260°

Comparing Horizon Forbidden West and Red Dead Redemption 2's Open-World Design

Horizon Forbidden West and Red Dead Redemption 2 are both stellar games, and their approaches to the open-world format are markedly different.

Read Full Story >>
gamerant.com
Jin_Sakai1154d ago (Edited 1154d ago )

Both games have amazing graphics but one is actually fun to play.

MajorLazer1154d ago

Wow, over 40 million people bought a game that isn't fun. 97 meta rating, universally praised as one of the most detailed and realistic games ever with detail no other game has ever matched. This site has a proper hard on for hating on RDR2.

lucian2291154d ago

I got bored of the game in three hours. It's soooooooo slow and boring. Needlessly so.

tay87011154d ago

red dead redemption is one of my all time favorite games, red dead 2 was a massive disapointment for me though. i too got very bored with it very quickly.

Jin_Sakai1154d ago (Edited 1154d ago )

“I got bored of the game in three hours. It's soooooooo slow and boring. Needlessly so.”

Same. It’s an amazing looking game but It got boring fast and it controls like a sloth.

Elda1153d ago

40 million may have bought RDR2 but that doesn't mean all 40 million enjoyed it. I bought it & thought it was a bore-fest.

outsider16241153d ago

What hate? I was hyped like anything for Rdr2. Got it on day 1. Yes the game is freaking immersive and one of the if not the most detailed game I've ever seen.

But boy...Jin Sakai is right, it does get boring and so unfun to play. After i finished the campaign, i haven't touched it again.

KyRo1153d ago (Edited 1153d ago )

It sold 40 million because it's a Rockstar game. A quick Google search will show you a lot of people found RDR2 Boring. The first game was enjoyable but the pacing of the second made it boring.

EnricoPallazzo1153d ago

I must concur with the prevailing opinion. Honestly, including a fast travel option other than the mostly useless one they gave would have helped a lot. I got tired of retreading the same ground just to get to a mission start

Bathyj1153d ago

40 million bought it and I bet you about a million finished it. Game was a snooze fest and I'm a big western fan. First game was way more fun.

MajorLazer1153d ago

44% completed the main game and 40% completed the epilogue according to the trophy list so try again. Shocking how so many people completed a game that's supposedly boring and long.

ScootaKuH1153d ago (Edited 1153d ago )

That's all fine and that, but that doesn't mean that Jin has to find it fun just because it sold a lot and got great reviews.

Does the fact that The Last of Us got rave reviews mean I'm wrong because I didn't like it? Have you never liked a game that reviewed and sold well?

Wrex3691153d ago

That and almost everyone here can't see two words that is talking critically about their preferred platform or game without knee jerking into a rant.

Lexreborn21153d ago

Honestly, I didn’t like the game at all. Tried it on Gamepass and was not impressed.

NecrumOddBoy1153d ago

I bought RDR2 day one and got bored of it too. But it just wasn’t the time to play it. I picked it back up last year and played it on PS5. What a masterpiece of game design, storytelling, and world design. 97 Meta doesn’t mean it’s for everyone and for me, it wasn’t at the time but I am glad I restarted it. It’s a great game but truly does take committed time to experience.

+ Show (10) more repliesLast reply 1153d ago
anast1153d ago

Nice opinion. The thing about opinions is that they can still be bad opinions.

Ezio20481154d ago

It is an honor for Horizon that its world is being compared to RDR2.

Gardenia1153d ago

Better to compare Horizon Forbidden West with Horizon Zero Dawn. There is so much more variety in the world of HFW, the people, nature, weather, enemies, towns. It's all a step up from HZD.

gammaray131154d ago

Forbidden West leaves RDR2 for dead and its not boring

1153d ago
Sciurus_vulgaris1154d ago

RDR 2’s world is more dynamic than the one present in Horizon Forbidden West. NPC behaviour and interactions in RDR 2 are more dynamic too. But you have to keep in mind the worlds of the two games are designed for differing levels of interactions.

WGAF1154d ago

I think it is better to compare HFW to more AC like games or Farcry, particularly Farcry Primal to be exact. These games do have more focus on combat and such (which can be quite fun) and looks insanely beautiful.

Nevertheless, interm of insane details, how grounded/interactive the world are (has actual physicality that enable ones to really play around with it surrounding), and surprising randomness elements of encounters as you explore, it cant be compare to games like RDR2, Skyrim, or BOW, not by a long shot.

Games that really put emphasis on pure exploration, surprising random encounters, or provide trully interactive environment (a true sandbox), are quite rare. Most open world games just looks pretty, but you just cant interact with it by any means. Perhaps, that weren't their focus anyway, so cant really compare them in that case.

mkis0071153d ago

Skyrim rdr2 and BOW sacrice in other areas though to get there.

Show all comments (42)
70°

Top 10 Video Games That Feel Like Reading a Good Book

For World Book Day, here are 10 video games that feel like reading a good book—emotional, thoughtful, and unforgettable stories.

Read Full Story >>
clouddosage.com
S2Killinit2d ago (Edited 2d ago )

I would have included the Uncharted games as well. Good list though.

