Gaming Boulevard reviewed the first episode of Telltale' Batman and concluded:
Telltale started off great but there’s still some questions that need to be answered. This sense of “left in the dark” is common with these Telltale storylines which are common but just like any good TV-series, it’s hard to wait for the next episode. I really look forward to the next episode and I hope they will follow the comics but with a personal twist. These dialogues and decision-making sequences really make me feel like Bruce Wayne and of course being the Bat.