440°

Think the PS4 reviews are bullshit? Not so fast

Ben Kuchera Writes: "So how controlled was the environment at the Sony meeting over the weekend? I’ve seen a good amount of snarky tweets and misunderstandings about how the whole thing went down, how much time we’ve had with the system, and the viability of the reviews that are hitting today. So I wanted to clear things up a bit."

Read Full Story >>
penny-arcade.com
Malice-Flare3814d ago

Ben's hardly trustworthy, after downplaying concerns about MS' DRM same as the rest of them...

Shikoro3814d ago

The thing is, everyone should trust their own eyes and how they feel towards the games. If they think that it looks fun, the natural process would be to buy the game if you can afford it. How people can take other opinions and use them to change their own is beyond me, but I learned to stop bothering with that a long time ago.

GarrusVakarian3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

Perfect comment right there, so much judgement and trolling going on today based off a few completely subjective review scores, like a consoles success is determined at launch from its launch games, anyone old enough to remember more than one console gen knows how stupid it is judge a console from its launch games.....history proves that with the PS3.,....but people just choose to forget and only focus on the negatives of the here and now.

Bubble up for well said.

Eonjay3814d ago

Guys stops freaking out. Go to http://www.metacritic.com/ to get a compulation of all reviews.

Notice that Shadow Fall has more positive reviews that negative ones and will probably overtake COD score by the end of the day.

Notice that the sites giving poor reviews are the same ones giving poor reviews to Resogun.

Last_Boss3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

This is why EVERYONE, as a fan of games should be humble towards each other. You wouldn't have such sinking or angry feelings if we banded together, to root out the true instigators. It's not about telling people they're blind, or their choice was wrong, it's about helping them find a general good decision on said purchase. It has already been proven enough times, that hands are deep in certain pockets. But by giving an ear in the first place, means you've already heard their voice, which leads them having some type of power to begin with. As gamers you should not have to go into any thread to defend your belief, it shows you lack faith in some way or fashion.

Skip reviews
Look for interesting games
Buy the console/s, that fit you
Big up your fellow gamers for what we've got

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3814d ago
ATiElite3814d ago

I think the ENTIRE Industry review system is B.S.

Most of these SCUMBAG so called Game Reviewers are in someone's Pocket.

Perfect example: COD:G getting 90's and 9's meanwhile everyone says it SUCKS. Even the Casuals who BLINDLY flock to COD every year are saying COD:G sucks.

Reviewers even have a long list of complaints in their reviews but at the end still give COD:G 9's and 90's because they are OBVIOUSLY in Activisions Pocket.

Metacritic Scores and review Scores HOLD NO weight for how well a game is made because these scores can be BOUGHT plain and simple.

Metacritic is a JOKE too because that score can be altered as well.

Example: Valve at the last minute canceled the DotA2 Halloween event making many gamers upset so a group of angry dota2 gamers decided to flood Metacritic with ZERO Dota2 scores thus greatly lowering Dota2 score.

You wanna know how well a game is, go to YouTube and watch Gameplay or get a Demo. review scores are GARBAGE!

GarrusVakarian3814d ago

Oh man, so much win in your comment.

Dat last sentence.

Bubble up for well said.

mafiahajeri3814d ago

Lol I stopped listening to reviews after the IGN PES 2008 reviews years ago they gave the game a 9. PES 2008 is notorious for being the worst PES of all time. Why you ask did ign give the game a good review!?? There were IGN ads in game In the menus and the ads on the field in the game. Unplayable online crappy animations rubbish graphics etc. and it gets a 9!

Lol, the sad thing is the sheep follow these reviews and believe them and most ye times are swayed heavily by them. The sheep goes "baaaaaa" I guess...

fenome3814d ago

Metacritic: The Last of Us

People are purposely giving it low scores to drop the overall number. Keep in mind these are user reviews, but that doesn't mean that actual paid reviewers don't do the same thing. Dirty deeds and they're done dirt cheap!

http://www.metacritic.com/g...

Last_Boss3814d ago

Also congratulate all the owners of the X1, cause in the end they were gonna purchase one anyway.

looking at how the game media is blasting off at the mouth about the PS4, it's no wonder they're going in this harsh.

The zealots went overboard, guys & gals.

DeadMansHand3814d ago

Such salty language for a news headline. Back where I'm from, men don't need to use them profane words to get their point across. A man should speak like a gentleman and if that doesnt work you always have your revolver.

