GI: "The finale of Batman: Enemy Within is a joy any way you cut it. I was on the edge of my seat during both paths, wondering what would happen next, feeling both dread and excitement all the way until the credits rolled. The episode drops some hints that Telltale isn’t done with Batman yet, but if the series continues, topping the beauty and brilliance of this finale will be difficult."
James writes - "The time has come for the fifth and final episode of Batman: The Enemy Within, “Same Stitch”, to try and cap off a great series full of exciting action and damn good storytelling. Being the last episode in a Telltale Games series, one expects this to be the where all your decisions have an impact on proceedings. But this is no ordinary climatic episode, for there are two very different paths to be taken; depending on the choices you’ve made. It’s billed as the most ambitious Telltale finale to date, so can it be the most glorious one too?"
Batman: The Enemy Within wraps up with Same Stitch, the fifth and final episode. Is this enough to keep the series fantastic, or was Telltale the true enemy within?
MonsterVine: "Same Stitch is an impeccable ending to Season Two of TellTale’s Batman: The Enemy Within."