Submitted by xtheownerzx 1432d ago | opinion piece

FPS Vs RPG's: Which Genre has the Greatest Games?

GamerFitNation's Gregory Laporte ask gamers which genre has the greatest games? Rpg's or Fps titles? "First Person Shooters are some of the most awe inspiring innovative titles ever created, RPG's are also some of the most time consuming but personally rewarding games in terms of story and combat. This brings us to the article that I am writing about today. FPS titles and RPG's have created waves of new ideas in gaming but, which has really created the greatest games? (Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3, Final Fantasy XIII, Killzone 3, PS3, The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Xbox 360)

Kalowest  +   1432d ago
Nevers  +   1432d ago
RPGs are my pick as well.

I play FPSes sometimes cuz I play videogames... but RPGs are what got me hooked into playing videogames at all.
#1.1 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(14) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Skip_Bayless  +   1432d ago
Life would be boring if one of the genres did not exist, but I must say in the modern day the FPS is dominant. I'm not a relic so I'm not going to back to the PS2,PS1, and SNES to play old games with visuals that don't stand up to today.
solid warlord   1432d ago | Offensive
solid warlord   1432d ago | Offensive
GameTavern  +   1432d ago
I don't think there's any way to really compare which has the better games.

What makes a great FPS isn't the same thing that makes a great RPG and vice versa.
HeavenlySnipes  +   1432d ago
Not really a comparison
at least, that's how I approached the question. I saw it as "Which genre has the best games". My immediate response was RPG because my favourite games ever are RPGs (Chrono Cross and FFXII). Add to that the numerous well received RPGs like The Elder Scrolls, Fallout, most of the Final Fantasies, Dark/Demons Souls, Chrono series, Xenogears etc..
GameTavern  +   1432d ago
You also get a ton of well-regarded FPSes as well.

And more often than not, you get something like Goldeneye, Halo and Modern Warfare which are seen as hallmark games that changed the industry.

For RPGs, I can only really think of Final Fantasy 7.
BitbyDeath  +   1432d ago
Don't forget Elder Scrolls
iamnsuperman  +   1432d ago
I personally not a fan of RPG so I would have to go with FPS even though FPS (to me) hasn't got the best games I have played. Its all about personal choice and preference.

off topic but I like the photo. Looks really good
#3 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
Relientk77  +   1432d ago
RPG's are hands down better than FPS's

Final Fantasy series
Breath of Fire series
Grandia series
Dark Cloud series
Legend of Zelda series
Legend of Dragoon
Rogue Galaxy
Diablo series
Pokemon series
Dragon Quest series
Wild Arms series
Lunar series
Chrono Trigger/Cross
Tactics Ogre
Ogre Battle
The Elder Scrolls series
Brave Fencer Musashi
Star Ocean series
Tales of (series)
Suikoden series
Saga Frontier series
Threads of Fate
Legend of Mana
3D Dot Game Heroes
Valkeria Chronicles
Vagrant Story
#4 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(19) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
xtheownerzx  +   1432d ago
you bring a lot of great titles that I haven't played in years relientk77. There are a lot of great series both past and present my only concern is why haven't we seen such greatness this gen. It seems like FPS titles are catching up in terms of quality and the experiences that they are providing.

There have been several great FPS titles this gen that are better than a lot RPG's this generation.
MariaHelFutura  +   1432d ago
There has been some pretty good RPGs this gen

-Tales Of Vesperia
-Lost Oddessy
-Fallout 3
-Mass Effect 1
-Demon Souls
-Dark Souls
-Final Fantasy Versus (looks to be amazing)
-Deus Ex

Thats pretty good.
Kalowest  +   1432d ago
"It seems like FPS titles are catching up in terms of quality and the experiences that they are providing." Lmao, sorry i just had to laugh.
Nerdmaster  +   1432d ago

I love RPG and hate FPS. But your post made me realize how the RPG genre has fallen this generation. I think the last great RPG I played was Final Fantasy X.
Focus  +   1432d ago
yay, lists
Capt-FuzzyPants  +   1432d ago
You forgot kingdom hearts. But yea rpg's are definitely better then shooters
Pikajew  +   1432d ago
Zelda is not an RPG, it's an action adventure game. Just because they are long doesnt make them an RPG

I like JRPGs, turn based RPGs and some action RPGs. I usually get borde with shooters half way threw

The only shooters I actualy finnish are adventure shooters like Halflife and Metroid Prime
#4.4 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
_Aarix_  +   1432d ago
Zelda has health, currency for items an side quests.. Yea it's an rpg.
Capt-FuzzyPants  +   1432d ago

shooters have health and currency too.those aren't the elements that make up an rpg
_Aarix_  +   1432d ago
Zelda has had all of those before any shooter did. What exactly makes a rpg then that Zelda hasn't had for 30 years. Never mind the fact that that's it's official genre other than a puzzle/action game.
#4.4.3 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
kma2k  +   1432d ago
Im a RPG whore its no comparison for me, but that is IMO its not fact!
Relientk77  +   1432d ago
Same with me. I love RPGs. They truely give you an incredible experience and suck you into a whole fantasy world. It is easily my favorite genre of video games.
thrasherv3  +   1432d ago
They are both good but it's when you combine them that magic happens.
Kalowest  +   1432d ago
Border Lands and Fallout 3 & NV are three game i can think of.
CaptainMarvelQ8  +   1432d ago
That is just ridiculous,RPG's will always be superior to FPS.For me personally what makes a game is a great story,gameplay and freedom...graphics are my least priority providing that the game looks acceptable.While for FPS games,everything is quite the opposite of what I like;Graphics seem to be top priority,then multiplayer(which is the only good thing)and lastly story,that is if there's actually a campaign.The gameplay is the same with very little developers innovating.Run,duck,shoot and repeat.
#7 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Bathyj  +   1432d ago

3rd person adventure games, and user generated content platformers have been the two best games for me.

