Submitted by bubs78 1405d ago | review

Bone-idle.ie : Battlefield 3 Review

Bone-idle.ie writes "But what we get is something on par with the mindless nonsense that was Black ops, with a ridiculous, often boring and extremely liner story mode, in the first few hours I think my vehicle was blown up by an RPG 3 times and I had a building fall on me yet managed to survive it all. It fell into the same trap of trying to recreate “moments” rather than a “game”. Large sections of cut scenes or QTE break up the gun play and this just takes you out of the experience." (Battlefield 3, PC, PS3, Xbox 360) 7.5/10

superfranky  +   1405d ago
stupid review, stupid reviewer
he doesnt get his God of War in BF3 and gave it a 7
iamnsuperman  +   1405d ago
Dissagre. "he doesnt get his God of War in BF3 and gave it a 7".

No he gave it a 7.5 because it has a bad single player experience that is more about moments than an in depth story a long with bugs that made him battle "the game" not battle "within the game"

"The score is perhaps lower than others have given BF3 but we felt we had to review the full package and not just the online"

I applaud the review for this. A review should be about the package as a whole not one part of it (which a lot of reviews for big publications have done). His justification for the score is very reasonable. 9 for multiplayer, 6 for single player. 7.5 total.
#1.1 (Edited 1405d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Pintheshadows  +   1405d ago
Amen brother.
bubs78  +   1405d ago
Well said, it seems anything under a 9 is the reviewers fault not the games !
superfranky  +   1404d ago
By your logic iamnsuperman, MAG should have got 5's across the board...same with Socom: Confrontation, why you ask? They don't even HAVE a complete package, $60 games that only had multiplayer.
Or let's talk about Dead Space 2 and Bioshock 2, good single player, but a tacked on multiplayer, so that means regardless of the campaign, we have to review the whole package, so let's see, that's a 7.5 TOPS for those two games.
bubs78  +   1404d ago
mag is sold as a online only game so you review the online only. bioshock 2 should take both into consideration and the fact its single player was a bit of a let down too.
fluffydelusions  +   1405d ago
Horrible review. Great game!
NuclearDuke  +   1405d ago
How is the review horrible for being honest?

If you take a look at ANY review that is 9.0 or above, they only review the multiplayer. They dismiss reviewing the singleplayer because they do not feel its a true battlefield component.

This review takes in the ENTIRE package and gives an overall score on the title. Battlefield 3.

Big kudos to the reviewer for being honest!
Clayman  +   1405d ago
It will be interesting to see if certain other modern military shooters will also be downgraded because of the dull SP or if they will just get a free ticket to GOTY right away.
josephps3  +   1405d ago
Battlefield3 was a little rushed to compete with MW3. Another few months would have done wonders. I'll wait for the Bad Company using the Frostbite 2 engine to come out. I'm guessing it will be all that Battlefield3 could and should have been-better SP, less glitches, better visuals throughout and there may even be BOTS.

I think Bots would be invaluable in the console version since there is less players. I'd love to hook up with 6 friends and have lots of bots fill in the gap to have a hectic real battlefield experience without annoying strangers. That would be a real fun battlefield party.
Ocean  +   1405d ago
Folks...could any early adopters of BF3 check this out and see if they have had the same problems?


Its on the EA forums as well

Pintheshadows  +   1404d ago
Oh dear. That isn't good.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Review: There's nothing epic about Gryphon Knight Epic | GameCrate

17m ago - GameCrate: "In the four hours it took me to get through Gryphon Knight Epic, all I could think ab... | PC

Finally, an official Hearthstone credit card that lets you earn more free card packs

18m ago - An official Hearthstone credit card is finally coming... to China. This is real. I kid you no... | PC

The Xbox One Games You Need to Play in August

Now - A new month has rolled up which means new releases are on the horizon. Microsoft has a fairly good line-up on the way for August, so let’s take a l... | Promoted post

Bungie Talks about Decision to Change Destiny Quest System

18m ago - "Among many other things new to Destiny: The Taken King is not having to go to the Tower to turn... | Xbox 360

Until Dawn Review | Blast Process

18m ago - "A year after a cruel teenage prank went horrifically wrong, 8 friends end up spending the night... | PS4

10 Most Popular Games in Korea That You’ll Get Hooked On

24m ago - South Korea has one of biggest gaming industries in the world, it’s no surprise they make some of... | PC