Battlefield 3 review (HonestGamers)

Tom Chick writes: "More than any other graphics engine today, it's a complete package, featuring scale, scope, spectacle, on-foot detail and in-airplane elbow room, multiplayer, meaningful destruction, and absurdly good animation. Absurdly good. The animation is so good you probably won't even notice it. Of course the characters move this way because that's how real dudes move. What's the big deal? You almost have to go back to another game with the usual animation to appreciate what Battlefield 3 does." 8/10

[Hufandpuf]

great review, but he didn't really make the bad parts about the game clear, other than the single player was bad.

[TooTall19]

Operation Metro in Conquest is possibly the worst map design I have ever experienced. Other than that map the game is a blast. The gun play is spot on.

[ECM0NEY]

Metro large conquest is the perfect map to jack your score and K/D up.

[Hockeydud19]

LOL , so Mr. Chick. Battlefield 3 is an 8 out of 10 and Uncharted 3 is a 4 out of town. That right there proves his reviews are all based on opinion. In no way am I saying Battlefield 3 is a bad game. An 8 out of 10 is a fine score.

[xPhearR3dx]

A review is an opinion? ZOMG when did that start happening?

[achmetha]

should be an educated opinion though and have some objectivity to support his claims. you learn it in like 6th grade.

[Hockeydud19]

That's my point bud. They shouldn't be based on opinion. When I read a review I want to know if it's a quality product. Smartass

[xPhearR3dx]

Ahh but your not bitching about his review, you're bitching about his score. The score is irrelevant, the written part is what matters. Every time a review is bashed and fanboys cry, they never bitch about what the author wrote, they skip to the end, see the score and cry.

[wastedcells]

This guys a joke
I never talk shit about reviews or reviewers but this guys no gamer.
4/10 for uncharted ? I love battlefield but I would never score it higher then U3

[Hufandpuf]

So the multiplayer in U3 is TECHNICALLY better than BF3? BF3 offers Co-Op, what about U3? U3 beats BF3 in campaign, but in staying power BF3 lasts longer. 100 hours to max out EACH class. That's 400 hours just to complete the unlocks, not counting the unlocks in Co-Op or the Karkand expansion.

In no way am I saying BF3 is better, or U3 is worse. It's all personal opinion between us. But on a technical side, there has to be a winner.

[MysticStrummer]

Yes UC3 has online and splitscreen co-op. Like BF3, it's not through the main story but has it's own levels. Not sure if you can be playing splitscreen and online at the same time. Which game has more staying power has more to do with how much fun it is than how long it takes to unlock everything. I'm not sure I'll be playing either game long enough to do that. Meanwhile, I still play MAG even though I've gone through all three PMCs and can't unlock anything but trophies, which I don't care about at all. I doubt I'll be playing either UC3 or BF3 long enough to equal my MAG time. Lowest reviewed of the three? MAG. *shrug*

[Hufandpuf]

@Mystic

You have my respect. good points.

[MysticStrummer]

"Tom Chick writes:" That's as far as I got. I already know the guy's opinion on videogames can't be trusted so why bother reading on?