Cuphead Preview–Not Our Cup of Tea (The Koalition)

Garrett Glass of The Koalition writes:
The common argument is gameplay is more important than graphics, and while that may be true to an extent, the same proponents of the argument can’t deny this: the perfect art style is enough to sell a game to players and then draw them into the world. For instance, because its competition on Microsoft’s stage was mostly a creepy sludge of conformity consisting of shooters, Cuphead, with its 30s cartoon style, captivated members of the audience in a way that few indie games are capable of. And while the design of Cuphead doesn’t sacrifice its mechanics in favor of the animation, the overall design of the game leaves little to be desired.

[rbailey]

Definitely love the art style and animation in this game. Hopefully it turns out to be a quality experience.

[sagesurge]

This is making me very sad, the game looks amazing.

[fermcr]

Games looks great.

[mhunterjr]

The game looks awesome. It's pretty much BS to imply that the visuals are the only reason people are sold on this game. It looks like a TON of fun.

[LoveSpuds]

I am not sure, really, how much have we seen?

Personally this is one of the games that has me buying a XB1 in a few weeks, I am really excited for it but I must be honest, its the artstyle that caught my attention and sold me on the game.

I rarely put any store in other peoples opinions, especially when they are based on a demo created for E3 which I doubt is fully representative of the game, I am sure there will be plenty to lovd about Cuphead.

[Why o why]

We cant know if it plays well. Most people I've noticed, myself included, were sucked in by the art style and concept. The gameplay seems to look fun so my hopes are still high. Even if I dont get to play cuphead, I wish it well.

[mhunterjr]

I'm not denying that the artstyle is attractive. But if the game didn't look fun, people wouldn't spend their money on it.

There are tons of beautiful, but shallow games, and they usually don't fair well. From what I've seen and heard about this game, the controls are exceptionally responsive, the levels are creative, and it's addictively difficult.

In short, the visuals might lure people in, but it's quality gameplay that seals the deal.

[nyobzoo]

Amazing art but Yea, I can't get into boss rush only games. Same reason why I couldn't into Titan Souls

[LifeInNZ]

The game looks fantastic...but I need to see more gameplay.

[LoveSpuds]

Its ironic that a game with this dazzling artstyle might turn out to be crushingly difficult.

Still high on my list of favourite games at E3, I love 2D games and love a tough game too....I want it now!

[lemoncake]

Person writing this obviously hates microsoft for some reason and doesn't hide it, after that everything he says looses credibility. Very poor journalism.

[wegetsignalx]

He made legitimate criticisms, you made personal attacks.

[PlayableGamez]

Best indie game at E3.

[LoveSpuds]

It sure is in the mix, I think No Mans Sky, Enter the Gungeon and Eitr also look particularly great.

I will be hoping Cuphead sells like hotcakes though, love to see indies do well, these guys seem super talented.

[2cents]

it's... different.

It's a game that the designers wanted to make. It's their vision and I love it.
A breath of fresh creativity and passion is a very welcome thing indeed.

If it's not ones cup of tea then have a coke and a smile and shut the 'F' up.

[Klonoa-dreamtraveler]

The art style and concept is excellent.