but you didn't, for probably unhinged reasons."

Good grief! lol

Zenzuu106d ago

Starfield even being mentioned automatically makes the article redundant.

FinalFantasyFanatic106d ago

Should have replaced Starfield with something else, there's heaps of games that are much better than it.

Elda106d ago

My pick is FFXVI which I just finished. Can't wait to play the upcoming dlc "The Rising Tide"

Show all comments (26)
290°

Todd Howard says Starfield's Shattered Space DLC launches this fall.

"Big update coming really soon" has city maps and shipbuilding improvements

The update "should be" properly revealed this week

Read Full Story >>
gamesradar.com
InUrFoxHole17h ago

Oh stop ✋️. Starfield is a good game. But definitely could be better. Would like some quality of life changes. Although if past games are anything to go by. Bethesda is gonna rely on the community to update the game :(

Gaming4Life198116h ago

Exactly Starfield is a good game and I can't wait until we get mod support. I'm looking forward to the new update and dlc.

Crows9016h ago

Its not though. If it was more people would be playing it but its long forgotten. Its average at best.

Armaggedon14h ago

@Crows90 You are looking at numbers, numbers dont tell the whole story. What about Palworlds 90+ percent drop off, or other games like that dropped lst year? People that think starfield is bad will find “evidence “ that it is, but its just confirmation bias my friend.

notachance14h ago

eh, bethesda completely killed the sense of exploration in starfield. In fallout and elder scrolls I could walk to a mission objective only to get knee deep on a random vault/cave 3 hours later because I randomly encounter other missions on the way, in starfield it's just travelling from city to objective to city to objective again...

would've been way better if they just make 3-4 planets but with big open area each full of contents.

Crows9014h ago(Edited 14h ago)

@armageddon

There's no bias. I played the game. Beat it. There's nothing interesting throughout the entire game...half baked systems galore. Just boring content...tons of boring content.

I have more fun throwing bread and chairs at players in chivalry 2 than in the entire Starfield experience. That's not bias...I don't care about numbers. Nobody cares about Starfield. It was a failed attempt ..maybe they'll do better with the next one.

Maybe if they give it to obsidian we'll get something awesome like fallout New Vegas. Hopefully with less bugs.

1Victor8h ago

So does this confirm a PS5 release by winter? 🤣

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 8h ago
Becuzisaid9h ago

@Armageddon "you're looking at numbers, Numbers don't tell the whole story..."

Seriously? You're argument is stop giving logical evidence. And giving evidence is showing bias?? Democrat much?

Armaggedon14h ago

My my, look at all these downvotes to people that actually like the game. Time to get a mind of your own people.

shinoff218314h ago

How is it not having a mind of your own to not like the game. I bought a whole series x for this and was pretty disappointed. No lore, exploration(half baked unlike their other games, and it felt like a step back), lack of lore, etc. As it stands I don't really like the game. I think it's a bad game and a huge step back. Step back is the problem as well. With that said I'll try it again after some of my complaints are fixed. Sadly though I doubt my lore issue(no books or pc's to actually read like their other games) will be fixed. Trust me I didn't spend series x money to say I didn't like the game.

Lightning772h ago

I highly doubt you got a X to play it. Or played it at all. The games in the future you're not gonna find booke and their are PC's to get back story.

You're lying.

Wretchedstain14h ago

This happens far too often on here.

"Whats that?!?, you like something that I don't? Here's a down-vote to you good sir for liking something..."

(Down-votes inbound)

Extermin8or3_13h ago

Literally the point of down voting is to down vote takes you don't agree with. So if most people think the game is mediocre at best then yeah praising it will get down voted.

Eonjay8h ago

I think that's the point. I get down votes all the time because I say stuff some people don't like or don't agree with. I didn't agree or disagree because I never played the game.

Crows903h ago

Down votes mean people disagree with the statement.

For instance. You said it happens too often and assume it's simply because people don't like what you like...that's not it...that's not the reason.

And that is why you're getting down votes.

Hofstaderman13h ago(Edited 13h ago)

Have you seen the Steam engagement numbers? I mean don't you guys gauage a games sucess on engagement these days? This game was slated as THE game to be played for months and years.... Allow me to save you the click its low.

dumahim3h ago

If I wasn't at work, I'd create a K2SO meme, "It's low. It's very low."

Barlos13h ago

What if, and hear me out here, but what if... these people actually don't like the game? I know, I know, pretty profound.

CrimsonWing697h ago

My, my, look all the upvotes to people actually not liking the game. Seems like they have a mind different than yours… maybe one that we can say is their own.

Nobody’s taking away your right to freely enjoy the game. I personally, enjoy some dumpster fire trash games. This particular one just helps cure insomnia… hell, just discussing this game is making me yawn.

Lightning771h ago

Lol no. Notice how it's only known Sony fanboys that have a extreme negative reaction to this game on here. Y'all Have had this reaction since the game released. I've never seen such hate and emotional reaction over a single game in my life yet leave it to Sony fanboys like yourself to set a unwritten record of most hate for a game. Clearly just look around in this comment section.

