60°
Submitted by Thrallia 1105d ago | opinion piece

New Game + | In defense of the gray moral choice

Disclaimer: No nuns were harmed during the writing of this column.

Perhaps this isn’t necessarily something that needs defending, but now’s as good of a time as any to discuss moral choices in games. They seem to be popping up everywhere these days, especially in games that don’t really need them. They allow for developers to give players multiple endings, but those endings (like the choices that precede them) are usually on complete opposite ends of the spectrum. What if you don’t want to be as good as Superman or the incarnation of evil? (BioShock, BioShock 2, Culture, Infamous, inFamous 2, Mass Effect, Mass Effect 2, Mass Effect 3)

come_at_me_bro  +   1105d ago
I hate blatant moral choices in games. They're never done well, ever. Some games handle them better than others, but I still know the consequences of each choice. It's a real shame that most "gray" moral choices are "do a good thing but lose a good thing" or "do a bad thing and something you don't want to happen, happens".
mistajeff  +   1105d ago
spoilers for the first fallout

I'll admit that I never played fallout 1 and 2 until after 3 got me into the series (which then allowed me to realize what a misfit 3 feels like in the fallout series). When I played the first one, I arrived at junktown, and after talking to some NPC's I realized that the gangster casino owner was basically running the town. Before even talking to the sheriff, I decided I was going to make him extra happy. I walked straight into the boss' office, and shot him and his bodyguard. I reported to the sheriff, expecting a cheery reception, but what I got amounted to "what the fuck are you doing? i'm happy he's gone, but you can't just roll into town and murder someone. we needed to mount a case and gather evidence. you have to leave and never come back."

As someone who didn't get into RPGs until the KOTOR era, this blew my mind. I did the "right" thing, but got a reaction as if it were the "wrong" thing. Then I realized, there wasn't a black and white, a dark side or a light side, just a situation and the way people reacted to how I handled it. After playing other old-school RPGs, it really feels like games have devolved in terms of the spectrum of the choices you have. This is why Witcher 2 was a breath of fresh air for me-- no morality scale, just your choices and the meaningful consequences they bring about.
banjadude  +   1105d ago
Ahhh, yes. The Junktown mission. So many approaches to that, and the consequences and rewards actually differ. I love that game, lol.
#2.1 (Edited 1105d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Thrallia  +   1104d ago
yeah, I'm really hoping that Wasteland 2 brings that type of thing back successfully.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Star Wars Battlefront (3) Exclusive Gameplay Breakdown & Narration

25m ago - This video spoils the contents of the Star Wars Battlefront 3 trailer, and includes details from... | PC
30°

Witchery Minecraft Mod

1h ago - The Witchery Minecraft Mod is a massive addition to Minecraft that basically turns you into a wit... | PC
Ad

See what games are coming out in 2015

Now - Visit our release calendar to see what games are coming out in 2015. | Promoted post
30°

GTA V PC Review | Twinfinite

1h ago - Twinfinite: The arrival of GTA V on PC has been a long time coming. Since its original release o... | PC
20°

Dragon Slash to release in late May

1h ago - Gamevil Japan will release the new smartphone RPG game Dragon Slash in May. | iPhone
20°

Android version of Magallanica Chronicle released today

1h ago - Today, Cover Lab and Fun Click released the Android version of Magallanica Chronicle. | Android