80°

Gaming Critics & Critiques: Consistent Voices

Robert Webb writes: "There are a number of mistakes I see critics making all the time. Nuance and consistency are all too often hard to find."

Read Full Story >>
fictiontalk.com
ApocalypseShadow837d ago

Truthfully, I'd remove the number rating too. And, there's no standard across the industry with a number. Or ridiculous decimal numbers like 7.5. The writing should be enough to get across to the consumer that the game is excellent; average that could have used a little more time and effort; and just down right poorly made game. It does help when you know the writer had a past history that plays similar games as you and has a similar perspective. A reviewer that grew up playing arcade games, home games like Contra, Mega man, Castlevania, Metroid, Ninja Gaiden, Mario, Tetris, Sonic, Streets of Rage, etc as I did, will most likely have a similar opinion on fun, replay ability and quality companies. So, search for your own trustworthy reviewer.

The problems of most reviewer's take on games today aren't just the numbers ratings. Reviewer's show clear bias, lack of game skills or haven't even completed the games they review. Or even like the genre of game they are tasked to review. Or, give a lower grade because the game is not first in the genre like Edge does. They are influencers looking to get paid or get swag and deter from giving a bad rating that might cut off their benefits. They don't report broken games or questionable micro transactions early. But, are also hampered by some developers tying their hands sometimes to prevent bad launch reviews. So, there's that.

A true reviewer will just tell it like it is. No matter the company or the developer or the cost. Story and graphics are subjective to personal taste. "Is the game FUN to play?" Are you enjoying yourself. "Does it control well?" There shouldn't be any difficulty between you and the controller. "Does the game have replay value?" Which is really tied to fun factor. Not amount of content in the game. If it's fun, you'll play it again and again. You could have a game with hundreds of items and characters and it's still not fun. "Is the cost reasonable for what you get?" You shouldn't pay a high price for a game you can beat in an hour.

And even with reviewer's take on a game to get an idea, in the end, trust your gut. YOU know what YOU like. Watch a video. Play a free demo if you can. But trust YOU. The worst that could happen is that you trade it in or sell it. (Oops. I'm sorry. I still like discs.)

LordoftheCritics836d ago

The number exists for the reviewer to commit to what they are saying.

Too many reviews dance around the good and the bad so the number system helps lock that down. Also the number acts as a quick headline. I dont think anyone has the time to read all the opinions on the internet.
Many advantages and disadvantages to numbering, but for the moment necessary.

Since game demos started disappearing, we relied on reviews and shockingly preorder bonuses.
Demo can hurt sales, so can reviews.

I think devs need to make better games first. The quality of shoddy releases is on par with the quality of the reviews.

victorMaje836d ago

Exactly this.
Imo the most important aspect of any reviewer is their past played & reviewed games. I cannot begin to stress how important that is. That’s how you build or (lose) the trust of the reader.

As for the last paragraph, although it is YOU who would know, it became harder the day demos stopped happening, that’s when that trust in a reviewer became even more important.

ApocalypseShadow834d ago (Edited 834d ago )

Agreed on the demos. That's where watching a video comes in if there isn't one. I love games like Hotline Miami and Max Payne. So, by watching a video of Hong Kong massacre, I KNEW that I would like it. Turned out, I love it.

I love samurai movies and Akira Kurosawa films. So, I knew I'd like Ghost of Tsushima. Loved it. By watching this video from Devolver,
https://youtu.be/qKuX0DdVYx...

I know I'll like it even without a demo if it controls well. A review will just tell me if it does controls well. But the game is already 90% bought in my mind. Same with Sifu.

FGHFGHFGH836d ago

"They are influencers looking to get paid or get swag and deter from giving a bad rating that might cut off their benefits."

Have you seen the influencer/reviewer packages they get? There's no way are going to give an unbiased review.
https://www.youtube.com/wat...

ApocalypseShadow834d ago

I know. It's BS. These people are bought off. Or beg developers for keys stating how they can benefit a company's game. But a great, finished game is what will benefit the developer. These journalists should buy them like we do. We would get a better review because now it personally hits their wallets.

carll836d ago

Exactly what happens personally i don't rate any if it so adventures than only i decide.

carll836d ago

Suppose a stranger recommends me a game. That’s nice and is perhaps in some way an indication of quality, but its usefulness is limited severely. Now imagine an old friend, who’s gaming habits I am familiar with, recommends something instead. This is what i wanted to say thanks for posting.

anast836d ago

Unlike being a professional art or literary critic, most game reviewers don't work within any schools of thought. They just spit stuff out and protect themselves while spitting stuff out. Also most game reviewers have almost zero technical knowledge. All of this should be concerning, seeing that games are a mix of art, literature and technical structures. In other words, most game reviewers are not even close to the task of being anything other than another tentacle of the marketing kraken.

ApocalypseShadow834d ago

Agreed. Journalists turned influencers.

90°

Comedy Central New Animated Series Based on Golden Axe

Get the scoop on Comedy Central's exciting new cartoon show inspired by the iconic Golden Axe video game

Read Full Story >>
retronews.com
Knightofelemia1d 5h ago (Edited 1d 5h ago )

Golden Axe is a great game I enjoyed it on the SMS, Genesis and in the arcade. Great game but it truly was a quarter eater back in the day. I wish Sega could get the rights to the arcade port of Moonwalker another great arcade game I enjoyed. Collect so many monkeys and become Robo Michael lol.

70°

The Best PS2 Games of All Time [2024 Edition]

GB: "With this feature, we will be taking a look at 15 of the best games from the PlayStation 2's vast library."

Read Full Story >>
gamingbolt.com
70°

Exclusive Monster Hunter 20th Anniversary Event with Themed Stays

Toyohashi, Japan is set to host a large-scale Monster Hunter event to celebrate the franchise's 20th anniversary, complete with themed hotel accommodations.

Read Full Story >>
retronews.com