180°
7.0

Tears of the Kingdom Review - But Why Tho

Charles writes, "For the right kind of player, someone who just wishes to explore and live in a gorgeously designed fantasy setting, this game will offer countless hours of enjoyment. However, if you are like me and when you are presented with a quest to undertake you simply wish to follow that quest in a way that feels fluid and rewarding, this game has some huge hurdles to overcome."

Read Full Story >>
butwhytho.net
Jin_Sakai753d ago

TotK got a 7/10? But why tho?

SullysCigar753d ago

Lmao I see what you did there

GoodGuy09753d ago

About 50hrs in and I can see why some scores are low. The game is a huge copy and paste from botw for one, and there's still a lot of problems, as a longtime zelda fan, that I have with it again steering away from traditional zelda and nore towards skyrim/minecraft. Still really enjoying it a lot nonetheless.

SullysCigar753d ago

"copy and paste" Agreed. This is my biggest issue. It feels like they've just re-released BotW with a different story and some creation options. It even looks the same, with the same graphical issues. I'd honestly rather they'd waited for new hardware, so we'd benefit from technical advancements, because that would make it feel fresher.

Can you imagine going straight from BotW to TotK? That's when 7/10 seems fair, to me, because it's just too similar.

anast753d ago

There's no way this game should get GOTY.

anast753d ago

To start: 700p-900p in 2023. From a technical standpoint, the game is jank. Not to mention it's a copy paste game. Might as well give BoTW the GOTY this year.

MIDGETonSTILTS17753d ago (Edited 753d ago )

It’s not our Zelda with glass jars required to catch fairies, and temples that might actually stump you and you’ll have to invite a friend over for help.

BotW and TotK focussed on creativity over challenge, which is a reasonable pivot for the franchise to make.

If you want to feel the same feelings OoT and MM gave us, then find your personal Souls game (mine is Demon’s).

gleepot753d ago

Yeah I get this. An example with the Souls games-- I really don't enjoy Elden Ring. I think it is a very unenjoyable experience, and I like my souls games to be somewhat linear and claustrophobic and that the franchise does not lend itself well to an open-world experience. That doesn't mean Elden Ring is a bad game, it's an objective masterpiece in for what it is (an open-world souls game), but it's not a subjective masterpiece for what I want out of it.

Bloodborne, however, is exactly the kind of experience I want out of a souls game. It's a top 5 all-time game for me.

Zeldafan64753d ago

There's plenty of challenging puzzles in both games if you actually want to find them.

MIDGETonSTILTS17752d ago

All I’m saying is I’ve watched my fiancé play for at least 20 hours now, and nothing seems to have compared to the Forest Temple’s hallways in Majora’s Mask.

But I’m sure there is more to come. I DO have alotta respect for the climbing and building mechanics… those would’ve been fun 20-25 years ago on N64.

gleepot753d ago

Reviews are weird. I totally understand where people come from when they play a game they aren't into and end up giving the scores they do, but I can't help but feel that games should be critiqued and reviewed by people who actually enjoy the genre of said game.

If someone is going to review a game for a genre they don't enjoy, they really need to approach it from an objective standpoint and not a subjective one, which I realize is a little confusing since a review is an entirely subjective thing. Perhaps I just feel that to be a journalist and a critique requires a very analytical mindset.

Show all comments (14)
60°
9.0

The Legend Of Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom (Switch 2) -A Sublime Sequel, Now Sublimer| NintendoLife

"When all's said and done, Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition is a fantastic revamp of perhaps Nintendo's most sublime sequel. What was once a technical marvel on aged hardware now has a chance to truly shine, with visual and performance boosts undoubtedly making it the definitive way to play.

Nothing will ever match the feeling of playing it for the first time, of course, and some bonus content would have been welcome, but armed with Zelda Notes and the promise of buttery smooth upgrades, I'd challenge anyone to dip back in without losing hours to its unrivalled wonder." - Jim Norman | NintendoLife

Read Full Story >>
nintendolife.com
50°

Zelda Notes is Actually Impressive and Adds More Story

Ben of Netto’s Game Room discusses the Zelda Notes App and why he feels it is actually pretty impressive, and well worth checking out!

Read Full Story >>
nettosgameroom.com
210°

List of all prices for Nintendo Switch 2 Upgrade Packs

Prices revealed for all Nintendo Switch 2 Upgrade Packs, coming from both Nintendo and third-parties.

Read Full Story >>
nintendoeverything.com
IanTH47d ago (Edited 47d ago )

I argue that simple res/FPS bumps should be free, and then you can charge $10 if it includes actual extra content. That seems to be what has been settled on.

Many PS4 games got free upgrades for PS5 when just increasing res/FPS. Days Gone, for example, got a free FPS bump to start the generation. Now it's getting a "remaster", improved visuals/extra modes/content for $10.

I know they have *some* free upgrades - though we don't know what they entail - but the Zelda games just seem like they know they can get money from eager new buyers, so why not. Zelda Notes doesn't quite seem to justify $10, but hey, let us choose. Make it a $10 app, and give the res/FPS upgrades for free.

CrashMania47d ago

Weird the Jamboree pack being 20 with no new boards or minigames for party mode, way to miss the mark. Minigame variety is seriously lacking for the party mode compared to superstars, my biggest issue with the game, think I'll pass on that.

L3e47d ago

I wonder if there will be supply issues (unable to find the system). Interesting that they are launching in the middle of the year as well.

gold_drake46d ago

some of these are abit pricey.
like why?

neutralgamer199246d ago

It's Nintendo they know they can get away with it. Bits that simple

Dhika46d ago

Why the differences in prices?