I do declare that I am voting this story quality WTF and No on the liking of such a site.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3814d ago
mandf3814d ago

2 days for a complete review. Yeah right. I like how they review KZ when they haven't had time to play the mp. Scores are off the sp. BF4 and COD get passes on sp because of the mp. Journalism has no set standard.

SpiralTear3814d ago

Yeah, I think it would be better to review a multiplayer game when the entire community is able to access it. I don't expect any post-launch online game to have a network as smooth and user-friendly as a pre-launch game.

KodevEx3814d ago

Most journalism is corrupt with buyouts. That's why I love the AngryJoeShow. True and loyal to the gamers, not the companies.

DragonKnight3814d ago

Did you watch his Battlefield 4 Angry Rant where he tears into EA for how buggy BF4 is?

We need more people like that, and that's something Youtube is great for because PR has far less control there.

KodevEx3814d ago

Yea I saw it. Hilarious! That's why I love that guy. He's straight out honest.

DragonKnight3814d ago

What I loved about that video is that it was classic Angry Joe. Lately he's been Mellow Joe, but this brought out the anger again and it was just a great episode. I wish I knew what he knows about EA or BF4 that he hinted about but couldn't discuss in the video.

spektical3814d ago

and even then the MP reviews are just complete bullshit.

of course you will lose a match if the opposing team takes a choke point spawn. of course you will most likely lose if they have more lives. of course you will lose if everyone on your team is a recon class.

these things are obvious and part of any MP experience.

-Foxtrot3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

Most of the criticism you get with Killzone or even Battlefield 4 is ignored in games like Halo and especially COD.

IGN's logic...for example

BF4 - 8

Killzone SF - 8

COD Ghosts - 8.8

I mean REALLY? Come on. How does a broken, same old, bland game with horrible graphics get a better score.

I know it's different reviewers and all but if it dosen't make sense with other reviews then it's going to make the site seem bad.

Colin said in his Killzone Shadowfall review that this entry was the best one in the core series HOWEVER Killzone 2 got 9.5 and Killzone 3 got 8.5. Saying stuff like that doesn't make sense overall.

SpiralTear3814d ago

I miss when Nintendo Power and older websites had multiple reviewers give a score and their opinion supporting it. You got a lot of diverse opinions, so the criticisms had more merit.

Now the entire site is represented by a single score, which kind of invalidates the views of other staff members who might not agree with it.

Memories...

-Foxtrot3814d ago

@PostMesmeric

I liked that aswell but it means reviewers have to spend more of their time on playing more video games...you know even though they are being paid for it since it's their job.

The thing is though with more people you wouldn't have to write a massive review you could spilt the review up into paragraphs for each person stating what they like, don't like and if there's any problems with it. If two reviewers contradict each other then they would need to show it and come to a conclusion together or state their argument to see which one is right and which one is being a nit picker.

SpiralTear3814d ago

Yeah, you're right about the "more time" argument. It would definitely take more time and money to accomplish, which isn't easy to do in this age of online immediacy.

I still think it's the more honest and credible review style, even if it's extremely rare to see nowadays. Nintendo Power even had that section in the back that showed each staff member's favorite and least favorite genres. You could get to know the reviewer better, so you could get a better view on their gaming ideology.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 3814d ago
Idba3814d ago

I do belive the PS4 reviews are bullshit. The reviwers have had 2 days to playu with PS4 and the firmware update was released less than 12 hours ago

P0werVR3814d ago

Of course, that's part of the game. "Gamers" already know what console they're getting, this is just to pump before release.

pacostacos3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

lol the sony fanboy community is imploding after so much trollin, with ps4 games getting mediocre reviews and cod being 720 on ps4 ...this is going to be a fun week around here

Minato-Namikaze3814d ago

Probably not, gonna be too busy playing games.

Bordel_19003814d ago

@pacostacos

I actually agree, I've pre-ordered the PS4 and have been looking forward to it. But in the end the launch games are average at best. Guess I'll game on my PC until the good games start appearing on the PS4.

schubacca3814d ago

They do not know what to do.

However, the next course of attack is "what until next week" with the hopes that the X1 games will review lower than the PS4.

Both the PS4 and X1 will do fine. It is silly to believe that these games represent what either machine can do.

tiremfej3814d ago

COD is 720p on PS4? Wait a second...why haven't I heard about "Resolutiongate PS4"? From the sounds of it "Consolegate PS4" should be more like it...lots of freaking 180's at least with MS we know what we're getting...

