It sounds like a copout but Lost really is only for fans. Despite the fairly clunky gameplay mechanics, the so-so acting and the new character, you're still wandering around an island that you've spent hours watching on TV, doing things that you've seen characters do, which makes up for many of these problems. Although far from ugly, more polished visuals would have helped no end, and the lack of the full voice cast can't be overstated. If you want to visit the Lost island (and earn a load of Achievement points very easily if you're playing on Xbox 360), and don't mind having your hand held throughout, give Lost a look. Just don't expect a new super TV show/video game hybrid genre.