VGChartz's Lee Mehr: "While capturing a serene environment, Lake's main shortcoming stems back to wanting to emulate a Zen-like gameplay routine without any sort of quality hook. Season's Greetings showcases Providence Oaks in a new season, but doesn’t think of adding much beyond this new coat of paint. From the repetitive delivery routine to a flimsy narrative, it's hard to blame anyone wanting to avoid this town during the holidays."
“A month of top-notch indie games just passed us by so let's take a look back at the best indies from December in 12 unique categories.” - A.J. Maciejewski from Video Chums.
William writes: "I enjoyed my time revisiting Providence Oaks in Lake: Season's Greetings. The loveable characters, heartwarming story and classic Christmas tone make this well worth a pick-up over the Holiday season, even if some technical qualms hold it back from tree-topping star status."