280°
Submitted by john2 895d ago | screenshot

Comparison: Next-Generation (Unreal Engine 4) vs Current-Generation (CryEngine 3 / Creation)

DSOGaming writes: "We bet that a lot of you are wondering how current-generation engines compare to the upcoming, next-generation version of the Unreal Engine, right? Well, time to find out. In this special feature, we compare Crysis 2′s (CryEngine 3) and Skyrim’s engine (the Creation engine) with Epic’s Unreal Engine 4." (Creation Engine, Cryengine 3, Next-Gen, PC, PS3, Unreal Engine 4, Xbox 360)

Orpheus  +   895d ago
The polygonal detail on the mountain (UE4) , in the scene where the demon is standing , looks like shit ( Its been modified , the mountain part is missing here

http://cdn.arstechnica.net/...

) .... so much for making people gasp. Some areas are really good though ... but I expected something better.

BTW another engine I would like to see in action is the 4A engine ....... Russians Rock when it comes to Graphics.
#1 (Edited 895d ago ) | Agree(8) | Disagree(10) | Report | Reply
wallis  +   895d ago
What mountain where the demon is standing? All I see is fire and a demon.

And honestly is it really shit? You realize photorealism is an asymptote and as time goes on computer graphics will only have smaller and smaller gaps to close so really what you're saying is that a tiny piece of detail in an otherwise incredible display of graphics isn't up to scratch...as far as you say. Honestly I can't see a single piece of poor polygon count in any of these pictures but even if it is it's a slight flaw. It's not "shit" - especially considering that we've already come so damn close to photorealism that OTHER features of engines are now very important to consider.

From optimization to AI systems there's plenty the unreal engine 4 isn't letting on or hasn't told us and a quick screenshot is nothing but a tease of the full power. What really makes an engine is more than raw graphics and boy does the 4A engine prove this. The 4A engine? Really!? As in the engine that broke my computer for a corridor but achieved 54 fps in a city scene. The engine that will change performance when you leave and re-enter a room. The engine that has worse AI than solitaire. The engine that is less optimized than internet explorer without a firewall or anti-virus.

I freakin' love stalker and I love metro but even I recognize that the 4A engine (an engine which btw had to do nothing but render subways and a quick forty five minute jaunt through the surface) is a piece of crap compared to most others. It's nothing but an engine turned all the way up. Anyone can achieve good graphics if they make the engine run like trash. Also the piece of shit forced motion blur which is a great way to turn a good game into six hours of motion sickness for those of us sensitive to it. But of course they couldn't turn of motion blur because their engine featured terrible ghosting because that's what happens when you force an overpowered graphics engine to run on computers than actually... ya know... exist in the real world.
Orpheus  +   895d ago
Look at the link i provided . And when I mentioned the 4A engine , I referred to the updated one by which Metro LL is being built ... the original was good too ... in many ways.

http://cdn.arstechnica.net/...
#1.1.1 (Edited 895d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report
mewhy32  +   894d ago
Well there's little doubt that both are superior engines but to say that one or the other is best???? I just don't think that there's enough here to say that yet. Let's see what games developers do and have to say about it. You know, people that actually make games? They're statements about hardware and software are the best informed.
MaxXAttaxX  +   894d ago
I don't trust bullshots from Epic.
Exhibit A:
http://photos.imageevent.co...
Y'all know the rest.

However SOME of these screens seem legit.
#1.1.3 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(2) | Report
ATi_Elite  +   895d ago
1. Frostbite 2
2. Real Virtuality 4 (ArmA 3)
3. 4A Engine
4. CryEngine 3
5. X-Ray Engine (STALKER)
6. RAGE/Euphoria Engine (GTAIV)

For me these are the best game engines! When it comes to PC gaming Photo realism, Scale, and Physics play a big big part in PC Gaming and these Engines are the top 6 best!

The Rage/Euphoria engine from GTAIV has proven to be a Beast when properly tuned/modded for the PC! The amount of things it can do is worthy of this prestigious list!
john2  +   894d ago
Gotta agree. RAGE engine (when moddded) looks phenomenal. GTA IV modded is by far one of the best looking PC games. Would love to see an upgraded version of it with better and proper multi-CPU and multi-GPU support
STONEY4  +   894d ago
I love S.T.A.L.K.E.R, but the X-ray
Engine, even in Call of Pripyat with Complete Mod, ranges from looking extremely good to looking downright awful. The foilage draw distance... ughh. I'm pretty sure there's an .ini edit to change it, but I played through without it. Still, it definitely isn't a top 5 engine.
#1.2.2 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
mep69  +   894d ago
@john2

Rage ? modded ?? modded Rage ???

