140°

What Defines A Classic?

OnlySP.com writes:
'The current console generation is home to a number of initiatives that see earlier games lumped under the prestigious banner of Classics. The respective online stores of the Xbox 360 and Playstation 3 feature subsections for the games on their predecessors, while the HD Remaster efforts (at least on the PS3 in PAL regions) carry the title of Classics HD. Most consumers see it as convenient branding to better distinguish them from more modern products, but when you consider the nature of what has historically been termed ‘Classic’, one might begin to consider this mass cataloguing, irrespective of quality, as sacrilegious. With this feeling at the forefront, the question coalesced: “What defines a Classic?”'

OnlySP explores the question as it applies to video games and whether the classification should be granted as indiscriminately as it has been to date.

Thatguy-3104597d ago

Originality and the experience one has through the first play through.

bubblebeam4597d ago

Agreed. There are so many excellent games that have come out this gen. I can't imagine even half of them will earn the "classic" status (not the Xbox platinum/ classic badge).

I think it is mostly story oriented games. As graphics and gameplay show their age, but story doesn't.

I'm talking about Bioshock, Heavy Rain, The Darkness, Alan Wake etc. Those will definitely be remembered as classics. Although, I'm not sure how long after the games release it can be called a 'classic' lol. I'm a bit confused on that front.

Picnic4596d ago (Edited 4596d ago )

That 'sounds' good and loads of people will agree with you on it. But some arcade games don't tend to have great stories. One of my favourite recollections is playing Outrun 2 on the Xbox. And when you're talking about Sega, they make graphics that don't really age anyway.
Techs specs may improve but it doesn't make old Sega games seem hideous, it just makes some other developers seem hideous, whether they have a great story in them or not.

As for gameplay, that depends on how the original compared to different genres of the time in the first place.

For me it nearly always comes down to who made the game - and if they created it especially for one console, preferably their own, that probably gives them extra points as well.

For my personality a classic is always a bit quirky in some way- but probably not in a self consciously pretentious way unless it is done with a wink.

It is almost certainly to do with the personality/history of the people or studio making the game and, in some cases, the console that they are making it for. I'll give it to Bioshock, for at least the first game, Heavy Rain - OK. Alan Wake- Probably at least the hallmarks of something classic there, from the makers of another classic series Max Payne 1 and 2 (but 3 is not quite the same kind of classic to me). Little Big Planet, yes. Jet Set Radio Future on Xbox. Paper Mario- The Thousand Year Door. Luigi's Mansion was a classic to me - something different. Silent Hill 3. Metroid Prime... I can go on.

What most of them have in common is a belief in exploring quirky situations, chnaging you a bit and putting you through the mill. They're all Alice in Wonderland remade really.

bubblebeam4596d ago

@Picnic

I completely agree with you. I didn't want to write too much in my first post, but I think in general it is games with epic stories.

It isn't exclusive to that though. It could be that the game-play was wacky and imaginative, or just over the top fun. Portal for instance. Quirky, funny and original.

It's too hard to say which games are more deserving of this 'classic' status, as everyone will have different opinions.

I'd suggest Beyond Good and Evil myself. Love that game.

HarryMasonHerpderp4596d ago (Edited 4596d ago )

"what defines a classic?"
The Little Mermaid 2 if you go by the EU store on PSN.
-_-

majiebeast4597d ago (Edited 4597d ago )

90% of the fps coming out this generation will never be classic's in my opinion. For me Dishonored and Bioshock are classics of the fps genre because they dont rely on multiplayer.

I dont know what it is with this generation, but there is not much i would call a classic. Maybe its because i grew up on the Snes/ps1/ps2 or the severe lack of good quality Jrpg's especially from Square enix. Or the over saturation of fps games.

KrisButtar4597d ago

i agree. i started gaming on the nes,i can name a ton of classics from then till now but this gen does seem to be lacking. even though i own a ton of games most of them had their roots from the earlier gens

godofboobees4596d ago (Edited 4596d ago )

The market is flooded with fps' I can count with two fingers that are classics. This generation barely has anything that defines classic and honestly the ps3 has more classics this generation than any other console this gen

Canary4597d ago

The same thing that defines a classic for any artistic medium: the test of time.

That's all that matters. That's why can appreciate art that's thousands of years old. For games? I'd say anything 10 or more years older that people still play and love qualifies as a classic.

