130°
Submitted by PoisonedMonkey 1123d ago | review

Review: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (TheGamingReview.com)

TGR take on the great outdoors, the nasty indoors and the fearsome dragons to take a trek around Bethesda's latest adventure. And by God, it's a good'n. (PC, PS3, The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Xbox 360) 10/10

Avernus  +   1123d ago
I love Skyrim, but it's nowhere near a perfect game. Reviews aren't suppose to be an opinion of the reviewer.
PoisonedMonkey  +   1123d ago
That's EXACTLY what they should be. Saying whether something is any good or not is always going to be an opinion. The guy who reviewed this clearly loved the game and his passion comes through in the review.

Would you rather a review just stated a load of facts and didn't really give you an opinion? Is a game only worthy of a high score if it ticks certain boxes in a pre-written set of criteria?

If everyone reviewed like that, then they wouldn't be worth reading.
D3mons0ul  +   1123d ago
Actually, if reviews were based strictly in the realm of objective, you'd know if a game works or not.

They would review games based on mechanics and functionality, bugs, etc.

In many ways, a world of reviewers like that would be a better one because you wouldnt have obnoxious punks taking shots at games for things they don't like strictly because they don't like them.

Artstyle is subjective

How much you like the story of a game or certain characters, subjective.

Everything outside of whether or not a game actually works is subjective.
Avernus  +   1123d ago
No, I rather a reviewer tell me the facts about a game. Opinions, differ, while facts are facts.

The fact is the PS3 version sucks. Framerate issues, and inferior graphics. Someone with a different opinion to mine might disagree, but it is simply a fact.

@D3mons0ul...I didn't mean to reply to you...actually I agree with what you said.
#1.1.2 (Edited 1123d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
FCOLitsjustagame  +   1123d ago
What is "broke" to one person may not be "broke" to another so its hard do define "facts" even to that point. I mean sure there maybe an objectivly broken quest but some people will say the hand to hand combat is broken or the pathfinding is broken (there was an article that actually complained about this) while others will think they are perfectly fine.

Reviews are opinions. As much as you would like to believe there can be fully facted based reviews that is simply not reality. Preferences will always creep in. Even if its the prefernce of the xbox or PS3 or PC controls.
#1.1.3 (Edited 1123d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
PoisonedMonkey  +   1123d ago
So a review should just be whether there are any bugs? How can gameplay, sound, music, controls, characterisation or any of that be reviewed without it being an opinion?

I know what you're getting at, but it's just not realistic and wouldn't make an enjoyable review to read in my opinion.
ssb3173  +   1123d ago
great game that is worthy of this score, nice

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

12 Minutes of Halo 5: Guardians Multiplayer Beta Menu Music

13m ago - OXCGN: Being apart of the Xbox Dashboard Preview Program on the Xbox One, we alongside hundred... | Xbox One
20°

Dissecting the Amiibo Craze

23m ago - Amiibo have become a hotly contested topic as of late. Their rarity and supposedly inflated value... | Culture
20°

TOP 5 Christmas Gifts For Xbox Fanboys

23m ago - The Tyuno Project: "What’s going on gamers, this is Tyuno The Great! Christmas is just around the... | Xbox 360
Ad

Need Cash? (US Only)

Now - How would it feel to have your money struggles solved by this time tomorrow? We give fast loans from $100-$10,000+, and repayment terms up to 60 mo... | Promoted post
30°

The Overseas Connection Podcast #300

26m ago - The Overseas Connection, the official G4TE (Gaming For The Elderly) Community weekly podcast disc... | PC