@Father Murder
Well, depending on where the GOTY award is coming from, the former could be as insignificant (in terms of an accolade for quality) as the latter.
As for best selling, we all know that doesn't mean anything. Just look at all other forms of entertainment and you'll clearly see that best-selling practically never translates to better quality. In music you have people like Lady Gaga, Miley Cyrus, Britney Spears and Beyonce being annual Billboard chart-toppers. In movies you have things like Transformers, X-Men, Harry Potter, Fast and the Furious, Ironman, etc. leading the modern box office charts. Not to say that some of them can't be decent (I rather enjoyed Transformers and Ironman and the Wolverine movies, plus I like some of the artists that make it on the billboard charts sometimes) but rarely (if ever) are they the best there is to offer. Often times they're just mediocre. The real 'best of the best'/gems are the ones that sell only marginally but the real critics, you'll see, absolutely praise said artists or films.
That being said, a GOTY award can be just as insignificant depending on the source. If it's GameTrailers or something like Spike's VGAs then I wouldn't care at all. However if it's a Game of the Year award from somebody like the AIAS or Game Developers Choice Awards, then I'd happily take that over top selling any day of the week. And that's the real rating of quality in my book. As long as the sales are well enough to make a profit for the developers and to warrant a sequel, than that's all that matters as far as sales are concerned, it doesn't always have to be lets-use-a-bigger-budget-for-a dvertising-than-the-actual-game -cost halo sales.
View