Even Cearny is saying remote-play isn't perfect or ideal for all games now...lol. Nice two days before launch to drop all of it when all X1's are sold out and you're pretty much stuck with PS4...bad reviews for games...I guess you'll be able to use it for something right? It doesn't do anything else...

TheLostCause3814d ago

cod SP is 1080p native on ps4, that article got updated due to confirmation by IW on Twitter.

Bordel_19003814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

So, MP i still 720p?

Edit: So, the disagrees means MP is 1080p also, or that fanboys are retarded?

InTheLab3814d ago

Do you really think Ryse and a gimped up Forza will light up metacritic?

And you know there will be lingering bias for the Drm nonsense....

So hold off on the gloating as the new console review bullshit boat will be stopping to pick up the X1 as well...

pacostacos3814d ago

i dont care either way im a fan of both consoles... i just dislike fanboys! i do expect forza and Ki to get great reviews especially Forza...forza has always been quality im not holding by breath for ryse or dr3

Death3814d ago

Yeah, but keep in mind the console is 50% less powerful so the scores can be 50% less and still be ok.

Snackel3814d ago

Of course Forza will score high it seems all the game reviewers are hypnotized by this game… Driving around a track gets pretty boring to me. I think Dead Rising will really rack in some good scores, it will be interesting to see how Killer Instinct and Ryse turn out!

Ezz20133814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

i wonder what you guys will be doing when xbox reviews are up for Ryse,DR3,KI,Forza
i'm sure it gonna be fun to watch
and see you guys do 180 on your comments if most of them don't do well

i'm buying ps4 not because launch titles and i said that million times already
but because the support
i will be getting with ps4 and the best version of multiplat games and exclusives

also COD on ps4 is 1080p native in both MP and SP
IW just confirm it....AGAIN
https://twitter.com/Infinit...

isa_scout3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

You talk about Sony fanboys trolling, but what the hell do you think you're doing right now???
It should be even funnier when RYSE and DR3 gets reviewed. Then we'll see whos laughing. The only way either one of those games gets higher than an 8 is if someones holding a gun to the reviewers head...
Polygon excluded of course, they'll be the lone site to score RYSE as a perfect 10.

+ Show (5) more repliesLast reply 3814d ago
lifeisgamesok3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

The games don't seem that good so far

Maybe this is the reason Sony didn't give journalist consoles and games like they've done before

xxLuckyStrike3814d ago

An so it seems the world has started to right itself

GarrusVakarian3814d ago (Edited 3814d ago )

Destructoid 9
Gamesreactor 8
Gamesradar 8

All independent reviewers, no bias or corruption (as there is on both sides).

But of course you only choose to focus on the negative scores.

Ketzicorn3814d ago

Yeah people are exposing the type of gamers they really are. Reviews are just opinions and people are acting like the system is a failure because launch games are getting mixed reviews. It just further exposes how stupid some of these trolls are.

Death3814d ago

Yes, only focus on the positive scores if you want to be unbiased.

The independent, independant reviewers that did not receive free stuff at the Sony event that only post positive points should be the only ones trusted. Everyone else is biased since they were given gifts before the reviews.

InTheLab3814d ago

I think the reverse is why they're getting slammed. People are salty over this review event so instead of giving a pass (which i'm happy they didn't) for little things or huge things in Knack's case, they grinded away all pissed about it and handed out scores for software and hardware that reflected their mood at the time...

Show all comments (96)
60°

Disney Dreamlight Valley teases part two of paid expansion

Disney Dreamlight Valley devs have officially teased the second part of the paid expansion titled The Spark of Imagination.

60°

Best Stardew Valley Farm Names – 100 Funny, Nerdy, Cute Ideas and More

Starting out a new farm, but need help choosing a name? Check out this article for a 100 farm name ides for Stardew Valley.

170°

Bethesda Needs to Reduce the Gaps Between New Fallout and Elder Scrolls Releases

Waiting a decade for new instalments in franchises as massive as Fallout and Elder Scrolls feels like a waste.

Read Full Story >>
gamingbolt.com
-Foxtrot10h ago

Microsoft have Obsidian but I feel it's Bethesda who just don't want to play ball as they've always said they want to do it themselves.

Once MS bought Zenimax in 2020 they should have put the Outer Worlds 2 on the back burner, allow Bethesda to finish off its own Space RPG with Starfield (despite totally different tone why have two in your first party portfolio with two developers who's gameplay is a tad similar) and got Obsidian for one of their projects to make a spiritual successor to New Vegas.

When the Elder Scrolls VI is finished Bethesda can then onto the main numbered Fallout 5 themselves.

