Do you agree with these Best Horror Game of All Time Results?

A survey of over 1000 gamers reveals a surprising result for the Best Horror Game of All Time - question is, do you agree with the choices?

[DarkOcelet]

The Walking Dead over Silent Hill? Just NO!

Its a great game but Silent Hill is the better horror game and also has better atmosphere and soundtrack.

Also those who voted those games must have never player a Siren/Clocktower/Alone in the dark games or even Eternal Darkness Sanity Requiem.

Those games were so much better than what is listed here.

[Ezz2013]

Can't agree with that at all too
In fact i have no idea what TWD is even doing here
It's not horror at all...atleast for me.

I think that title go to RE1 or Silent Hill 1 or Dino Crisis or Evil Dead Ps1 or P.T or Siren (That creepy SOB game almost give me a heart attack)

or a game no one seem to know about
Alone in the Dark (Ps1) like you said
That game was the most creepy and heart bounding game i played in Ps1 era

As much as TLOU is my favorite game of all time ..it's also not Horror game
so i don't know what it's doing on that list too
It's survival action stealth game with some horror elements.

[DarkOcelet]

Exactly!

This list is just bonkers. Its most likely for people who played modern games from the PS3/X360 till now.

Also putting Fatal Frame so low on the list is a disgrace. That game at its time was the scariest horror game to ever come out.

[Hold_It]

@Ezz Agreed. TWD and TLOU aren't horror games, as TLOU is more action/thriller/drama than anything, and Clock Tower would be more qualified as a horror game than TWD. I also think Condemned Criminal Origins should be a lot higher on the list.

Missing Dino Crisis 1
Missing Alone In The Dark
Missing FEAR 1
Missing Clock Tower
Missing Penumbra: Black Plague
Missing System Shock 2
Missing Parasite Eve
Missing Call of Cthulhu : Dark Corners Of The Earth

[Army_of_Darkness]

The walking dead???!!!! a horror?? LOL!
Before dawn??!?!? Seriously??! Can't even get the name of the game right. this list is a total failure.

[TomRL]

The first Silent Hill game seriously does not deserve to be that high. It arguably shouldn't be on the list. And Silent Hill 2 should be in the top five. The voters obviously didn't play the games.

[jb227]

Totally agreed. TWD was a great game but I wouldn't really consider it horror. Honestly for my tastes I'd switch TWD & Dead Space...I actually enjoyed that series more than Silent Hill mainly because I've had more experience w/ it.

[Unlimax]

Wai- Walking Dead .. Horror game , of all time !?
This list doesn't make any sense to me :\

[Donnywho]

Resident Evil Within was a solid horror entry. I hope more people give it a try.

[Hold_It]

The Evil Within was good imo pretty much everything Resident Evil 4 should have been. That moment when Sebastian is like "What thaaa fuuuuuck", and he sounds confused, shocked, and accepting all at the same time.

[JamesBroski]

Yea, unlike The Walking Dead Island Riptide

[Picnic]

Silent Hill 3 in the dark.

[SouljAx360]

No, in fact that list is awful. The Walking Dead being anywhere on that list is proof that the list has no credibility.

If you're going to consider Last Of Us a horror game which is a bit of a stretch, then you have to consider Dark Souls a horror game which is less of a stretch. Bloodborne too for that matter, and they would be pretty high on that list.

[Tzuno]

Before Dawn 27 votes lol it's called Until Dawn, such a amateur writing.

[SH1ELD]

Silent Hill 2 and the original RE are the best known examples. TLOU is more defensive to Ellie. As a quality gameplay and story-wise it delivers but I don't get running from crimes as a survival rather than just another example of hatred style except for the sake of single human being.