Yui_Suzumiya2d ago

Island would be #1 but that would be anything from Frontwing.

QueenOfFrowns2d ago

Haha it is not lost on me that two of the games in the top four were already novels before they were games

290°

I Watched the Leaked Horizon AI Tech Demo Through My Fingers

Maybe I'm turning into "old man yells at cloud."

Read Full Story >>
thegamer.com
Rancegamerx32d ago

So lame, a tech demo was conducted to test new technology. This is nothing new; they've been doing this since the 1980s. There have been thousands of tech demos that led to nothing. That said, AI is here to stay, and it will eventually find its way into games in one form or another. It's time to stop the overly dramatic reactions and accept reality.

Christopher32d ago

Talk about a 180 midway through your argument. Perhaps that 180 is why people are talking about it?

darthv7232d ago

What he said was not wrong though... AI is here and being used more and more is different industries. Its not like it is going away anytime soon.

Christopher31d ago

@darth: Where did I say he was wrong other than expressing that it's this thinking that people are talking about it? He complained about people talking about a tech demo being shown to the public as an expression of AI's use being popularized and then proved it with his own words. I didn't say they were wrong, only it only gives credence to those who are worried about the popularization and use of AI in the industry to replace actual actors.

Rancegamerx31d ago

I can see what you mean. What I am getting at is just because they did a tech demo with Aloy using AI to voice doesn't meam that this particular tech will ever actually be used. Although I personally think it will, if we can get voices to sound more natural and real. Unless it's stopped by voice actors.

darthv7231d ago

that is the current situation. voice actors are 'voicing' their concern over the use of AI. im sure you have heard those TV commercials where you can tell its an AI voice. But as things improve... there will be a point where nobody will be able to tell the difference.

Mr_cheese32d ago

Thegamer are quickly highlighting themselves as a website full of over the top BS

gold_drake32d ago

there is this website from a bunch of devs who developed a more enhanced AI conversational voice thing, where u can talk to them.

i did for 10 minutes and it freaked me out how real it sounded. it did glitch a few times but damn. the, in real time, chatter and response was amazing and frightening at the same time ha

Kyizen31d ago

One of the original Toy Story developers summed it up nicely. Basically when they were doing Toy Story people were shocked you are going from hand drawn art to computers but now no one blinks an eye and most if not all anime is 'drawn' on computers. But he also stated this didn't replace artist but just gave them a new tool to use. Now with AI the author is saying it will replace writing but it won't, using it to have dynamic conversations with NPCs or chatter as the character explores the world will avoid that repetitive banter. You will still need writers to craft a good story and make a compelling character(s).

31d ago
110°

Horizon Forbidden West Struck the Perfect Balance of Tribes for Horizon 3

Horizon Forbidden West may have struck the right balance after adding several new tribes to the series, something which Horizon 3 should try to keep.

Read Full Story >>
gamerant.com
Cacabunga52d ago

No horizon 3 i beg you Sony .. enough of this series already

pwnmaster300052d ago

It literally only had 2 main games and 2 dlc.
Sure it had some spin off but others have more
Halo
Gears
Elder scroll
Uncharted
God of war
Gta
Etc.
Game isnt done yet and just because your tired of it doesn’t mean everyone is.

ravens5252d ago

Exactly. (*All following #s are slightly exaggerated*) There's like 36 CODs. 16 Assassin's Creed. 25 Final Fantasies. 80 Maddens. I hate when we're on the 3rd iteration of a game and people say this.

isarai51d ago

We've had 2 main games, 2dlcs, a vr spinoff, a lego spinoff and soon to be GAAS spinoff

lukasmain52d ago

Why not? It's popular. They're great critically acclaimed games. It need a 3rd game.

northpaws52d ago

@Cacabunga

Only speak for yourself, I want to know how the story ends.

raWfodog51d ago

Same here. I'm enjoying the story. I want to see what happens when Nemesis arrives.

JEECE52d ago

It all depends on if it's actually a massive step forward or if it just feels like an iterative sequel. There's a lot of revisionist history now about how "mid" Horizon has always been, but people weren't saying that when Zero Dawn came out-people were pretty much universally into it. The major hit against it at the time was that it came out too close to Breath of the Wild.

The problem with Forbidden West is that it took five years and it was just an iterative sequel. Iterative sequels can be fine, or even great, but when five years pass and a new generation of consoles comes out, people expect a big jump, and they didn't get it. Stuff that worked in 2017 felt tired by 2022.

3 can't just be Forbidden West with slightly better graphics. It needs to actually be a meaningful leap.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 51d ago
ravens5252d ago

Im looking forward to the 3rd game. I'd like that to be the last one though. New IP after would be ideal.

jznrpg52d ago

Took me a little while to get into Forbidden West because I was playing on hard but it was really damn good once I got into a groove.

I want to see the ending of this trilogy so hopefully it’s not too far out. Hopefully whoever plays Sylens can do the character justice.

isarai51d ago

I dunno, i LOOOOVED Zero Dawn, but i wanted Forbidden West to be over by like the halfway point. It's an absolutely gorgeous game but damn was it buggy for a while after release, and the enemies and combat felt so janky and unbalanced compared to the first.