arsenal99 (User)

  • Trainee
  • 5 bubbles
  • 5 in CRank
  • Score: 880
""

How to solve a problem like piracy?

arsenal99 | 647d ago
User blog

An article I wrote in August 2010 looking at Video Game piracy. I hope to review this topic soon and thought it would be interesting to see my views back then.

Video game piracy is a beast that the industry just cannot tame. Many different techniques have been implemented to try and tackle this problem yet none seem to work. With pirated video games becoming more easily accessible by the day, it poses a massive hurdle for the industry and one that the industry is determined to crack. This article aims to examine the ways in which the video game industry tries to combat piracy and if those methods are effective.

Don't Punish Us!

The main thing that Video game publishers and developers must realise is that in their attempts to combat piracy they must punish the pirate without punishing the consumer. Many companies incorporated anti-piracy software onto the install disks. Consumers were getting the sense that they were being punished for what the pirates do. EA games tried to do this with the game 'Spore', they added DRM software onto the disk. It backfired and the game went on to be one of the most pirated games ever. It turned out that pirates could bypass this software protection while consumers were forced to live with it. Publishers therefore must reward the consumer for purchasing the game this can be done in many ways. They could offer money off the sequel of that game when it comes out, offer free downloadable content or offer free merchandise with every order. One of the main reasons for piracy is that people demand more for their money. More and more games are being released per year and the consumer only has a certain amount of money available to spend on video games. By offering a better value proposition the consumer is more likely to purchase the game rather than pirate the software. Punishing the pirates can be done through numerous ways but the traditional way of fining the odd pirate just does not work.

Video games must play to their strengths; just recently EA games unveiled 'Online pass' which allows the consumer to enter a code to access the online play, a code is given to anybody who buys a new copy of the game. The importance of this is that people who pirate games will not be able to use one of the most important features in today's games, online play. Of course people could still pirate these games and use the online feature by only paying $10 to acquire a code; this will allow publishers to get extra income from pirates who would not consider paying for any part of the game. As another bonus Ea games will receive extra income from the used games market.

Other publishers such as Activision must take note, Call of duty is famous for its online experience. If they can utilise this same method you will see people purchasing the game rather than pirating it so that they can play online.

Quality is key!

Another way to combat piracy is to simply make a good quality game with increased longevity. As stated earlier consumers will not see the value of paying full price for a game that might be great but only lasts 10-12 hours. By making a game of good quality and longevity the consumer is going to see better value and will be more likely to buy the game. If the individual were to evaluate a video game and realise it was not worth their money they are more likely to pirate the game instead of before when they would not buy it and consequently never play it, this is due to the convenience and easiness of pirating in modern times.

Platforms

Another point to consider for developers is which bit of hardware they should develop for. The Sony Playsation 3 is notoriously hard to crack and therefore pirated games can't be used on that system. On the other hand, the Xbox 360 and the Wii can be cracked by any individual who has access to the internet and a decent guide on how to crack the system. The PC needs no cracking at all and has become the pirate's choice when choosing to pirate a game. Developers should work with these hardware companies to make sure that they are hard to crack or they could look at just developing solely on the playstation 3 as long as this trade off is a viable one.

Use brand communities.
The final point that could help combat piracy is to become a publisher or developer that listens to the community. By having a community that respects the organisation the chances are they are more likely to buy the game and discourage piracy. Ways companies can do this is by regularly communicating with people on forums, listen to their key consumers and by offering incentives. These incentives can be access to Beta's or money off codes for being a member of the organisations forums or websites. More people will pirate a game if they feel the developer or publisher disregard the consumer's desires or neglect them altogether. The ability to keep connected with their key audience is a very powerful tool and should be considered by publishers who have a poor relationship with their consumers. The knock on effect could lead to greater sales and thus profit margins. If all else fails and piracy is still too high you could ask consumers what they want to pay for that game. 'World of goo' developer's 2D boy allowed consumers to name their price when purchasing 'World of goo. Although a lot of people chose to pay one penny for the game it was still a huge success. It could be said that would be pirates who had a chance to pay what they liked for the game would do so instead of pirating it.

In conclusion, there really is no sure fire way of stopping piracy. The old method of fining people randomly for downloading Illegal software is outdated and does not work. Publishers have to be creative and think outside the box, with people having less disposable income more and more will turn to piracy as a way of fulfilling their gaming desires. By using some of the methods stated in this article developers and publishers could start to see piracy for their game falling and their profits rising.

