Top
I'm feeling less stable.

coolbeans

Moderator
CRank: 22Score: 0

User Review : Velvet Assassin

Ups
  • Interesting WWII quasi-historical story
  • Great atmosphere
  • Nuanced stealth gameplay
Downs
  • Weak gunplay
  • Certain aspects of stealth are fundamentally flawed

A WWII Game That Doesn't Center Around Shooting.

It's safe to say that the World War II era has been one of the most overused stages for videogames, mostly revolving around FPS and RTS genres. With this in my mind, it is likely any new WWII game will be met with an inauspicious beginning. What makes the case for Velvet Assassin different is the fact of it being a stealth game. With the unexpected genre choice and the inclusion of promising gameplay nuances, one must ask whether or not breaking the mold on what's expected in a WWII game instantly makes this a good one.

The main character is Violette Summer (inspired by real-life WWII hero Violette Szabo), a British female spy that's dropped deep into German territory for means of sabotage, assassination, and more. After being mortally wounded, Violette lies on the brink of death while retelling fragments of her past life pertaining to important missions she was tasked with carrying out. The missions she was ordered to carry out range from destorying vital Nazi equipment to assassinating high-value targets. As Violette dives deeper into her nightmares, she also displays the many horrors that the Nazis imposed on innocent life.

The story is one of the brighter spots to this game. Violette's flashbacks ,coupled with her current situation being discussed in between some missions, help flesh out the story in an interesting way. It's quite entertaining to hear both the grisly statements of certain Nazi soldiers and Violette's introspection with the task at hand. The main fault to be found with the flashback mechanic is how blatantly unnecessary some of her thoughts are to the gamer. In the end, this morose WWII tale is guarunteed to deliver some powerful moments.

The presentation of the game can be praised more for the artistic implementations, rather than sheer fidelity. For the most part, the engine holds fairly well to today's age. Ranging from the solid character models to the enviroments, the graphics are quite good. The problems that really plauge the game are in different aspects: framerate hiccups quite often, daylight missions don't have dynamic shadows (ie sun stays put until you reach a certain part of the map), and fire effects are underwhelming. As stated, the graphics have their faults but can hold their own.

The sound department is also one of the highlights of the game. The score isn't exactly versatile, but it makes up for it in depressing the mood. Being greeted by a single violin in each mission intro feels like it sucks out all of the verve one may have acquired in their previous mission, making each level feel start on an unnerving note. Another great idea Velvet Assassin had was keeping all German soliders speaking German, rather than the usual English with a German accent.

When comparing to the likes of the Splinter Cell or Metal Gear Solid series, the controls can feel rather rudimentary. The layout is simple with the stand/crouch button, typical weapon layout, whistle, and interaction button (whether to turn off light or assassinate someone from behind). The differences from this game to other stealth games is your violet silhouette and morphine mode. The violet silhouette is the indicator to show whether or not you are hidden or in plain sight. Morphine mode sends you into a trippy haze, with Violette dressed in her nightgown, that stops time and basically hands over a free kill (ability to kill one soldier from any angle). To ensure most of the assassinations are purely stealthy, there's a curbed amount of one-use morphine shots on each level.

At it's core, the stealth mechanic operates on the "study the enemy's routes" formula. The training of watching your target until he is in the right place can come off as archaic to some; however, there's still satisfaction to be had by the plethora of different animations seen as Violette silences her enemies. The glaring fault in the stealth mechanic would -ironically- be in the stealth itself. IF Violette is seen by a guard, she is litterly an ubiquitous spy even after she's gone back in the darkness. Only staying in darkness is irrelevant until your violet silhouette stops blinking (indicator for being seen). There is also no multiple alarms punishment of any kind, although being caught unexpectedly usually guaruntees a death screen to begin with.

The weapons in Velvet Assassin revolves around the basic arsenal: knife, silenced or standard pistol, shotgun, machine gun, sniper rifle, and flare gun. Since stealth is the main mechanic, the gunplay in VA doesn't receive much notice...and it shows throughout the entire game. The gunplay has a plethora of problems: overall stiff mechanics, bad hit detection (save for landing a headshot), general uselessness, and so forth. Overall, the gunplay is literally atrocious. And to make matters worse, the final level demands more shooting than stealth.

In conclusion, Velvet Assassin is the definitive "mixed bag" game of this generation. No one can deny the charm of either the unexpected genre used in this WWII game or the display of Violette's brutal nature. VA delivers some new ideas and a wholly entertaining story while also showcasing some very disheartening gameplay. While there's still an enjoyable ride to be played in VA, it's a shame that it's a ride that could've been so much better.

coolbeans' *RotteN* rating

Score
6.0
Graphics
The game looks beautiful at certain points; although, somewhat less in other parts of the game. Framerate hiccups are guaranteed throughout your adventure.
7.0
Sound
The inclusion of Nazis only audible in German language was a great idea. Not exactly a varied soundtrack by any regards.
4.0
Gameplay
It's a shame to see a game with a seemingly exclusive personality have so many gameplay faults.
6.5
Fun Factor
I'm not afraid to admit that I really enjoyed this game. Feeling like a love letter to past stealth series, VA procured a sense of personality unseen in today's WWII FPS quagmire. For all of it's faults, one could possibly find this to be an enjoyable experience.
Overall
5.3
The story is too old to be commented.
coolbeans2706d ago (Edited 2706d ago )

Hope everyone enjoyed the review. Just to note, German developer Replay Studios should be respected for their stern view on Nazi Germany throughout the game. Maybe some people in Hollywood could learn a thing or two between the honest view versus the neo-patriotic view of certain wars.

Edit: To clarify the "neo-patriotic view" part, I distinctly remember "The Patriot" showing the British in a terribly untrue light during the Revolutionary War.

consolez_FTW2706d ago

Nice reviews man. I noticed you've been putting up some quality reviews lately, glad to know I can trust your review scores. Unlike other major review sites...

coolbeans2706d ago

Much abliged, sir. I think I have MAG pegged for my next review (disagreeable score for that incoming) and then I shall focus on games from PS3/360's "HD History".

Since I started grabbing PS3's and 360's earlier exclusives, I'll post my thoughts on how those games panned out for their time.

PS3: Resistance: FoM to Uncharted: Drake's Fortune, with a few games in between.

360: Kameo to Gears of War, with a few games in between.

coolbeans2704d ago

I'd also like to point out that getting a rotten rating does not instantly = a bad game. In certain cases, such as Velvet Assassin, I can find the game to be an enjoyable adventure, but it's a game that I can have faith in even the hardcore fans of the genre enjoying.

I DO recommend trying out Velvet Assassin, but I DON'T believe all hardcore stealth fans will have as much of a great time as I did; thus giving it the *RotteN* rating.