I said FOR ME.
kma2k  +   1432d ago
Soooooo your favorite game is infamous/uncharted?
Bathyj  +   1432d ago
My FAVOURITE game is probably Tenchu Z on Xbox, but I think the best games are LBP and Uncharted. Infamous is my favourite superhero game.
Chnswdchldrn  +   1432d ago
wow how can you even make such a comparison

on average, RPGs have more great games than the FPS genre, but there doesn't exist an RPG that tops Half Life 2 for me
Focus  +   1432d ago
RPG's. . .more specifically WRPG's.
Kalowest  +   1432d ago
Personally I think JRPG's are better. The best JRPG's this gen are mainly for the Handholds.
Deadman_Senji  +   1432d ago
RPGs, no contest
Tex117  +   1432d ago
What a retarded question.

Some people absolutely LOVE FPS.

Some people absolutely LOVE RPG's.

For me, Im an RPG guy, but that doesn't mean they are the "better games."
VonAlbrecht  +   1432d ago
finally, someone with a fucking brain showed up in here

and someone had the testicular fortitude to disagree with preference being a subjective thing
Tanir  +   1432d ago
well lets see.......FPS's the most milked genre besides sports....vs the takes time to make genre and is actually worth 60$ genre called Rpgs.

these Rpgs have replay value, immersion, customization, and if ur speaking of jrpgs, awesome story, long campaign, fast paced combat (tales, star ocean etc)

theeeeeen FPS's........well ummm, you shoot crap.....shoot stuff, shoot things, play the 2-3 hours SP, then play the copy paste MP that feels the same across all games. I mean FPS mixed with rpg is cool (bioshock, fallout etc)

but just shooters are Meh

long way of saying rpgs ftw
BitbyDeath  +   1432d ago
Pretty much my thoughts as well.

Have a bubble
SDF Repellent  +   1432d ago
RPGs are great but in this generation, tactical RPGs like Final Fantasy tactic or Shining Force are no where to be found.

I will sell my first born to have a new Shining Force 4 or a HD remake of all three shining force 3 scenarios.
#14 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
TheColbertinator  +   1432d ago
Try out Jeanne D'Arc,Sakura Wars:So Long My Love and if you have not tried out yet,I strongly recommend Valkyria Chronicles 1 and 2.
admiralthrawn87  +   1432d ago
adventure shooters like Half-Life, Halo, Bioshock, Doom 3?
or mindless 4 hour long shooters like COD, Battlefield?

those are two different genre's to me
VampiricDragon  +   1432d ago
its not even close

rpgs by a mile

theres been hundreds of good ones this gen on all systems
TheColbertinator  +   1432d ago
Some FPS games have the brilliance of RPGs like bioshock,Half-Life,Deus Ex,and Mirrors Edge.

Most FPS games are devoid of quality unfortunately.

JRPG and WRPG games on the other hand are brilliant.The characters,the music,the art and the stories are definitions of high quality gaming.
BitbyDeath  +   1432d ago
Whether you like them or not you gotta admit that RPG's are a lot more diverse in what they offer. You get JRPG's, WRPG's and the inbetween mixes.

Where as shooters are generally the same. Some may come with destruction, added gore or a series of crazy weapons but none of that really changes the game unlike an RPG which doesn't always have guns or even the same view type (text based, overhead, 3PS, side scroller etc). Which changing those up can also lead to a lot more variety in story and missions.

RPG's should win by default IMO
#18 (Edited 1432d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Sharingan_no_Kakashi  +   1432d ago
Rpg's.... duh.
swishersweets20031  +   1432d ago
i think rpgs were king 10 years ago but now days i just cant get into them anymore.. :(

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Why 2K chose New Orleans for Mafia 3, plus four Districts and Music discussed

4m ago - Games have a way of bringing to life a time and place like no other media can, and in the upcomi... | PC

5 Amazing Free-To-Play Online Games

7m ago - Gaming can be an expensive proposition, whether we're talking about upgrading your PC to meet the... | PC

MoreConsole takes on Destiny: The Taken King

Now - MoreConsole's rag-tag band of guardians finally make it to the Oryx's ship...but can they make it out alive? | Promoted post

Dark Souls III PS4 Beta Client Goes Up on PSN, Then Gets Pulled Down

10m ago - A little earlier today the Dark Souls III PS4 beta client went live on the PSN. It was a little s... | PS4

How Battlefront gets Star Wars right

14m ago - VideoGamer: "Star Wars Battlefront has its share of problems, but it nails the appeal of the fran... | PC

In Memoriam: 10 Best Legendary Weapons in Year One Destiny

15m ago - September 15th was a sad day for the hardcore year one Destiny player. It was the day that hundre... | Xbox 360
Related content from friends