The Outer Worlds 2 started development in 2019 so putting it on the back burner wouldn't have been the end of the world, they'd have always come back to it once Fallout was done and it would have been nicely spaced out from Starfields release once they had most likely stopped supporting it and all the expansions were released.

If they did this back in 2020 when they bought Zenimax and the game had a good, steady 4 - 5 years development, you might have seen it release in 2025.

We are literally going to be waiting until 2030 at the very earliest for Fallout 5 and all they seem bothered about is pushing Fallout 76.

RaidenBlack8h ago(Edited 8h ago)

Its not just only Todd not playing ball.
Obsidian have made a name for themselves in delivering stellar RPGs, but most famous once have always been sequels/spin-offs to borrowed IPs like KOTOR 2, Neverwinter Nights 2, Fallout: New Vegas, Stick of Truth etc.
Obsidian wants to invest more in their own original IPs like Outer Worlds or Pillars of Eternity with Avowed.
Similar to what Bluepoint & inXile wants to do or Kojima is doing (i.e not involving anymore in Konami's IPs).
So yea, even if New Vegas has the most votes from 3D Fallout fans, Obsidian just wants to do their own thing, like any aspiring dev studio and MS is likely currently respecting that.
But a future Fallout game from Obsidian will surely happen. Founder Feargus Urquhart has already stated an year ago that they're eager to make a new Fallout game with Bethesda, New Vegas 2 or otherwise. Urquhart was the director of the very first 1995's Fallout game after all.
And don't forget Brian Fargo and his studio inXile, as Brian Fargo was the director of Fallout's 1988 predecessor: Wasteland

KyRo4h ago(Edited 4h ago)

Obsidian should take over the FO IP. They're do far better with it than Bethesda who hasn't made a great game for almost 15 years

Duke194h ago(Edited 4h ago)

I disagree. Part of these games is the support for the mod community. If they move to releasing a "next game" every 2 or 3 years, the modding support plummets and the franchises turn into just another run of the mill RPG.

Make the games good enough to withstand the test of time, to keep people coming back to them and expanding on them with mod support.

--Onilink--2h ago(Edited 1h ago)

I dont think anyone is saying they need to come out every 2 years (not to mention almost no game is released that quickly anymore)

By the time Fallout 5 comes out, it will be more than 15 years since Fallout 4 came out (same with ES6 coming out 15 years after Skyrim). Even if you want to use F76 as the metric for the most recent release, that one came out in 2018. It will be a miracle if F5 comes out before 2030

The point is that for a studio that doesnt seem to operate with multiple teams doing several projects at once, that their projects normally take 4-5 years as a minimum, and that now they even added Starfield to the rotation, it becomes a 15+ years waiting period between releases for each series, which doesnt make sense. Imagine that Nintendo only released a mainline Mario or Zelda game every 15 years…

They either need to start developing more than 1 project at a time, let someone else take a crack at one of the IPs or significantly reduce their development times

Duke1930m ago(Edited 27m ago)

Why should someone else take a crack at one of the IPs? Look at what happened to Final Fantasy as a recent example - there is pretty clear FF fatigue setting in because they are now pumping out titles in the franchise every few years. Pumping out more games faster doesn't always make a series better.

There are plenty of options to make new games, not just create more titles in the same universe at a faster pace.

mandf1h ago

Yeah I’m going to say it, who cares about the modding community when making a game? Half the time developers only tolerate modders because they fix there game for them.

Skuletor3h ago

Yeah, let's all advocate for smaller gaps between series' releases, then we'll probably get headlines about how the series have dropped in quality and they could have benefited from more time in the oven. Let them cook.

SimpleSlave2h ago

"how the series have dropped in quality and they could have benefited from more time in the oven" So every Bethesda game then? Got it.

Listen, I would agree if this was about From Software or something, but Bethesda?

🤣

C'mon now. What timeline are you from?

Skuletor24m ago

Think about it, they're already bug filled messes on their current schedule, can you imagine how much worse it would be if they rushed things?

Duke1929m ago

I mean you aren't wrong. People are going to complain about anything

isarai2h ago

Hows about you focus on quality, just a thought 🤷‍♂️

Sciurus_vulgaris1h ago

Bethesda [or Microsoft] would have to reallocate internal and external studios towards fallout and elder scrolls titles. Bethesda has the issue of developing 2 big IPs that are large RPGs on rotation. If you want more Fallout and Elder Scrolls, development will have to be outsourced.

Show all comments (17)