CrimsonWing691h ago

@Lightning77

I can only speak for myself, but I bought this game, yes bought, so I’m not sure where in the hell that makes me a Sony fanboy. I own all the f*cking consoles, so quit b*thing about fanboys just because people didn’t like this game. I think it’s completely underwhelming and quite frankly one of the most boring experiences I’ve ever had the displeasure of experiencing.

You go ahead and like the game, bub. Nobody says you can’t, but don’t get your panties in a bunch when people voice their opinion on the game and don’t go trying to make claims it’s only fanboys that hate it.

People just don’t like it, it’s just one of those things you’ll have to learn to deal with.

Lightning7750m ago(Edited 47m ago)

"so quit b*thing about fanboys just because people didn’t like this game."

The ones who are genuinely underwhelmed at SF are hardcore Bethesda fans. What's the only fanbase or fanbases that takes a game that's only on one console dials up the hate to a maximum? Half these ppl here are lying about playing it they don't have Xbox. It's fanboys don't cover up their behavior. I see the same ones here, hell even on twitter the same culprits every time. They all have extreme fanboy track record I see a recognize and I can easily point them out. It's not hard.

If I enjoyed the game or not doesn't matter it's the terrible, toxic fanboys over this game is the issue.

There very fact you say "ppl voicing their opinions" is beyond hilarious. These aren't ppl they're fanboys. I recognize most of these ppl here all over Xbox news and games in general through out the years. Nice excuse.

You're not gonna win at this. You can keep deflecting and making excuses for them for their behavior. The fact that it's "oh it's just honest gamers voicing their opinions'" makes you very, very sus none logical person.

Or one of them.

CrimsonWing690m ago(Edited 0m ago)

@Lightning 77

I can’t tell if you’re trolling or not.

Do you realize your comments are probably the most fanboy responses in this entire comment section?

If anyone’s “sus” it’s you and your paranoia perspective on everyone who doesn’t agree with your fanboy stance on the game.

You’ve definitely demonstrated how impossible it is to have a discussion about anything with a fanboy.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 0m ago
Becuzisaid4h ago

No one is downvoting you because you like a game that they don't. They downvote you because you're a smug, contrarian, ignorant person that seemingly exists just to tell people they're wrong for thinking differently than you do.

Crows903h ago

Follow your own advice and stop worrying about what other think...

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 0m ago
Barlos13h ago(Edited 13h ago)

Thank you Todd! Thank you Phil! Thank you team Xbox!! Thank you Bethesda! Thank you to my mom for giving birth to me so I could experience this masterpiece of a game!! This is the most amazing news I've ever heard!!! DLC to the best game ever made!!!

Let's gooooo!

!!!1!!

Eonjay8h ago

I'm half expecting them to announce it for PlayStation next week.

Barlos5h ago

You never know. I'd still not buy it.

Extermin8or3_13h ago

Cool so I bet the PS5 version with all the updates and the expansion etc releases early next year then. I'm not particularly fussed or looking to buy it given my time with the game on pc was very "meh" but importantly it will help prove a point to all those in denial claiming the reports about a starfield port were wrong.

CobraKai12h ago

I enjoyed the game. I wasnt into Skyrim that much but using a sci fi setting got me into this one

Crows903h ago

I was honestly super excited for it. Just found it too shallow and uninteresting. Rather play mass effect.

CobraKai14m ago

Mass Effect is one of my favorite games of all time. I like em both tho. Maybe ill try Skyrim again

Show all comments (46)
110°

I’ll Never Beat Baldur's Gate 3 Honour Mode

I'll stick with Tactician for now.

Read Full Story >>
thegamer.com
jambola2d ago

Fascinating
If anyone is interested, I will never beat X-COM on the hardest difficulty
For a list of games I will never complete on a specific difficulty
Feel free to subscribe to my professional" news site

Michiel19891d 6h ago

I can't really remember if I tried xcom 1 on the hardest difficulty but I gave xcom 2 on the hardest difficulty and ironman plenty of shots and it just seemed impossible. I don't often give up, but that game beat me.

anast1d 7h ago

No real examples on why honor mode was too difficult. What I mean by this is there was no mention of the builds and gear he/she was using or classes and races.

Nittdarko1d 4h ago

I mean I understand, after 14 attempts (non cheese) me and 2 friends finally beat it, It's really not for your everyday party adventurers

Don't get me wrong, a casual player could easily google (BG3 cheese builds) and Moon druid or Tavern brawler their way to victory with some ease, but going in playing it blind or telling yourself not to break the game and play normally is never going to end well at all.

Funny as well because Divinity Original Sin 2's honor mode was a fraction of the difficulty of BG3.

Popsicle1d ago (Edited 23h ago)

I won’t either. I am a dirty save scummer who definitely lacks honor on my dice rolls and checks. Not turning TAV into a squid just because I wanted a few parasites burrowed into his brain. Lol

60°

Review: Final Fantasy 16 — The Rising Tide | Console Creatures

Bobby writes, "Final Fantasy 16 — The Rising Tide is a great expansion but it's on the short side."

Read Full Story >>
consolecreatures.com