Picnic4596d ago (Edited 4596d ago )

The test of time, if it doesn't happen very quickly, has a habit of being of little or no use to the poor dead soul who waited all their life not to be regarded as irrelevant though. Vincent Van Gogh's torture and financial dire staits no doubt keeps on turning every few years in to somebody more comfortable's new yacht.

I hope that everybody who has made all the videogames that have given me so much pleasure can feel how relevant they remain to me and others, no matter what sales they got.

Y_51504597d ago

I can name games like Uncharted and inFamous being classics someday in the future.

tweet754597d ago

if the game stands the test of time well .....is it still as enjoyable to play 20 plus years in the future?

Show all comments (21)
130°

10 Legendary Games That Still Absolutely Crush It in 2025

Discover 10 timeless video games from the past that remain absolutely playable today. From Chrono Trigger to DOOM, these classics have aged like fine wine!

Read Full Story >>
gamegeeked.com
anast47d ago

Simon's Quest is better than Symphony.

djl348546d ago

If you're gonna troll, at least make a legitimate attempt.

Levii_9247d ago

Hot damn that's a good list. The only one i never played is AOE2 and i never finshed Chrono Trigger but it was damn good.

Speaking of what's old but holds up amazingly well and plays like a dream.. i played Symphony of the Night for the first time in 2019.. yep that's right. It became one of my favourite games of all time that i replay almost every year. I couldn't believe how good it was. That is almost impossible for me with newer games let alone older ones. Truly a special gem.

LG_Fox_Brazil46d ago

That's a pretty fucking great list

__y2jb46d ago (Edited 46d ago )

The only one I’d disagree with is doom. It shows its age badly I think. After 5 minutes of play these days you put it down.

Show all comments (8)
210°

Top 100 Video Games Of All Time

Many games have come and gone as gaming began its illustrious history in this world. So let's talk about the top 100 video games of all time!

Read Full Story >>
lordsofgaming.net
Babadook7112d ago (Edited 112d ago )

Yeah. That’s the first I’ve seen it anywhere near #1.

Mario 64 is great but I wouldn’t put it over Mario World.

CUnit123123112d ago

Appreciate you checking out the article

CUnit123123112d ago

Thanks for checking out the article

slate91112d ago

Top 10 were bangers till they threw the #1 spot away lol

CUnit123123112d ago (Edited 112d ago )

Thanks for checking out the article

Zeldafan64111d ago

Not having any Xenoblade Chronicles games on the list is a crime.

CUnit123123111d ago

Sorry lol. I wrote the article but 5 of us voted for many different games and majority went on the list then we worked on the list. If it were just my personal top favorite we'd seen some xenoblade and star ocean as well as some others. Thanks for checking out it!

RavenWolfx110d ago

Chrono Trigger at 31 makes my heart hurt.

Zeldafan64110d ago

Not having any Xenoblade Chronicles games on the list at all is a crime.

230°

Top 10 Soulslikes You're Not Playing

Soulslikes are punishingly difficult but amongst the most compelling games. Power Up Gaming goes through the top ten Soulslikes you're likely not playing.

Read Full Story >>
powerupgaming.co.uk
thorstein136d ago

Demon's Souls isn't Soulslike. It's the original Souls game. WTF? And Elden Ring?

Another Crab's Treasure simply is not.

All the journos claiming things are "Soulslike" simply don't know what that word means.

GeeEssEff135d ago

The term “Soulslike” has become ridiculously diluted. I have seen it used for games just because they are difficult.

Cacabunga135d ago

Reminds me of Doom like back in the days for every FPS game

blackblades135d ago (Edited 135d ago )

Yeah, souls, souls lite, souls like same goes for rogue.

anast134d ago

It's either AI or the writer doesn't know the subject matter.

robtion135d ago

I've played all of these bar the Crab one so not a very accurate title.

Goodguy01135d ago (Edited 135d ago )

Nioh 1+2 imo are the best souls clone. Love the melee combat and ki system, really hoping team ninja doesn't abandon the IP and continue with a new title, hell just give us your take on the western fantasy setting for a new nioh game.

robtion134d ago

Yes Nioh 2 in particular is great. Also Wo Long (which is basically Nioh 3).

qalpha134d ago

Should have included 'Lies of P'. Seriously fun game.

Nacho_Z134d ago

That's what I was going to say, great game. Best non From Soulslike I've played.

134d ago