Rage isn't moddable, as they never realeased mod tools.
Arnon  +   894d ago
@Orpheus
It looks like shit compared to what? You can't just say that it looks like shit without comparing it to something else that would make it look like said shit. It looks a hell of a lot better than anything currently out.
#1.3 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
ChickeyCantor  +   894d ago
That "mountain" you are referring to is the Particle mesh which has a shader to render the dust cloud coming out of the volcano.
#1.4 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
JokesOnYou  +   894d ago
I'm no Super Duper tech analyst but I trust my eyes and those UE4 pics look freak in sick, if next Gen engines will deliver these type of high end graphics I'm in no complaints, ha well I'm a gamer so I'm buying consoles that play great games either way.
Sony360  +   894d ago
I wonder how you were able to see the "polygonal detail" without any wireframe or polygons being displayed in these images?

Unless you are able to tell the difference between normal maps, polygons, and what's tesselated on an object at a distance.

No. You can't.
#1.6 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
WeskerChildReborned  +   895d ago
Either way, i can't wait to see the UE4 demo that's suppose to be at E3.
john2  +   895d ago
Same here. Let's hope that Epic will leak it before E3 :D
WeskerChildReborned  +   895d ago
No way lol, i wan't to wait to see it :P
dorron  +   895d ago
I'm not impressed at all...
h311rais3r  +   895d ago
I'd hate to buy u a present :/
GamingPerson  +   895d ago
This is running on Nvidia gpu!

See the light particles around the eyes?
http://www.dsogaming.com/wp...
http://www.dsogaming.com/wp...

like this.
http://www.youtube.com/watc...
#3.2 (Edited 895d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Sony360  +   894d ago
Don't be so bitter.
#3.3 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
MYSTERIO360  +   895d ago
UE4 when is this going out?
cstyle  +   895d ago
The real reason some of you aren't impressed is that you know that this engine will debut with the next gen xbox and it will look better than anything on PS3 and xbox360. Get over yourself guys, the engine is impressive and will probably blow away your favorite looking game this gen, as it should.
AdmiralSnake  +   895d ago
oh...
cone   894d ago | Spam
Trekster_Gamer  +   895d ago
I just want a new XBOX that can handle either of these engines properly. They both will amaze us all with the right developer!
fucadastates  +   895d ago
come on.. you dont want a new xbox.. you want a new playstation :D im trooooling :S
#6.1 (Edited 895d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
Trekster_Gamer  +   894d ago
Sorry had a PS3 and god rid of it after they kept taking options away.
Backwards compat.
install other OS
fucadastates  +   894d ago
well, had an xbox, but the keep adding adds and want you to pay for free stuff.
2v1  +   894d ago
the ue3 rrod mill of xbox
yabhero  +   894d ago
Rumor is that WiiU is being tweaked to run this *squeal*
CryEngine 3 already confirmed to run smoothly on WiiU
#7 (Edited 894d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
CryWolf  +   894d ago
I believe CryEngine 3 looks a lot better then Next-Gen Unreal Engine graphically its unbelievable realistic compared to Unreal Engine 4.
CoLD FiRE  +   894d ago
I'm not impressed by these pictures at all? I mean they sure do look nice but I expected something much much better. Also, I hope that we don't just get better graphics next gen but better physics and AI too.
modesign  +   894d ago
unreal engine is nothing to be shocked about, im sure the average dev will butcher what ever title they create under UE4.
zero_cool  +   894d ago
Euclideon says hello to epic games,crytek ect...

http://www.youtube.com/user...

http://www.euclideon.com/

Cheers Gamers & Happy Gaming!

Related video
meowthemouse  +   894d ago
The screenies on the right look WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY better! I am worried that UE4 will give same results while demanding more power!
ninjahunter  +   893d ago
Most impressive thing here:
Cryengine 2 particle test
XD then cryengine 3 cut some corners on that type of thing(PHYSICS AND SUCH) to add more shiny.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Splatoon, Yoshi’s Woolly World, Mario Maker, Project Guard, Coming To US First Half Of 2015

6m ago - MNN: "Nintendo has outlined its release schedule for next year. While none of the big games have... | Wii U
30°

Hideki Kamiya: Scalebound Don't Look To Bayonetta Or Metal Gear Rising

6m ago - To feel like we truly wield the power of a fire-breathing sky lizard and eviscerate our enemies i... | Xbox One
10°

PlayDevil: Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor Review

6m ago - PlayDevil has reviewed Shadow of Mordor for PC Here is a snippet: "These living, constantly... | PC
30°

PS4 Dominates Xbox One in Ubisoft Platform Sales Charts

7m ago - As part of Ubisoft's latest earnings report today, the French Assassin's Creed publisher released... | PS4
Ad

Win Outlast and Whistleblower Codes!

Now - It's no trick, Outlast 2 is in the works - and to celebrate Red Barrels has given us Outlast and Whistleblower treats! | Promoted post
30°

AC Unity: does the time anomalies trailer visit WWII?

9m ago - Pixel Dynamo take a look at the latest time anomalies trailer for Assassin's Creed Unity and disc... | PS4