Greg Ford writes:
"Played one way, Mario Super Sluggers pulls off a pretty solid imitation of Wii Sports Baseball. Using solely the Wii Remote, you can pantomime simple pitching and swinging motions to achieve those most basic of baseball actions. But to play that too-accessible way (with no control over defense or baserunning) belies an even deeper and more entertaining game. Attach a Nunchuk and Super Sluggers becomes a rollicking match of arcade-style baseball with a nice layer of depth."