Alex White of The Independent writes "I love violent video games. I’ve played all of the GTAs, most of the Modern Warfares, and more than a few hack n’ slash RPGs. I’ve never been bothered by blood and guts. But when it comes to the boundaries of good taste and quality, there's a line.
Originally, I thought it was a joke. That the release of Hatred by Destructive Creations was a joke. If only."
"So, as you might expect, when Steam decided to pull the game, I thought, “Good for them. They shouldn’t have to sell this crap.” The backlash was instantaneous. “They’re demolishing our freedom of speech!” said the fans; “It’s a conspiracy!” They demanded that Steam return the game to Greenlight post haste."
A game about killing people.
This game was just gratuitous violence. I don't know why it was rated AO. It's no worse than a GTA killing spree, Hotline Miami, or even the 'No Russian' COD mission. Reminded my of a weaker Dead Nation except no zombies.
I'm surprised Switch is getting this and PlayStation/Xbox isn't. The game was basically Postal with better graphics and more realism.
A look at five games that gamers loved but most critics hated.
Advent Rising is another good example. It got panned by critics but it has a good story and I enjoyed playing it. The graphics are dated, the enemies all look the same, but it was made in 2005 so what do you expect? I wish they made the sequel so I could finish the story but I think the critics killed it off.
Joanna Mueller writes: "Since the 1980's, video game advocates have been arguing for the protection of games as a medium of free speech. Frankly, I consider myself in that camp, but just because a game can push against the boundaries of common decency doesn't mean it should. Especially if the developer is just hoping to ride the wave of pearl clutching controversy to the bank."
Nothing wrong with pushing for controversy, but the game still has to be worthwhile. Lots of games in the 90s showed that.
Because the novelty will eventually wear off and the audience will eventually wise up.
So what? If there's a market for something then why should anyone care if it gets filled, as long as it's not something illegal? You can dislike so-called "edge lord" games all you want (in fact, you can like or dislike whatever you want, full stop) but even if games like Hatred are just trying to take advantage of anti-SJW backlash to make a quick buck, the fact that they exist at all is important in a culture that's becoming increasingly puritan and censorship orientated. Art is supposed to push the envelope. It's supposed to make you think. And even if all a game makes you do is think about why certain people are so desperate to ban it.
There is no point to this game, but just murder innocent NPCs for no reason. Is there a story? Is there a reason besides anger for doing this? Is there a silver lining or moral at any point of the game? This game just seems like the perfect game to convince lobbyist to attack the gaming community and I just see no good coming from it.
"Despite all the hype now surrounding the game, there are no major gameplay innovations here. What's more, the graphics look awful — "
And this is my biggest problem with the game. The fact that it's nothing new, exciting, or even interesting, just steam rolling hard off of controversy alone.
People are abusing the "freedom of speech" angle more than actually looking at how poor this game really is. As I said before the developers are laughing in the back room, popping champagne bottles while their spokesperson rallies the "fans" to cry about freedoms being taken away.
In my opinion a game like this will only hurt how the gaming industry is viewed and this game is doing nothing for the community, and to say this is art? Just stop.
I am not going to play this game. It looks like it will be boring really fast. They sure got a lot of attention and free advertising. It's all about shocking people to get attention to their mediocre game.
ill play for curiosity it doesnt look very promissing but the dark toned violence is interesting but i dont see much else from that.
noir themed games were always very interesting to me.