Fez (User)

  • Trainee
  • 5 bubbles
  • 5 in CRank
  • Score: 38100
"I say good day!"

Beating a dead horse...

Fez | 1139d ago
User blog

Last night I went to the cinema to see Snow White and the Huntsman, an alright film let down by Kristen Stewart trying to be enthusiastic and uplifting. During the film, a particular scene struck me and the bias against certain forms of entertainment became apparent.

In the scene, Snow White is locked in her tower when the Queen orders her brother to fetch her. As he enters, he sits next to a horizontal Snow White, strokes her leg and says something along the lines of "my sister won't let me near you" and the clear and unambiguous suggestion of rape is complete. As the film progresses we see two men and seven male dwarves striving to protect Snow White.

In case you havn't guessed, this is not unlike the E3 tomb raider controversy. Except when a google search for "snow white and the huntsman controversy" is performed, we see people are more concerned that the dwarves weren't played by real life little people. Whereas a search for "tomb raider controversy" brings up the same tired articles.

How is it possible that a variation of a children's fairytale, rated as a 12A in cinemas not receive the same criticism that a video game, which will probably be rated at least a 15, gets?

Personally I don't have a problem with either situation because they are both quite realistic and ultimately both characters go on to kick some ass but surely there has to be consistency between mediums. The uproar surrounding the developers comment about the "player wanting to protect Lara" was misplaced. Who wouldn't want to protect someone who has just been threatened with rape. Of course people may argue that this makes the character weak and is therefore a negative stereotype which is usually reserved only for women. I feel that in the context of the Tomb Raider reboot and origin story the situation will help to shape an awesome female protagonist. At the same time though, I would like to see some strong heroines who are strong just for the sake of it. Basically, it would be nice to see Joss Whedon make a video game :D

SeekDev  +   1138d ago
Honestly, I haven't been following the Tomb Raider controversy at all because I already know what I think. And that is, the TR trailer did nothing wrong and wasn't controversial in the smallest sense of the word. Compared to other forms of media, the Tomb Raider trailer was equivalent to Barney, imo.
Hufandpuf  +   1137d ago
They having killing in a child's fairytale too. Where's the controversy for that?

I think people get hung up on stupid things. If the scene in the game doesn't bother you, then don't try to tell others just to have it justified. The devs won't change a thing anyway nor do they care.
Kratoscar2008  +   1136d ago
I dont get the Fuss, Women get raped around the world and its showed in movies and books, how something that actually happens couldnt happened to Lara, those are villians not little teddie bears.

It makes me mad that there is a lot of people that want the games to be more hollywood esque media and when a game like this point towards that, it gets bashed.
StayStatic  +   1136d ago
Games seem to get targeted and treated more harshly sometimes , not particularly fair but when you have ass hats like that Jack Thompson causing a fuss , it's no surprise.

If Crystal Dynamics give into this social media bull crap and cut out what will essentially be one of the reasons to make you give a dam about the character and want to survive the entire game ... then I will not buy it.
smashcrashbash  +   1136d ago
The point is that it's so obvious. Beat Lara to a pulp and then she miraculously rises above the MEN that kidnapped her and hurt her. It's practically a mirror for a story on the Lifetime Network. It's lazy writing.Why aren't there any women abusing her too? They could have found other ways to show Lara gaining strength without any of this. Lara is beaten up by bad MEN and to defeat the bad MEN she has to become a strong WOMAN. There doesn't seem to be any subtly or depth to the theme. I could be wrong and maybe there is more to it but knowing how developers work these days, I am doubtful.
pandaboy  +   1136d ago
That never occurred to me when I watched a pirated version on my laptop :p by now that you mention it there does appear to be a double standard going on. Thought the film was good until the last half hour. I'll stick to twilight for my Kristen Stewart fix.
MacDonagh  +   1136d ago
It depends on the maturity of the audience. The outrage that came out over the Tomb Raider debacle was clearly a non-issue but it clearly highlighted the lack of maturity in gamers in handling criticism regardless of it's merit.
MeatAbstract  +   1135d ago
You're absolutely right...Joss Whedon SHOULD make a video game!
Greinv   1135d ago | Spam
HonestDragon  +   1134d ago
Rape is a very serious subject in general, but it shouldn't be completely avoided in one form of media over another. Movies and novels have long had scenes and even mentioning of rape. I think the only reason why people are up in arms over this is for the fact that Lara Croft is a long standing character that's never dealt with that kind of subject, how it shows women as always being vulnerable, and also for the age old "think about the children" BS.

Well, one, this is a new start for the Tomb Raider series and I really like the direction it's going in. Two, there are many strong female characters in entertainment and this game is showing Lara becoming stronger as a person through the trials she faces. Three, this is not a game for children so stop using them as scapegoats.

As it is, the scene that was shown didn't even lead to anything showing or hinting at rape. It was a small hand stroke. Nothing more. Grow up people.
Zulianie   1131d ago | Spam
linger66   1128d ago | Spam
xxuhal  +   1123d ago
outlander is my absolute favorite book, but yeah, I stopping after drums of autumn too. I haven't read the newest ones and I honestly have no desire to.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login