This was written in 2010 and a lot has changed What do you think publishers and developers should do to stop piracy?

ZombieNinjaPanda  +   647d ago
“The easiest way to stop piracy is not by putting antipiracy technology to work. It’s by giving those people a service that’s better than what they’re receiving from the pirates.” - Gabe Newell
OcelotRigz  +   647d ago
Exactly. Thats why i have so much respect for Newell and Valve, they think outside the box and look at problems differently from most other devs and publishers. They are also a perfect example of the authors last point "Use brand communities", they listen to and treat the community with respect that is severely lacking from other devs/publishers.

When i built my 1st PC before Christmas i had every intention to pirate games, there was so many games i wanted to play and building the PC left me broke. But then i installed Steam and browsed the store. Luckily for me it was the Fall Sale and i was so surprised by how cheap games were selling for. I suddenly felt really guilty and then completely changed my mind about pirating games and decided never to pirate again because when games are this cheap pirating is just taking the biscuit.
I have now discovered the likes of Greenmangaming and Direct2Play who have great deals while there isnt a Steam sale going on.

With that being said, another key reason for pirating is to try out games before buying them. The obvious solution to this is to release demos for every game possible but the lack of demos out there at the moment is ridiculous and something that has to change.

EDIT: I made a blog post on here a while back about what i mentioned above, how i changed my pirating ways, just in case anyone wanted to check it out.
#1.1 (Edited 647d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Tetsujin  +   647d ago
The people I've talked to about piracy don't pirate just to dodge paying for games, they download because what they play have no demo to test their hardware, as well as if it's a game they want to purchase. It was also argued videos can only go so far before people actually want to test the games for themselves, same with magazine advertisements. I've known people who mentioned borrowing/renting however again it goes back to what's available.

I'd look more into the why people pirate rather than just "oh it's wrong, you shouldn't do that" because the reasons can at least be a wake up call for some companies. My opinion about gaming piracy is if a company doesn't want their games illegally obtained, they will find ways to where people "don't" obtain them illegally; there's some companies (Activision) who need to be hit hard, while others (NaughtyDog) who could use the extra income and support.
SilentNegotiator  +   647d ago
More pirates to avast ye mateys. Copy ("It's not stealing, it's just making a copy!") their stupid furry DeviantArt pics that are on sale, take a lighter to their checks before they cash them, fart on their pillows....maybe they'll change their attitudes on the matter.
Kratoscar2008  +   646d ago
Good article, you bring a lot of good points however this is not a battle that will be won. By nature people like things free, i mean you can charge 1$ for a clean apple but if you can get an apple from the tree and even tough the apple could had worms the person will still opt for the free apple.

Here in Honduras Piracy is a way of living, the PS3 has been troughly pirated here in fact you can see people outside selling illegal copies of PS3 and 360 games and you can buy them shamelessly and i will admit im part of it.

You certainly hit the nail with the consumer company relationship, im member of the ATLUS USA forums and i buy their games because i respect the company and enjoy their quality games so maybe that could help HOWEVER most companies doesnt care about their customers animore, just see at SE and Capcom.

Good Blog.
parkerpeters  +   646d ago
While the earlier quote from Gabe Newell is insightful, you have to also take into account that Valve is a company that releases a high quality game every few years with an immense amount of polish, and just filled to the brim with innovation and creativity.

I buy good games. I don't think that Activision or EA deserve any of the money they get from consumers. I honestly wish that every EA-Activision consumer was a tech savvy pirate. If they were, EA and Acti would be out of business, and this industry could get back on it's feet

/unpopular opinion
Dasteru  +   646d ago
The best way to stop piracy is to stop trying to stop piracy.

The pirates will always win, and the legit buyers are the only ones that ever suffer from DRM.

Several companies have already learned this and they are better off for it.

1: Release games completely DRM free, or through Steam with nothing else.

2: Provide physical incentives for purchasers that cannot be obtained through piracy.

3: provide demos or trials for all games. Alot of people pirate to test games before buying. $60 is alot to pay for something that MAY be good and is non returnable once the seal has bean removed. If you have faith in the quality of your product then there is no reason not to release a demo for it.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember