In today's gaming industry, just about any successfully and financially successful game means a sequel isn't too far behind. While that decision makes sense from a business point of view, it also means developers are expected to replicate success, and in some cases, catch lightning in a bottle yet again.
That's easier said than done, as can be seen by any number of sequels released year-to-year. Whether due to rushed development, a shift in direction, publisher pressure, or just failure to connect with gamers a second time, many sequels come up short.
We've looked through the pixels of gaming history to focus on the sequels we most felt were disappointing, misguided, or just plain broken.
Dying Light: The Beast doesn’t just bring back the undead—it resurrects everything fans loved about the original, now with sharper claws and a deeper bite.
Supermassive’s Directive 8020 looks to elevate The Dark Pictures Anthology with tighter gameplay, deeper choices, and genuine sci-fi horror, out October 2, 2025.
TSA writes: Rematch reimagines what a football game can be, putting player skill and five-a-side football in the foreground. It's a little rough, but has potential.
Some legit picks. Silent Hill is lucky it didn't make the list. Even the HD Collection was fubar
Good 'safe' list. Should have included Final Fantasy XIII.
Oh god, RE6, horrible, very horrible game, each time i remember it, i wish i had thrown my 60$ in the air instead of buying that game.
fable 2 was crap
Very good list. Had me laughing a couple times given the jabs that are taken at some of these bad sequels.